What is the most specific and stable DNA-protein interaction you know of?

question

I'm interested in a system in which a given piece of DNA is "tagged" using a sequence motif specific for a protein binding partner with a high k_on, low k_off rate and high specificity (in vitro). DNA hybridization isn't an option.

What would be the most specific, and most stable DNA-protein interaction you know of?

Thanks in advance for any suggestions.

edit: Thanks to everyone who replied already! This was really helpful.

Posted Apr 13, 2018, 10:21 PM UTC · edited

1918
Penoir4UPhD•

Its not the most specific or stable, but it is a good place to start. The birthplace of modern inducible synthetic biology: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Lac_repressor (so long as lactose is not present).

If that is not sufficient I would look at other repressor-operon pairs that have tighter regulation. The good thing with repressor proteins is you can often make them release the DNA by adding whatever small molecule they are specific for.

10
lemrezOP•

Yeah, I've been considering the lac system, but I was interested if there is anything even more stable. Was hoping to crowdsource a little. Wouldn't be so interested in releasing them, but rather just specifically binding a DNA of interest.

3
Symander•

So specific and stable are two sides of the same coin. The more stable you get often the more “off-target” you see. A few systems get around this. Cas9 (or other crispr complexes) is one. cro and lac repressors get there a little with cooperativity on tandem operators. But honestly they’re not really as stable as reported outside of a narrow buffer condition range. There’s those forgotten talen proteins also. The most stable single protein that can also be coerced into specificity I have ever worked with is ecor1. There’s a mutant that is inactive and binds in the low femtomolar range a shade better than biotin streptavidin.

Good luck.

10
HandyAndy•

Wow, had no idea there were stronger non-covalent interactions than the much touted biotin-streptavidin. This a DNA-protein interaction? I'm assuming you're referring to the restriction enzyme EcoRI...

3
lemrezOP•

Ah this sounds interesting, but EcoRI's binding motif is sort of ubiquitous due to its short length. I guess I'd have to try to find out if it would work. Thanks a lot for the suggestion! (also to u/voynich who suggested the same)

1
voynich•

EcoRI Gln-111 mutant

The negative charge of Glu-111 is required to activate the cleavage center of EcoRI endonuclease J Biol Chem. 1989 Jul 15;264(20):11816-21.

9
mvpetri•

Histones interact very well with DNA, although they are not code specific I guess.

But you could look into some transcription factors. Some might interact strongly with DNA

5
gpcr_monkey•

Tus-Ter binding. K_d ~ 1e-13 M, k_on ~ 1e8 /M/s, k_off ~ 1e-5 /s. For reference, biotin-streptavidin has a K_d of ~1e-14 M.

http://www.jbc.org/content/267/11/7434.full.pdf

http://www.jbc.org/content/272/42/26448.full.pdf

5
lemrezOP•

This sounds perfect. I'm impressed that there are interactions that strong. This one has the added benefit of being 23 bp in size, so just at the limit of being unique in a totally random genome of typical size.

Thanks a lot!

2
chemicalcloud•

Not protein but check out Peter Dervan's work with specific DNA-binding oligomers.

4

Restriction endonucleases attach to only specific nucleotide sequences that vary in length. Some of the most useful longer ones code to specific ten base pair sequences and thus are usually unique to one site within whatever DNA fragment you’re dealing with. This is the most intense biological specificity I can think of, for instance you have a 1/4^20 chance of having two of the same 10-base pair coding endonuclease sequences in a DNA fragment, and these proteins only attach to that exact (usually palindromic) sequence.

2
lemrezOP•

An EcoRI mutant has been suggested by a couple of people in this thread, but I'd be anxious that it would be pretty unspecific in a mix of genomic DNA due to the short recognition sequence.

Looking up restriction enzymes with a longer motif is definitely a good idea though. It makes total sense, that they'd be pretty good at binding DNA.

2
CallMeD3conBlues•

It would be worth looking into the dna binding region of histones or nucleosomes, though they typically bind relatively larger stretches of dna. But their interaction is very high affinity.

1
lemrezOP•

But their interaction is very high affinity.

Unfortunately, in my experience they are pretty strongly affected by detergents (at least I tend to loose them with my current preps). Would definitely be a possibility, but I'd have to optimize a lot probably.

1
nmrt95•

Maybe the TAL effector region of TALE nucleases.

1
lemrezOP•

I heard it can be quite arduous to clone TALENS repeats with a reasonable sequence specificity though. Definitely going to keep that in mind though. Thanks!

3
king-prawn•

Can we label the DNA? If so, synthesise the target DNA with an NTP conjugated to biotin (eg by PCR), or add a 5' Biotin on your oligo. Use strepavidin as the partner molecule. Specific. Strong. Stable. This strategy commonly used for magnetic tweezers, where direct force is then applied.

You could also use pretty much anything that can be conjugated to an NTP and an antibody for that as the partner.

1
lemrezOP•

No, unfortunately not. The goal is to pull out DNA (plasmid vectors) from mildly lysed cells with native structures attached to the vectors. So it has to be specific for a binding site. Standard biochemical methods wouldn't work as the actual ultrastructure has to be preserved (I'm a structural biologist).

1