Have you ever had to kick someone off your team? (Not $ Related)

I have this person on my team who's been playing pool for over 20 years and is still a 3 - sometimes a 2 (the lowest handicap). A couple teammates and I are getting pretty tired of carrying this person and I decided to kick them off after this league is over. Got any tips on being less of a dick about it?

Posted Apr 9, 2018, 3:42 PM UTC

745
Revzerksies•

I was a 7 on a APA 8 Ball team and had to leave the team. The rest of the drinking team was a 4 or 5 and pool was effecting their drinking time.

10
ThorsGrundle•

For most people this is what APA is. You sound bitter about it, but there are plenty of players out there who want to improve. Should start up your own team and get those type of players on your team

1
Revzerksies•

I wanted to play pool, Go to Vegas. They cried like little girls all the time.

1
NotYourNewMan•

I’ve met my mirror opposite! I was a SL6 that topped the MVP list every session for almost 2 years, showed up EVERY night even if I wasn’t going to play, I got kicked off the team run by a group of 4’s because I drank and none of them did. In hindsight the religious team name should have been a red flag. Ruined APA for me and pushed me to BCA. I just wanted to go to Vegas and have a couple beers.

2
thepottsyMcDermott GS12C Oct 2013 Cue of the month•

Which league? At least in APA, it's helpful to have a lower ranked player.

8
8BallRunOutOPTAP / Predator 314-2•

It's TAP - similar to APA. We have 3 3's, so I actually struggle to play them on a given night.

3
thepottsyMcDermott GS12C Oct 2013 Cue of the month•

Is there another team that could use a lower rank?, maybe you could negotiate a player swap.

3
8BallRunOutOPTAP / Predator 314-2•

Oh, that's a good idea! She doesn't have a great reputation at league, but it's worth a shot.

2
thepottsyMcDermott GS12C Oct 2013 Cue of the month•

That could potentially be a problem, but you never know.

I've seen it work in the past. We've had teams that ended up with to many high ranks, having to split their teams up.

1
dalgeekDFW - APA 8/9 Ball - Players/Z2•

I've kicked people off my team mostly for not showing up. It's pretty easy to do because I let people know ahead of time what the rules are for attendance.

I kicked a 6 off my team because he wanted me to tell him days in advance whether he would be playing, which isn't possible when I don't know who will show up for the other team or who will play. If I didn't tell him in advance then he wouldn't show up, and if he showed up and didn't play then he would get all pissy.

I wouldn't kick a low ranked player off the team unless they showed no interest in trying to win and they wouldn't listen to advice, especially in a handicap league. One session I ended up with a 7 and two 6's on my team, so it was difficult to make numbers without a bunch of 3's. They should be winning at least half the time against opponents at their skill level, but if they keep getting swept 3-0 then it sounds like a motivation issue that needs to be corrected.

As for not being a dick about it, as long as you're up front about the situation and follow through on what you say then they have no right to be upset. Even though it's an amateur pool league and there isn't much money involved, your teammates expect and deserve everyone else on the team to at least try. Give them drills, spend some time coaching them, but if they don't seem interested in improving then cut them loose.

7
thepottsyMcDermott GS12C Oct 2013 Cue of the month•

he wanted me to tell him days in advance whether he would be playing

I hate when people do that. I hate being asked the night of league, since I don't have control of who the other team is going to play.

2
8BallRunOutOPTAP / Predator 314-2•

your teammates expect and deserve everyone else on the team to at least try

That's a great point. I Just can't get over the fact that she's been playing for over 20 years and hasn't got any better. I'm pretty convinced she isn't trying.

2
dalgeekDFW - APA 8/9 Ball - Players/Z2•

I know people who have been the same skill level forever, but it's OK because they play their skill level well. Handicaps are setup so that every player has an equal chance of winning any match up. It really comes down to reliability: can you expect them to do their part when the time comes? If you guys make it to playoffs or beyond, are they going to try or just tank when it comes down to the wire?

1
moar_distractions•

This is a weird question. If I liked playing with someone and I didn't have to even use them week to week I'd never consider kicking them off the team. But I guess it depends how long/well you know them.

If someone is a 3 and they aren't winning half their games, they should be a two. That's how handicapping works. Maybe talk to the commissioner?

4
8BallRunOutOPTAP / Predator 314-2•

Most of the team doesn't enjoy playing with her. She was friends with the old captain who left to play elsewhere, so I 'inherited' the team and I think it's time for a shake-up.

