Something I've realized and might be a problem for others here, my wife has ALWAYS had responsive desire.

I bring this up as I see it so often in posts here and I really think it could help a lot of people. So many guys are afraid to really lay it out with their wives, and sadly this is not a aspect of sexuality talked about much.

"Our sex life was great, and then it started to slow down, and its two times a month duty sex and I hate it. " - Many DB posters

It could be a trope here I think at least for LLF's, and maybe some LLM's though they seem more rare as responsive desire types.

Responsive desire works in that they just don't think "hey sex would be great" but need to be stimulated in a way to think, "Hmm maybe sex would be nice." and then once it starts its "hey sex would be great!"

As the HL, I'm almost always thinking sex would be great, or at least nice (I'm not 100%HL 24/7) but once a day would be fabulous for me 90% of the time.

Here is how I realized she had always been responsive desire oriented even years before I had an idea of a DB.

When we were first dating, she was very sexually inexperienced. Just going on a date was "sexy" in terms of her libido, or me holding her hand, or just spending time together. Boom shes horny, and we had lot of sex.

Then early on it was BJ's and doggie and all the usual sex as a new toy thing, and it was sexy and good and boom shes horny.

Then we were separated by schools and distance so we only saw each other every 2 weeks at best, sometimes 6, and boom shes horny.

This sort of thing continues due to life until we are married, but then we started doing things like watching porn together, and getting her first sex toys together, and boom she is horny.

And then I start to discover swinging and we meet our first couple we hooked up with and it was new sexy and exciting and BOOM she was horny.

And then shes willing to act on her bi side and she had her first encounter with another woman and low and behold things are new and horny.

And then we start to slow down with kids and life and we got out of shape so our swinging prospects were lower and this is where I start to worry because we have less horny moments.

So we start exploring her exhibitionist side, and we get back into shape and start swinging again, and shes getting more horny, and then we start camming and it works while we are camming and she is horny then but only then and I'm getting frustrated because sex is now 2 week duty sex unless we are swinging or camming and she always makes swinging and camming seem like too much work even though almost always has fun, and I'm getting frustrated.

At this point the only possible escalation of our sex would be an open marriage and I'm firmly against that for a lot of reasons.

So now I have no way else to up the ante and decided to post here.

So I post here and learn about responsive desire, and long story short sex is now a daily thing which is making her more horny because shes always thinking a bout it as a thing happening today, not put off a few days, but it will happen, and then she starts to get horny a bit and things are good.

Now I was very proactive in our DB, and luckily in that we are both freaky enough that I could, not realizing it, mask our DB issue with more "new" sexual experiences each step of the way.

Basic sex is boring? Lets try porn.

Porn is boring? Well lets do what they do in porn.

That gets same old, well lets MAKE porn.

And each step I was keeping that responsive desire going but not understanding why she just couldn't say "I have fun doing this, lets do that again!" It was always me pulling her along, but even in our fuck like rabbits days I was pulling her along and didn't know it, it just took a lot less to pull her along!

I've come to realize, I will never get her to a point where she will pull me to her and say "Fuck me like an animal" but I can work her and get her to a point where she wants to be fucked like an animal.

It's not perfect but it sure as hell doesn't suck either. I was lucky in that she really does love me, she really does want to improve our relationship and she was willing to get past her stubbornness to improve it. I still have to pull those strings to get her horny but on the other hand, we stopped having daily sex for a lot of reasons last month (not really her fault, not mine, life in the way), and three days ago she said "We need to get back to our every day thing."

Three months ago? She thought, honestly that her vagina was not actually able to handle it.

Posted Apr 20, 2018, 6:52 PM UTC

525
Beachit56•

I was lucky in that she really does love me, she really does want to improve our relationship and she was willing to get past her stubbornness to improve it.

I suspect for most HLs here, it's hard to navigate past "No!" into sex toys, porn and swinging. If they try to take the discussion past No the LL instigates a fight, or "Is this all you think about?" and etc. There might be a porn star locked up in a lot of LLs but finding it is near impossible.

