Is it just me, or is the are the monster creation rules in the DMG inaccurate?

Most things seem to line up, but it seems as if the damage category in particular is incorrect; when cross referencing it with monsters in the Monster Manual, it seems like the Monster Manual examples do less damage overall than the chart on page 273 of the DMG implies they should, based on their challenge rating. Is there something I'm missing?

Posted Apr 21, 2018, 6:17 PM UTC

412
Trace500•

Yeah, there are a lot of monsters that don't deserve the challenge rating they were given. Presumably this is because the monsters in the MM have had their challenge ratings adjusted based on playtesting even if they don't have the numbers to back it up, which leads to things like the Druid, a CR 2 creature that appears incredibly weak. If I had to guess, it got its CR because entangle can pose a problem when the players have unlucky rolls and the druid has allies, and because an upcasted thunderwave actually deals decent damage, but it's not like the book is going to tell you these things so it can lead to some head-scratchers.

6
IndexObjectOP•

It's confusing, because part of the section on monster creation mentions things like spells but doesn't say that necessarily increases the challenge rating. All in all monster creation is incredibly vague for all of that writing.

2
mclemente26Warlock turned DM•

Are you averaging the offensive CR and defensive CR?

4
IndexObjectOP•

I am! My problem currently seems to be the damage category, and how to go about it. Average 40 damage, for example, means dice totaling approximately 80 points maximum. But 4d20 seems like a lot of damage. Looking in the monster manual, it seems like most if not all of the monsters I'm seeing have a lower than recommended amount of damage.

4
Trace500•

In my experience most monsters are actually stronger offensively for their CR than defensively. 40 damage would be CR 6, and skimming through the MM, I think most creatures at that level are pretty strong offensively. What monsters are you looking at?

2
IndexObjectOP•

Mammoth jumps out at me, but I'm now realizing that Charge gives them the potential to do more than the prescribed 40 average damage. So I guess you have to factor in the monster's 'worst case scenario', and then determine how often that'll happen?

2
Trace500•

Iirc the guidelines are that you should assume players fail their saves and that AoEs get two players. So the assumption would be that the mammoth gets its Trampling Charge in, and that plus its +10 attack bonus gives it a high offensive CR, which they offset by giving it low AC and hit points.

2
Veruah•

Yeah, the CR system has a lot of problems. It is good for a general (very general) idea of a creature/NPC's power, but so much can change that. Not limited to: PC party composition, resources left in the tank, player tactical skill, environmental factors, etc.

1
8kNNRQ•

The monster s in the MM were made with the rules in the DMG. After play testing the MM CRs were adjusted. Then the DMG had to go to print without further adjustment. If I actually knew any of this I wouldn't be able to say it because of an NDA.

1
IndexObjectOP•

HMMMMM interesting...

1
macbalanceRolling for a Wild Surge...•

I think they’re intended as Guidelines, not hard & fast rules.

1