CMV: Apu is not a stereotype as explained via Venn Diagrams

The controversy about The Simpsons and Apu got me thinking about Venn Diagrams.

Image : http://www.data-miners.com/blog/uploaded_images/two-circle-venn-770799.jpg

Venn Diagrams need not be even or balanced. It can be the case that As are rarely Bs, but that Bs are often As. This case is shown generally in the above image.

This relates directly to Apu.

There are roughly 150,000 convenience stores in the United States. 80,000 of those stores are owned by Asian-Americans. There are 18 million Asian-Americans currently living in the United States.

Source: https://www.ndtv.com/world-news/indian-americans-pay-a-price-for-running-convenience-stores-657201

In this way - The proportion of Asian-Americans who own convenience stores is 0.45%. However, the proportion of convenience stores which are Asian-American owned is 53%.

Thus it follows that "All Asian-Americans own Kwik-E-Marts" is a stereotype - less than 1% do. However, "Most Kwik-E-Marts are owned by Asian-Americans" is less off the mark. If we are willing to grant that >50% constitutes a valid use of the word "most"- then this statement is true.

Thus is Apu a stereotype? Which # matters? the 0.45% or the 53%??

In short - going up to a random Indian-American and calling them Apu as an insult - is obviously terrible. However, is it terrible to have a convenience store owner on a TV show be depicted as Indian - I don't think so. While the show might want to rethink Apu's accent and dialog, I don't think the character is fundamentally broken.

Having a convenience store owner be depicted as Indian is reflective of society and not racist - it is only the assertion that "all Asian-Americans are convenience store owners" which is racist - which the character Apu doesn't do.

CMV


This is a footnote from the CMV moderators. We'd like to remind you of a couple of things. Firstly, please read through our rules. If you see a comment that has broken one, it is more effective to report it than downvote it. Speaking of which, downvotes don't change views**! Any questions or concerns? Feel free to message us. Happy CMVing!

Posted Apr 25, 2018, 5:52 PM UTC

88185
Loading comments…