r/civ•
metorical

Civ 6 - Post a problem and its simple solution

There's still lots of really silly bugs in this game that could easily be fixed. I'm not talking about major mechanics changes or AI overhauls, I'm talking about "if X then Y rules". Let's see how many we can come up with!

See my example below.

Posted Apr 23, 2018, 4:17 PM UTC · edited

313
BigCheesecake•
  • Problem: Military Engineers are not worth their build cost.

  • Solution: Instead of Fort builds, Military Engineer also acts as a support unit which gives the fort fortification bonus once it has spent 1 turn on a tile. (Aka movable forts).

  • Problem: No universally applicable way to stop a religion if you don't have a religion.

  • Solution: Make a religion-less unit able to war holy war.

I'll give one that might be unpopular;

  • Problem: Horde of units from a single strategic resource.
  • Solution: Strategic resources only support a set number of units.
6
depression_anon•

It speaks to the quality of the game design that I don't know if these problems even need solving.

  • Military Engineers would be OP with your tweak, IMHO. I think their main value comes from airstrips well before aircraft carriers are available

  • I kind of enjoy this aspect of religion! If you don't get to found one in time, you must pick from some combination of the available options. It feels like a realistic challenge, to me. I'd prefer a tweak to how many Great Prophets can exist in a game, and when. Maybe add a/some new Great Prophet(s) each time a new era is reached for the first time..? Just a thought. I'd like to see game mechanics for more diverse and less ancient (both in civ world and in real history) religions: Lutherans, Anglicans, Mormons, Rastafarians, Scientologists...

  • Boo, don't take my horde of units! No, really, I think this should stay how it is. It represents the massive advantage of having that access to strategic resources at all, and lets them be rare. With your design, they would have to be significantly more plentiful.

Really good thinking here, even though I disagree with E V E R Y T H I N G

2
BigCheesecake•

1: I don't really even bother with military engineers at all in a single-player game. It just isn't worth wasting the build cost.

2: This is the reason I turn religion off during a single player game on higher difficulties. It forces you to either end up in perpetual war with a religious civ so you can condem heretics and then hope they keep sending units so the passive pressure doesn't get you or completely focus on religion at the VERY start and hope you snag one. Either make it so everyone can get a religion or give me an atheistic style religious unit to at least counter someone else without requiring full scale war. (What other victory condition can you be permanently locked out of within 75 turns).

3: It doesn't mean having 1 unit per strategic, it could be like 1 iron = 10 units, 1 horse = 5 horse units, 1 niter = 5 guns etc. Right now just having that SINGLE strategic can make you super powerful, especially if you luck out and one appears under a city making it invincible. This is not realistic when you consider how important limiting an enemies access to strategic resources has been in modern wars (Japan oil embargo, the whole war in North Africa/ME in WW2).

I want more methods of waging less war mongery wars, specifically against guys like Ghengis.

1
Ducklinsenmayer•

ai trades war declarations like popcorn:

solution: cost of a joint war declaration should depend on the strength of the enemy forces, and the relationship they have with that party; it should NEVER be cheap.

4
metoricalOP•
  • Problem: The AI builds tile dependent wonders (e.g. petra) in bad locations (e.g. 2 desert tiles)
  • Solution: Count how many workable tiles there are and only build if greater than X
4
Tavia_Melody•

They'd also have to consider how many desert tiles their enemies might have if they know about them, so even if they can't use Petra, if an enemy would get a massive boost from it they may want to build it anyway.

3
Iamdanno•

Problem: AI halfway around world (possibly on other land mass) declares war on other player it cannot (or will not try to) reach within 30 turns.

Solution: Have AI check travel time to potential attack site and react accordingly.

Exception: Go ahead and have them declare if they are getting paid enough to do so.

4
metoricalOP•

To get us started:

  • Problem: AI complains about you settling too closely, when your city is only a few tiles from your first city.
  • Solution: Don't complain about cities within X tiles of your first city.
3
metoricalOP•
  • Problem : auto unit cycle happens too slowly and tries to cycle units while you are giving orders
  • Solution : don't cycle unit if you are mid order
3
kaesden•

Easier solution, just turn off auto unit cycle.

4
metoricalOP•

Ah, I seem to remember it wasn't in the options? You had to disable in config. I see now it's there. Good point :)

1
super_aardvark•

Problem: In the Australian economic scenario (I forget the name), the tech tree doesn't open, which means clicking on the science button in the upper-left doesn't do anything and you can't check your science progress.
Solution: fix the UI

Problem: In the Australian economic scenario (I forget the name), the Civic button in the lower right (e.g. when you need to pick a new one) doesn't work; you have to click the culture button in the upper-left.
Solution: fix the UI

Problem: In the Australian economic scenario (I forget the name), if you bring up the ESC menu and then close it, the blue overlay remains and the game no longer accepts mouse input. The only way out is to quick-load.
Solution: fix the fucking UI

Problem: In the Australian economic scenario (I forget the name), you can't quit to main menu, nor to desktop. Alt-F4 does nothing. Windows Task Manager is required to kill the game.
Solution: ..........................

1
DesmondDuck•

You also cant start production on the alexander one.

1