Tankies fuck off

The state-ideology of Stalinism, and all its derivatives thereof, were created to justify the capitalist actions of bourgeois states by severely distorting Marxist theory and by mangling the Communist programme to be unrecognizable to its original purpose. "Marxist-Leninists" and all derivatives of that bourgeois ideology can only ever act as parasites to the international proletarian movement, at the very least, drawing energy away from it and weakening it. It would have the workers side with their national bourgeois to fight and kill other workers of the world, drawing it further and further away from its ultimate goal- the establishment of an international class union and conquering of political power, and consigning the proletariat, even after killing each other in inter-bourgeois struggles, to continue to be oppressed under a national bourgeois dictatorship rather than a foreign one under the pretext of "national liberation".

Report all tankie activity so we can unleash revolutionary terror on them. Thank you and have a nice day.

Relevant reading material:

Doctrine of the Body Possessed by the Devil.

Militancy, the Highest Stage of Alienation.

Posted Apr 15, 2018, 8:20 AM UTC · edited

7521
WhipItGouda•

Poop on tankies.

14
Absolut_Null_Punkt•

I was listening to one of Dan Carlin's podcasts yesterday. It wasn't one of his better ones and was full of Great Man Theory and Ideology. But he brought up a good point. He posed the question (paraphrasing) "Why did Radical Leftism in the US halt after the Wall Street Bombing of 1920?" No more plurality in Leftist engagement, no more "radical terrorism", etc.

He had no definitive answer, but he drew conclusion to the Bolshevik victory and "mainstreaming" and centralizing of "Leftism" by the USSR, especially post 1924. He then went on to detail the damaging back and forth/badly communicated/etc "directives" that originated from the Soviets across the next two decades ending with the most destructive - the capitulation to German interests with the Molotov-Ribbentrop Pact which, essentially, disillusioned a significant number of the Left in the US that they abandoned the struggle.

11
leftcommunists•

How was that a bad thing though? From the Russian experience we can clearly see that the long campaign of individual terror by narodnik intellectuals did not work, like at all, I don't know why the same sort of "struggle" would work in the US. The calling for centralization of struggle is literally in the manifesto.

2
Stickmanville•

I think the comment’s point is that the adoption of Marxism-Leninism by other parties pushed through by Russia served the counterrevolution by transforming international struggles into a defense of the Russian national state.

5
Absolut_Null_Punkt•

Not quite that specific, but more or less the same reason groups attempted the Stalinist model over and over and some still insist on it today.

"This is the one thing that worked"

It was an event whose outcome discouraged pluralism in the political sphere. It was deep and wide reaching. Not even Mao was willing to openly separate from Stalin until after Stalin's death. But what may have been "self enforced" due to optimism was eventually executed from the COMINTERN itself.

2

Which episode?

1
Absolut_Null_Punkt•

Dunno off hand but if you look for whichever one was about early 20th century left wing/anarchism it's that one.

1
prenatalism•

From the link:

The ridiculousness of their pretensions might make you laugh, but laughter is not enough. It is necessary to look deeper, to understand why the modern world produces these bureaucratic extremists, and to tear away the mask of their ideologies in order to reveal their true historical role. As far as possible, revolutionaries must distance themselves from leftist organisations, and show that far from threatening the old world order, the action of these groups can at best only lead to its reconditioning. Starting to criticise them prepares the ground for the revolutionary movement, which will be obliged to liquidate them, or else risk being liquidated itself.

Makes me wonder why this subreddit even exists. Stop staring into the abyss.

4
WhipItGouda•

if you stare into the abyss long enough, the abyss says something about how national liberation is good for advancing the proletarian cause and you giggle.

10
leftcommunists•

Are the "left-coms" here like fully opposed to national liberation movements, as espoused by Marx, Engels, Lenin and Bordiga(and the ICP)? It feels very memey and nonsensical to link both a councilist article and one by Bordiga...

2
Absolut_Null_Punkt•

My opinion is that whether they are good or bad on an individual basis is inconsequential to concept of Socialism. Quotes from the 1900s, early and mid, are absent of the actual praxis that occurred for decades.

Lenin, Marx, Engels, Bordiga, etc didn't live through the era of the wars of national liberation to witness the respective national and comprador bourgeoisie completely integrate their own economies with global capital and, thus, these men have no ability to reconcile their comments made before these events to the reality that we know today.

Also something something something quantity eventually becomes quality.

5
leftcommunists•

Lenin, Marx, Engels, Bordiga, etc didn't live through the era of the wars of national liberation to witness the respective national and comprador bourgeoisie completely integrate their own economies with global capital and, thus, these men have no ability to reconcile their comments made before these events to the reality that we know today.

Bordiga did live during several wars though, and the ICP is still around. The point of a national liberation movement is that the country can't overthrow capitalism and instate a dictatorship of the proletariat yet and instead need to gain more autonomy and so on from imperialist powers.

As the ICP says in The Colonial Question: an initial balancing sheet,

If colonialist domination had been maintained, the communist revolution would have found itself, in Africa and in Asia, confronted with a “Russian situation”, similar to the one that the dictatorship of the proletariat confronted in the ex-Russia of the Tsars – or rather, even further behind under social and economic aspects. Therefore, if a communist power had succeeded in bringing down colonialism, it would have found itself in the impossible situation, precisely as in Russia, of translating into practice the fundamental points of the communist programme relating to the suppression of the capitalist relations of production. We would have had, sticking with the same hypothesis, a new case of a communist revolution which succeeds in seizing power from the dominant classes but is unable to use this power to start the transformation of the economy in a communist direction, and which has to wait, in order to accomplish this, for the proletarian victory in the more developed capitalist states.

