SeweragesOfTheMind•

I’m very confused why anyone would still use SourceForge. It’s trash.

44
Booty_Bumping•

A while back they got bought out and immediately promised no more malware bundling, ever. So at least they're not evil anymore.

But yeah, still a pretty damned inferior service.

25
zfundamental•

Pre-existing momentum, a different feature set for issue tracking (generally superior IMO), integrated mailing lists, better access control systems, more complex/more-featured project web hosting, better project statistics, better organized file downloads, etc.

From a management and IT maintenance standpoint sourceforge has done a ton wrong, but from a technical standpoint of the feature that they offer, there's a bunch of good.

10
[deleted]•

[deleted]

2
zfundamental•

It would also be great if github didn't limit statistics to only the most recent week. Perhaps there's some way of getting around this using one of their APIs, but sourceforge at least gives you download stats (for all files or for individual ones) going back years (publicly viewable last I checked). Sourceforge used to provide project-web statistics as well, though I'm guessing they deprecated that infrastructure with the rise of other options such as google analytics.

4

Hey, zfundamental, just a quick heads-up:
publically is actually spelled publicly. You can remember it by ends with –cly.
Have a nice day!

^^^^The ^^^^parent ^^^^commenter ^^^^can ^^^^reply ^^^^with ^^^^'delete' ^^^^to ^^^^delete ^^^^this ^^^^comment.

1
MagicFritzOP•

sadly there's a ton of content on it you cannot get otherwise

1
akester•

Shameless plug for my open source service Storehouse. We built Storehouse to address a lot of the privacy issues we saw with projects like SourceForge. We work very hard to ensure our operations don't have issues like these.

14
zfundamental•

Congrats on launching your project. Looking at it though I can't help but feel like it still needs to have considerable work before it's a viable alternative to other sites (sf/github/bitbucket/etc/etc):

  • The first time I tried to view the source https://sthse.co/project/akester/storehouse/dashboard was failing to load correctly
  • Other pages take excessively long lengths of time (10+ seconds) to load
  • The issue tracker looks very bare bones
  • The majority of the claimed features are 'Coming soon'

Good luck with progressing your work, though it may be too early (IMO) to be actively promoting it as these sorts of issues could impact first impressions.

16
akester•

I appreciate the feedback. I'm still working on improving our platform and I'll be the first to say that we still have a long way to go before we're on the same level of some of our competitors.

7
bushwacker•

The code should be on github.

-5
CosmosisQ•

Maybe Svnhub if there were such a thing. Anywhere but SourceForge.

1