Well, it's weird with the handicap... She only gets 1 or 2 match wins in a league (out of 8 to 10 matches) and if she does drop to a 2, it's only for a week, then she's up to a 3. I think that's just how the algorithm works. I mean, a 2 is reserved for absolute beginner's no?

2
thepottsyMcDermott GS12C Oct 2013 Cue of the month•

I mean, a 2 is reserved for absolute beginner's no?

No, not really. It's just a rank, some players will just never move any farther up. There is a woman that plays on our 9-ball league, that has been playing for years, and bounce between a 1 and a 2 ranking. She tries, she really does, she just never gets any better.

3
moar_distractions•

That sounds like a problem with the algorithm (I stopped playing in leagues that have one). If you're only winning once or twice you should absolutely be a 2. There are "pure 2s" in leagues that just don't win. Ideally they should be matched up against the lowest skill players from the other team as much as possible. I've also noticed that sometimes women players just get flustered/intimidated against guys, especially when they think they're going to lose anyway. So you may want to match her up with women if possible. Part of the fun of pool leagues is everyone having a chance. You may want to consider trying to arrange these kinds of matches with the other captains. I'm not exactly the out for blood type though.

Most of the time on teams I've been on our subs only play like 4 times or whatever the minimum is to shoot in playoffs. It seems like you feel for her a little at least, maybe see if she wants to consider asking about playing on another team who wants to play her all the time otherwise she can stay on and shoot less?

1
dalgeekDFW - APA 8/9 Ball - Players/Z2•

If you're only winning once or twice you should absolutely be a 2.

Not really, because your losses count towards your handicap as well. If you lose consistently with fewer than 10 innings per game then you could be a 3. If you lost 100% of your games at more than 10 innings per game then you would be a 2. However, if you win over 50% of your games then you'll be a 3 regardless of how many innings you have during your wins or losses.

1
moar_distractions•

I'd never play in a league with innings. It's bs especially for a 2.

1
dalgeekDFW - APA 8/9 Ball - Players/Z2•

She only gets 1 or 2 match wins in a league (out of 8 to 10 matches) and if she does drop to a 2, it's only for a week, then she's up to a 3. I think that's just how the algorithm works. I mean, a 2 is reserved for absolute beginner's no?

Because your losses count towards your handicap. If you "lose well", i.e. with low innings, then you can still maintain a higher skill level. If you lose with high innings then your skill level will drop.

1
CreeDoroflFargo $5.98~•

We've booted people off for not showing, but it didn't really matter because there's no practical difference between "they quit" vs. "they got fired". They weren't showing up before they getting booted, and they continued not showing up afterwards.

Remember that in APA, rank is 100% irrelevant, what you need to care about is win rate. The system is designed to push everyone towards a 50% win rate.

So if your POS useless 3 gets ranked as a 2, and wins a little more often than a "true 2" would, they are valuable, even though it's shameful that they haven't improved in 20 years. If they win 55% they're valuable. If they win 50% they're acceptable. If they win 30-40%... yeah, that's deadweight.

I have a developed a FOOLPROOF way to get rid of any player without hurt feelings.

What you do is tell them "hey man, I've decided I'm gonna go with another team this session, thought I'd let you know, was great shooting with you though."

Then you have someone else on your team go up to them and say "hey man, I've decided I'm gonna go with another team this session, thought I'd let you know, was great shooting with you though."

Repeat this until there's only one person left on the team. Meanwhile you and your buddies form a new team that is very similar to the old one, except one minor difference.

4
kavoul•

Lol, that foolproof method. They won't even so what's coming.

2
arcline111Blak3-1 Revo 12.4/BK3/Bullet/ 9,10, Lives in Mexico•

Laughed out loud at your solution. Genius :)

2
8BallRunOutOPTAP / Predator 314-2•

Lmfao, brilliant.

I think I'm just gonna tell her I'm more serious about winning than the last captain and want to try out a different team. If she gets upset then so be it.

1
CreeDoroflFargo $5.98~•

man that's way too honest. She's gonna cry, I guarantee it. I would tell her everyone decided to take a break this session. Then have everyone hide in the bathroom on the first day until it's too late and she's signed up somewhere else. If you're lucky, she won't show up.

1
8BallRunOutOPTAP / Predator 314-2•

I dont even know anymore.

FUCK IT, WE'LL DO IT LIVE!

3
rxmxsh•

We've done it. She was awful, but thought she was great. Additionally, she wouldn't listen to coaching. At the end of the season, we told her she was no longer on the team b/c she wasn't coachable. She found another team and is still just as bad.

