What reign of Voldemort do you consider to be more deadly?

Discussion

When I think about Voldemort and all the horrible things he did in his life, I break it up into two separate reigns of terror. The pre Harry era and the Harry era we read in the books. The question I’m asking is which of those two reigns was overall more deadly, destructive, terrifying, whatever you want to call it. I feel a case could be made for either side. Personally speaking I fall into the pre Harry era. This was the era when Voldemort rose to power and became one of the worlds most famous (or infamous) wizards. Establishing a fear of his name, becoming all powerful, and creating horcruxes are all valid arguments. I’m curious to hear if anybody disagrees or perhaps agrees but has further points to add.

Posted Apr 11, 2018, 7:39 PM UTC

28
EngineerBabe'I think we should all want to be Hufflepuffs'•

His first reign was significantly longer (over 10 years) and more deadly.

However, a lot of what happened in the first war was more clandestine operations on both sides and skirmishes. No real 'Battles' per say so I don't think there were single events in the first war that were as deadly as the Battle of Hogwarts, at least not that I know of.


Quaffle Caught!

  • GAME A u/dawnphoenix of Ravenclaw ~ 1 Point(s) to Ravenclaw!

  • GAME B u/Rysler of Hufflepuff ~ 1 Point(s) to Hufflepuff!

WHAT'S THIS? READ MORE HERE

CURRENT SCORES | GAME A - Ravenclaw: 5 Slytherin: 1 | GAME B - Gryffindor: 0 Hufflepuff: 5 | "

6
WorriedLettuce•

I think Harry era is worse. Once he succeeded in taking the Ministry he had carte blanche to lockup and/or kill off muggleborns in higher numbers and torture became common place in Hogwarts. Pre Harry era had Dumbledore to still keep Voldemort in check so casualties were kept down somewhat. Once he had the Ministry he had resources and manpower freed up to reallocate as well as Ministry resources added in to transform Wizarding Britain into a really shitty place to live.

5
[deleted]•

[deleted]

1
MerkedJsOP•

I do like the idea of Dumbledore almost watching over Voldemort while he was still alive. However I always felt that Harry took over as that Dumbledore figure. After all, Harry was the one who ultimately took down Voldemort.

1
dilqncho•

Harry took down Voldemort due to plot, and was only dangerous to Voldemort himself- he was still very vulnerable to Death Eaters etc. Until the last second, Harry didn't even know if he can stand up to Voldy, and was hiding in tents and getting captured while Voldemort was having fun taking over the entire country. Comparison- while Dumbledore was alive, he was chilling in Hogwarts while Voldemort and his followers were scurrying around lying low not daring an open assault. Only after Dumbledore's death did the Death Eaters dare openly assault The Ministry and Hogwarts.

Harry managed to take down Voldemort, yes, due to a plethora of intertwining factors- including his own qualities, I'm not denying that. The Horcrux hunt isn't something anyone could've handled. But he was never the powerhouse that Albus was and never had nearly as much to do with keeping Voldemort in check.

4
WorriedLettuce•

Harry was a threat in a different way than Dumbledore. Voldemort was afraid of him because a prophecy said he would be a threat to him and then Voldemort found that they were connect via a mind link as well as by their wands, he didn't understand these connections and he didn't understand Harry. Although you're right that Harry replaced Dumbledore as symbol around which to rally for the good guys.

Dumbledore was a threat to Voldemort personally because he was a skilled and powerful duelist that could possibly 'kill' him, he was also a threat politically both in Britain and internationally as he was Chief Warlock and a representative to the ICW, he was also a military leader in that he created the Order of the Phoenix and coordinated the fight against Voldemort on a large scale.

Harry can lead individual battles but Dumbledore ran wars. After Dumbledore died Harry concentrated solely on destroying the horcruxes and essentially assassinating Voldemort, he didn't have the time or the ability to do as much to manage damage control. It's not a coincidence that the Ministry fell mere months after Dumbledore died.

Anyway once Voldemort had control of Britain, the country was practically his playground, so I'm still of the opinion he was doing more damage then than when he had to concentrate his efforts on taking over.

2
camurinho•

"He did great things; terrible, but great."

4
AmEndevomTag•

We can't say for sure. The first reign was longer, but in the second he actually was in power and could kill more people in a short timespan.

The only hint we have is in Trelawney's second prophecy, where she said that afte rhis servant rejoined him, Voldemort will become more terrible than ever. That suggests his second reign was worse.

2
[deleted]•

[deleted]

1
David-89•

I hope that one day we'll see a movie about Voldemort first war.

1