Where is the best place to supersample? Tray tool, Steam or in-game?
I've always used the tray tool unless there is an in-game option.
Anyone with more time tested out each method? Does either offer better performance?
Posted Apr 7, 2018, 7:28 AM UTC
For interests sake and to try get some kind of data rather than rely on notoriously poor human memories, perceptions, and biases I made some comparison screens. :)
Each screen shows the same scene with the SS value set either by the game, SteamVR, or Oculus.
Keep in mind there are slight differences due to minor headset wobble (it's very sensitive!) and small time differences in taking each shot.
And as you will see from the Left/Right Viewport stat, each method does request a slightly different render resolution (likely due to conversion errors in the scales used)!
Considering that, the screens look to be of identical quality to me.
I used cubeupload to try keep it lossless. Make sure to click the '+' when hovering over each pic to zoom to 1:1.
Default game with no supersampling: http://i.cubeupload.com/XK4BDx.png
Set to 2x in the SkyrimPrefs.ini: http://i.cubeupload.com/QMyLCO.png
Set to 200% in SteamVR: http://i.cubeupload.com/wuU028.png
Set to 1.43 in the Oculus Debug Tool: http://i.cubeupload.com/u1Ue5o.png
(sorry, I don't know how to embed pics here)
Thanks for taking the time to do this. I remember some guy in the Fallout 4 VR sub was so sure that the two SS methods were different that he spent days trying out different combinations and made a post with random descriptors for each one like muddy vs soupy or sharp vs crisp. I pointed out how scientifically useless it all was and how a single screenshot would settle everything but he ignored me and I was too lazy to prove it to him.
No problem!
I wish I'd locked the headset down somehow to stop the wobbles, and maybe tweaked the numbers a bit to try get the render resolutions identical, but I think it shows well enough that there's no real difference wherever you choose to set the SS.
Which makes total sense to me, since they're all just different places to set the same thing (render scale). Those claiming big differences should be the ones posting the proof.
Regarding Fallout 4 VR, I guess it's possible Bethesda wrote some custom supersampling option for that rather than just set render scale... but given how it's an even lazier port than Skyrim I'd wager they took the easiest option. ;)
This is great thanks for doing that.
There is a second question that arises... how was the actual gameplay performance with each setting? Did you notice more frame drops etc with any of them...?
I didn't actually play with any of them enabled, as I was trying to keep the headset in the exact same spot/orientation for each shot. Even if I did, I'd want to try get proper data and not rely on feel. :)
However, I highly doubt there is any difference since all you're doing with any of these three methods is setting the resolution that the game is rendering at internally. The actual rendering is done the same way regardless.