3
afflaqRaleigh, NC - Klapp Custom•

In the past when I ran teams, I was running 5-7 teams and DR’ing as well when I was sucked into the APA umbrella. I’ve kicked people off bluntly and tried to sugar coat it, doesn’t really matter either way. “We’re trying to bump the overall skill level of the team so we don’t have room for you next session, but we can try to help find you a team” usually did the trick.

Just don’t kick them off mid session, that’s bad form.

3
ThorsGrundle•

This is the most sensible answer in this entire thread. If you're running a team, chances are you interact with the other captains far more than your other players. Try to supplement your kicking them from the team by letting other captains know they've become available and are actively looking for a team to join. In my experience, albeit only a year in APA so far, teams form and break often every session, and people come and go on teams. There's always an opening, especially for a 3. Help them finding a new team, so they don't other out of apa.

1
afflaqRaleigh, NC - Klapp Custom•

Yea no shit I wish I was a 3, finding a team as a 3 is joke level easy, no matter how horrible you are as a person.

2
ThorsGrundle•

Forreal

1
Cramman67•

I’ve kicked off one of my good friends from my team. This person would come in drunk and/or high and at times couldn’t even hit an unobstructed object ball, just misses entirely and gives ball in hand. I could tell the atmosphere from the rest of my team that this kind of behavior wasn’t preferred. I asked that he come and play his match sober then he can get lit, but after a month, no change. I kicked him and unfortunately we aren’t much of friends anymore, but that’s the burden of leadership. Gotta put aside your personal wants for the good of the team.

2
Vinalone•

Had to ask a 5 to leave who was a core member of the team because he couldn’t function at higher level tournaments, just started playing like crap as soon as the lights came on. As a result of that move one of my fours quit who was a head case anyway, Pool nights are just so much more chill now I had no idea how much if my patience the four was taking...

2
nsfyn55Philly - Predator 8K-3/Z2 - Zan Premium Soft•

ooof I don't know man. I'd be cautious about kicking a player off the team for reasons other than attendance or other problematic behavior. Its supposed to be for fun. Feels wrong to me.

2
NotYourNewMan•

Cost of shipping to Texas? I need a 2!

Seriously, my best option for getting rid of players has been trying to trade people with other teams. That works 80ish% of the time. The other 20ish% I’ve just had to say, “I have to do what’s best for the team to win (insert regionals/state/nationals).” It sucks, but it’s a team, not a social club (at least the teams I play on), we may all be friends, but we are all playing to win, not to just hang out together.

2
polishgravyJoss East•

I had to suspend a player who eventually quit for sandbagging. I have never heard of dropping a player for being low rank. 2s and 3s are in much higher demand then 6s or 7s. Maybe trade him to another team.

1
blue_27•

Your team chemistry is of paramount importance. I've seen Captains kicked off of teams before.

It sounds like she isn't trying to improve. I usually tell my players that we're there to have fun, but, we're also there to win. I don't mind losses when there is clear effort. But, if someone is always too drunk to play, or gives up after the first time they get pinned by a safety, then they are not a good fit for my team.

How to be less of a dick about it? "Hey, thanks for last season, but, we are going in a different direction." aka "Uhh, Coach wants to see you. He said to bring your playbook ..."

1
bored3227•

I had to ask a player to leave the team a few years back. It was difficult. She was a SL2 who we picked up to offset a SL7 we had on our team. I don't think she had much interest in playing. She was friends of one of the players girlfriends and didn't have anything else going on Monday nights. Over the course of 3 sessions she only won one match and that was due to her opponent scratching on the 8 twice.

The rest of the team was really strong (good 4's and 5's) and she was a liability. She was almost guaranteed a 0-3 loss while our SL7 (who was really good) was not guaranteed a 3-0 win so it impacted the rest of the team.

The blow was softened when I explained to her that I was getting rid of the 7 to try to balance out our roster.

Still wasn't easy.

1
Hydris•

I wouldn’t be too upset about it. A seasoned 2-3 that doesn’t move up. In APA that players gonna have no problem finding a new team. Those are like gold.

Anyway, I’ve kicked people off got personality and because of skill level. Gotta have a team that can make numbers.

1
RoadHustler•

I like my teammates to be responsible adults I need them to show up before I need them or let me know ahead of time. I would prefer they don't start drinking till after they play. I actually don't care how they play. I will teach them that part so I prefer beginners or other teams rejects and much older players. So yea I have kicked off lots of players. This season I joined a team that needed some help. I got rid of the team captain for non payment and another guy who couldn't show up couldn't play and freaked out when he lost lol. He was a peach lol. Next season I am keeping 4 of the remaining 6 and recruiting a few beginners.

1