Non-directive in daily life?
With other methods of meditation (probably not "all" others though) you can bring your method outside the mat. Being mindful in daily life. Being aware of the breath or the body. Reciting the mantra all day.
What about non-directive? Has anyone ever tried applying this outside the mat?
I just read something from Toni Packer about having less and less decisions in daily life, which brought this topic to mind.
Posted May 2, 2018, 3:01 PM UTC
Nondirective's benefits are in untying the effortful conditioning that we all take on. In my experience, the benefits go beyond the mat in themselves.
However, that doesn't prevent one from applying this principle to everyday experience. What has been most clarifying for me is noticing moment-to-moment when I'm putting extra effort into something. We think we need to make special effort in order to make our brains think better or perform better, and this effort gets in the way. It's apparent when we squint our eyes to hear better, or furrow our brow to understand better. This is completely unnecessary, but we've trained ourselves to make these extra tensions to do everything from walking to thinking—even falling asleep!
So, whenever I notice these tendencies, I let go of the feeling that "I must do", pause and physically and mentally relax the effort, then continue on from that relaxed state. Sometimes thoughts will arise to create resistance to this, and will explain in all kinds of ways how this is not the time for you to relax or you will mess up if you let go of your heightened focus, etc. It is that kind of thinking, precisely, that keeps us on the wheel of believing our thoughts and moving with extra effort, tension, and anxiousness.
Thanks, that was insightful!
You mentioned noticing moment to moment.. Does that happen naturally or should I put in some subtle effort to do that?
This is a great question. The short answer is that you could say that this is the one effort to permit yourself, to notice when a stronger effort of "making something happen" is taking hold and to pause and relax out of it. Don't get too hung up about making a smaller fire if it's going to help stop the larger fire that is consuming the forest.
The slightly longer answer is that ultimately what feels like an effort to pause and relax is not effortful. But in my experience, there are two factors that make it seem so, especially at first. And this is perfectly fine.
First, there's a kind of relaxation-resistance that we have when we've been all balled up with tension and moving intensely toward some minor goal for a while. This is true mentally and emotionally, and it's true physically.
A very physical example of this is if you've ever held onto something tightly or balled your hand into a fist for a long period of time. When you finally relax the fist and let go, it can feel like an effort to open the fingers even though you're clearly moving in the direction of less effort and deeper relaxation to do so.
The second factor is that because we're so used to this effort—this feeling of pushing ourselves—sometimes we will put more effort than is needed in stopping and relaxing. This is just a bit of an overswing, and if we are just kind with ourselves and observe, then this will start to become apparent. Over time, you'll feel out the sweet spot where you just kind of let go of efforting and float to a calmer place.
That was great, thanks! I feel like I'm inching closer towards where "mindfulness" meets "non-directive." (In terms of conceptual understanding, not attainment or what have you)