You had something to work with, and the two of you were willing to exceed some boundaries that most couples aren't, like swinging and your wife's bi experiences.

I'm not convinced "responsive desire" covers a significant number of stories here. Some people just don't like sex, except as a tool to attract mates and then do whatever procreating they want. Or they've lost their sexual attraction for their partners, assuming they ever had any.

4
diffdedbedOP•

I'm not saying everyone will work this away, but maybe 15 years ago, had I known what is going on, I could have started the every day sex thing etc then and not had to go to things like swinging.

I regret nothing, really swinging is great for us and has made our relationship better beyond sex, but I know not everyone is up for that for a lot of reasons.

One thing I think is a bigger problem in DB's is how slow people are to address the issue. Once it becomes just how you are and resentment and such has built up it may not be possible to cure, where as having a talk the first time your partner rejects you twice could have helped fix it 10 years prior.

3
Beachit56•

had I known what is going on, I could have started the every day sex thing etc then and not had to go to things like swinging.

No, you could not have done that. Not without your wife's cooperation. When you have a spouse that desires (or allows) less and less sex, you are not in the driver's seat...

When you are headed down to sex once or twice a week, what exactly would you have said (or done) to your wife (as a general solution here) to get her back up to everyday?

No one here has ever figured out how to trigger an LL's "responsive desire" by talking or just initiating more. Thus the question.

1
diffdedbedOP•

No one here has ever figured out how to trigger an LL's "responsive desire" by talking or just initiating more. Thus the question.

You can read my post history before my breakthrough, its all my story and what I did to fix it.

She had to agree but had I not done anything, nothing would be different for me, and instead of my wife asking to start sex every night again, she would still be thinking, honestly, that she couldn't handle sex every night even physically.

I am taking full credit in fixing her responsive desire, but it required she actually have responsive desire.

With responsive desire, the person with it needs to be willing to accept it and work with the HL, and the HL needs to be willing to work with it.

2
Beachit56•

You were right in an earlier story that you "don't really belong here" because, while you have a lot of issues, you do have something to work with.

If you think the average guy here, no matter where he is in his DB, could sit his wife down and have her sign a contract for sex every day, I think you are very mistaken. I'm quite sure my STBX would have considered it rape and told me to fuck off. Can't speak for anyone else.

1
pbdgaf•

I'm not sure that responsive desire covers the OP's pattern of requiring ever-increasing stimulus to spark his wife's interest. Perhaps she has responsive desire in addition to something else.

1
diffdedbedOP•

Sex everyday is also keeping her interest. I did what I did because I wanted to do them with her, not to keep her interest, its only in retrospect I see the pattern. I didn't even know this was a thing 3 months ago.

2
3TreeTraveller•

I'll chime in. As the "LLF" in my marriage, I was also able to "fix" our DB with swinging. We had a DB starting from when we moved in together and the NRE wore off. I was very LL most of the time for well over a decade, but I would have spurts of HL that lasted a week or two a couple times a year.

During one of these HL spurts, I started thinking about what I could do to make it last and not lose my libido again. My now ex and I started talking about sexual things we were interested in, and we were both curious about swinging. So we went for it, and guess what? My libido never tanked again.

The new sexual energy kept me interested in sex in general, so I was happy to have almost daily sex with my now ex. But what I learned was that the DB was a distraction from and a byproduct of deeper problems in the marriage in addition to a way for me to bury and avoid dealing with past abuse.

We went to couples counseling, and I went to individual counseling. He fought me every step of the way. He couldn't or wouldn't see his part in any of our issues. He also fought back on my efforts to work through my past abuse. I think he was threatened by it all. He kept telling me he wanted me to go back to the way I was before.

