How to reward long term folders as well as significantly increase the team's PPD over the long term.
Reward(s) should be calculated on two levels.
One is/should be the PPD of the last day or so (50% of the reward) and the other (50%) should be your Total PPD of the last 6 months as compared to the Team's total PPD of the last 6 months.
So if you're 10% of the daily PPD yet you were absent the whole of the last 6 months or so you are only getting 5% of the total daily reward.
By contrast , if for the last 6 months you were folding, even during the downturn yet you had one bad day (your gpu found hurdles), you'd still get 50% of your daily reward as a thank you for folding for so long, despite having had a bad day.
This way cheaters would be punished, as it would become even less affordable to both pay the rent and suffer a 50% loss/reduction of the reward.
Long term folders would be rewarded for their loyalty.
Now if you want to both rent and be loyal be my guest. You'd be losing money as there would be months to not be able to pay the rent, but you'd help the project long term.
Loyalty should be rewarded over naked rent seeking.
I hope the devs would give it a thought. It would do wonders over the average PPD, as we'd lose the downward force in the price of the coins that we have currently (renters selling like maniacs), allowing for an ever greater PPD, allowing for more users to stay long term (as both the prices are better and their loyalty is rewarded).
It solves everything with only a small tweak on the reward system.
I don't see any fault in my thought process. If you find any, please explain.
Posted May 6, 2018, 2:38 AM UTC
Seems like this idea would disincentivise new folders: you spend your first 6 months getting less rewards and possibly not making enough for electric bills.
The prices of the coins would be higher as there would be no downward pressure on the price from the renters.
I expect new folders to make around the same (a bit less) and progressively making more (by the 3 month mark).
You have to understand that current cure/folding prices are a bit of a "magic picture", much more dumping going on than used to.
Edit: But yeah, the idea is to be making on par or a bit below to electricity at first so that we may disincentivize rampant renting and/or coin hoppers.
Knowing, though, that your reward would go continuously up you'd probably be able to justify the first 1-2 months of folding below electricity. It's about looking at the long term and investing to it. The exact opposite of what we have currently...
Maybe we should think about the starting reward to be above electricity cost but below current profit. So the first months are no loss but if you continue for more month your profit increases.
Currently we have 3 groups of folder:
1) Rentals
2) Home farm of e.g. 10 GPUs
3) Home users with 1 GPU
I much prefer to be below electricity at first because it will kill the tought of rentals. Curre tly more than half of the PPD are rentals. Imagine most of them going away, suddenly even a low reward would be enough for most people to fold.
Halving the reward would make rentals untenable for most but the most faithful of people.
Rentals cost more than electricity, for a gtx 1080 you pay $118 a month. It can earn $3 a day = $99 a month. So currently you don't make profit with a rental but it's close.
But it takes 150 kwh at $0.1/kwh which is $15 a month electricity if you run it at home. Even if the power cost would be 3 times higher then it is only $45 and you still make $50 profit. It takes one year to get your ROI and you still have the GPU resell value.
So looks like people using rentals don't make profit but only increase the FAH PPD which is why only Vorksholst is using it as he needs the compute ressources for his folding projects.
[deleted]