(Effort post) How much does constitutional structure matter for organizing?
I had this thought while drinking beer and working on my thesis, and decided to post instead of work (don't @ me).
I'm comparing open government portfolios in different countries, and it occurred to me that the constitutional management and mandate for cities has a massive effect on organizing for any kind of reformist, electoral route to social.ism.democracy.
I come from Canada, which is arguably the most "States Rights!" country in the world. We have an incredibly decentralized structure that puts a massive onus on the various provinces to run their own affairs. It runs decently well because there are a small enough amount of veto players in the provinces compared to the US (10 - the territories don't really count, and that's part of our long scourge of the indigenous people in Canada, which goes far beyond my knowledge and this effort post).
However, our cities fucking suck. Vancouver and Montreal have parties that legally must detach themselves from provincial and federal parties, and the rest of the cities (as far as I'm aware - maybe some other mid sized QC cities have parties) are non-partisan. There are fucked up amalgamations, arbitrary fundraising rules, and cities are unable to run deficits. They've also been historically heaped upon by conservative governments attempting to cut deficits. Mike Harris, premier of Ontario, is maybe one of the worst people to win an election in the western world. He ran a socially conservative, economically libertarian scorched earth policy on this province.
I'm comparing open government in the UK, and they're so massively centralized that it's not fathomable to me. However, there's also radical devolution and a pretty clear separation of powers between the cities and the central government.
I have a couple friends who try and organize a lot in municipal politics, but it seems so fruitless - you have no real taxation powers, you can't coordinate with a party institution, you can't ever afford anything you need (social housing, public transit, public spaces, arts and culture investments). The provinces can create massive changes. In Quebec, they've created something that vacillates between a civic national social democracy and an ethnic national social democracy. Alberta has been pretty fucking libertarian at times. BC instituted one of the first ever carbon taxes.
It seems like in the UK, if you get 10 Downing street, you run the country. And there are mayors in a lot of cities across the world who seem to have pretty massive powers. But it seems to me that in Canada, the electoral aim is to run a province. That's where the power to affect change and the ability to interface with people actually lives.
I think that direct action more often gets a lot of goods than electoral action, though I think it's important not to discount the latter. Is this a big part of organizing where you come from? Is the ladder of legitimate electoral politics - being a county clerk, councillor, legislator, senator/governor, executive a clear career ladder? Or is there a pretty dynamic element to how to get involved in electoral, leftist politics?
Posted Apr 25, 2018, 11:20 PM UTC
I think the nature of the electoral system itself matters more than relative distribution of powers between the various layers of government