0
Bigfluffyltail•

the country can't overthrow capitalism

Though probably not intentional, this is more revealing of the mindset than anything else.

What does the proletariat have to gain from being exploited by this or that bourgeois? Autonomy? What a joke! Again: many national liberation wars have happened. They resulted only in our bloodshed. The interests of a nation are that of its bourgeoisie. And I'm not sure the countries the text talks of became autonomous from foreign powers.

The point of national liberation movements is to establish or help develop capitalism. Capitalism is global and as such, such a program makes no sense. These movements only serve to pacify any actual working class revolts that are often behind, dominated and strangled by the national liberation of the bourgeoisie. A much different position than the one claiming that workers have interests in national liberation or the one saying there is nothing proletarian at all in these sorts of political contexts, you will notice.

Edit: Meant to but forgot to ask, why was your last account suspended?

9
leftcommunists•

Though probably not intentional, this is more revealing of the mindset than anything else.

I'm going to blame me just getting of my night shift on my faulty thinking.

My point was not that a country "overthrows capitalism" since capitalism can't be toppled in one country or by a country of course. What I think I meant is that the proletariat in a country, which is still connected with proletarians of all countries and coordinated trough an international, crush the state apparatus in that country and create their dictatorship of the proletariat, like the October Revolution and Paris Commune.

The point of national liberation movements is to establish or help develop capitalism. Capitalism is global and as such, such a program makes no sense.

Yes, but a lot of imperialized countries or nations being occupied can not fully industrialize or develop the proletariat to the point where it can constitute itself a party. Like in Palestine. Of course I don't think communists should just throw themselves head first to defend any and all national liberation movements, and neither do tankies. I've never met a tankie who has unironically thought that organisations like the PLO have acted correctly from the start.

Edit: Meant to but forgot to ask, why was your last account suspended?

Ban evasion lol

2
jakehmw•

Marx and Engels lived in a time of ascendant capitalism, where it still needed spreading across the globe. The 20th century and even this century has shown that national liberation movements didn't contribute to a larger socialist movement, but actively suppressed the proletarian movements within them.

5
Bigfluffyltail•

I cannot speak for everyone of course so personally I maintain that the whole national self-determination thing is not revolutionary in any way (comrade Woodrow Wilson!). Notions of "people" an "nation" only serve to mystify class antagonisms. I tend to be disgusted by the idea that workers should take the side of one fraction or another of the bourgeoisie. It has never ended well for us.

Only two short articles being linked is a bit weird yeah and although I like both they seem kind of random to each other. Not sure what the point was there. The second part of Militancy clarifies the first.

For your own information, the ICP branch here in France imploded in the early 80's because their stance on nationalism had lead them to third-worldism (invariance moves in mysterious ways). They never really recovered. I've only met support for them on the internet so from my point of view they're the meme.

As a mod I feel obliged to mention: unless your stance leads you to say some incredibly dumb shit you should be fine.

4
leftcommunists•

Only two short articles being linked is a bit weird yeah and although I like both they seem kind of random to each other. Not sure what the point was there. The second part of Militancy clarifies the first.

It's not weird, it is completely expected. The people here have no actual theoretical schooling, they are just linking things their meme forerunners linked to them.

I cannot speak for everyone of course so personally I maintain that the whole national self-determination thing is not revolutionary in any way (comrade Woodrow Wilson!). Notions of "people" an "nation" only serve to mystify class antagonisms. I tend to be disgusted by the idea that workers should take the side of one fraction or another of the bourgeoisie. It has never ended well for us.

I think Lenin is given to little credit. It's not like he just said that everybody in oppressed nations should become frothing nationalists supporting their own bourgeois. He still said that struggle against exploitation needs to be free from nationalism to be effective since it will otherwise break the solidarity with workers of all countries.

As he says in The Right of Nations to Self-Determination,

The interests of the working class and of its struggle against capitalism demand complete solidarity and the closest unity of the workers of all nations; they demand resistance to the nationalist policy of the bourgeoisie of every nationality. Hence, Social-Democrats would be deviating from proletarian policy and subordinating the workers to the policy of the bourgeoisie if they were to repudiate the right of nations to self-determination, i.e., the right of an oppressed nation to secede, or if they were to support all the national demands of the bourgeoisie of oppressed nations. It makes no difference to the hired worker whether he is exploited chiefly by the Great-Russian bourgeoisie rather than the non-Russian bourgeoisie, or by the Polish bourgeoisie rather than the Jewish bourgeoisie, etc. The hired worker who has come to understand his class interests is equally indifferent to the state privileges of the Great-Russian capitalists and to the promises of the Polish or Ukrainian capitalists to set up an earthly paradise when they obtain state privileges. Capitalism is developing and will continue to develop, anyway, both in integral states with a mixed population and in separate national states.

In any case the hired worker will be an object of exploitation. Successful struggle against exploitation requires that the proletariat be free of nationalism, and be absolutely neutral, so to speak, in the fight for supremacy that is going on among the bourgeoisie of the various nations. If the proletariat of any one nation gives the slightest support to the privileges of its “own” national bourgeoisie, that will inevitably rouse distrust among the proletariat of another nation; it will weaken the international class solidarity of the workers and divide them, to the delight of the bourgeoisie. Repudiation of the right to self-determination or to secession inevitably means, in practice, support for the privileges of the dominant nation.

2
[deleted]•

[removed]

-3†
Xram-Lrak•

did you feel like a big boy when you typed this?

Common man, it isn't necessary to ridicule other people.

8
LaurenEP•

hows "owning the libs" in r/milliondollarextreme going

6
AlienElationOP•

Are you too stupid to understand irony?

5
[deleted]•

[removed]

1