By the time I decided it was over, we had been in a poly relationship with another couple for several months. My new SO was so much different. He was supportive of my needs and wanted me to grow. My now ex spent those months in endless fights with his new GF revolving around her not caring enough about his feelings. I realized this is who he is, and he will never change.

Five years later, I'm still with the same SO from that poly relationship. He also got divorced, and neither of us want anything to do with polyamory again. We did jump back into swinging a couple summers ago, but that fizzled out fast. Finding other couples takes effort, and neither of us cared to bother. I love sex with my SO, and I initiate all the time. I don't want or need any outside desire.

OP, I know there are a lot of differences in our stories. I thought I'd add mine because of all the comments saying this doesn't apply to DBs. It probably is irrelevant to most, but it does apply to some.

3
diffdedbedOP•

Glad in the end it worked out for you. I don't think most couples need to go completely into the alt-lifestyle with swinging and the like to get that spark back. I had interest in it long before I thought about a DB, so it was just natural for me, and turns out she did too so it worked out for us.

I'm just hoping to help a few people along the way.

1
windirfullVHLM - 3 years liberated•

and she always makes swinging and camming seem like too much work even though almost always has fun

When you two are swinging, does she do most of the coordination, chatting, texting etc? We've been in group chats with other couples before and I had no idea just how much work goes into it. In all instances the wives are the ones who initiate contact and then sustain the conversation, with the guys chiming in on maybe 2% of the conversation. Their chats were pretty casual and sometimes sexy, but many times it was just to get to know the couple and to build trust. Anyway, I'm curious if she does most of the leg work and was legitimately burned out of it?

Edit: I feel old, I had to google "camming"

2
[deleted]•

[removed]

1
diffdedbedOP•

In most cases is the guy doing the footwork, myself included. Normally only one part of the couple does it. My wife is involved in details but only after we are ready to meet someone. Swinging is a lot of work though yes, though thats not whats burning her out.

I wish actually she would take over the footwork because that would keep the whole "sexy vibe" thing going. We tend to take a swinger vacation a couple of times a year, and being surrounded by that atmosphere is enough to get her going, even if we don't swap and just play together.

Its one of those things that I used to point out to her, that for some reason, at a place like Desire (swinger resort) even if we weren't with other people, she was up for sex every night, but at home, not so much. She even stated it was the atmosphere of those kind of places that did it for her.

1
ThatWideLife•

I dunno, to me it’s a huge red flag that she gets in the mood at the thought of fucking other people, or only in the mood when it’s another female, or only in the mood when other people are watching. Do you see the common theme here? Only in the mood when others are involved but when it’s just the two of you it’s hard to get her into it. To each their own but the thought of sharing my wife when she won’t fuck me just doesn’t do it for me. I’d be cool with an open type relationship if we were both already sexually satisfied but wanted just a little more that neither can give.

2
diffdedbedOP•

Its the sexual energy that matters, its keeping it fresh, until I ran out of fresh. I don't think you have to go to my extremes, I wanted to go there anyways so it all worked out, but what you can't do is expect them to just want you and lust you like you do them. Their brains don't work that way.

3
ThatWideLife•

I agree their brains don’t work that way but how are you gonna maintain that? I don’t see opening the marriage really doing anything because her desire for you doesn’t seem like it was ever really there. Maybe in the beginning it was because it was more the idea of “new” that turned her on but was it actually “you” that was turning her on? Open will work in the sense that you will get your needs met elsewhere but what happens when she refuses to sleep with you and only sleeps with the other person? I don’t see anything wrong with two people agreeing to share each other but when you only share and never have each other it seems more like a roommate situation. Maybe I’m wrong? Who knows lol.

2
diffdedbedOP•

Everyone seems to be glossing over the ...

She wants to have sex everyday with me now

Part.

This is after constant arguments over once a week duty sex where she was really wanting once every other week duty sex prior.

3
ThatWideLife•

I must’ve missed that part sorry. In that case, lucky you lol. By all means do what’s working you don’t need our advice.

1