Scoring Bug / Question

I'm no expert on baseball scoring, but this here seems off to me.Given the following: https://imgur.com/a/yv43fG0

By winning 4-3 and both scoring 1 in the 9th, shouldn't the relief pitcher (S. Wiselle) get the win?

The save is correct.

Shouldn't the losing pitcher be the one that allowed the run in the 9th (B. Towers)?

Posted May 10, 2018, 10:56 PM UTC

14
careagan•

The Freebooters tied the game in the second and took the lead in the fourth. Their starter left after six with the lead, the score at 3-2. Freebooters took a 4-2 lead in the top of the ninth inning, and their closer gave up a single run in the bottom of the ninth while completing the save in the 4-3 victory.

A starting pitcher gets the win when they complete at least five innings, exit the game with the lead, and the opposing team never ties nor takes the lead at any point after the starter has left. So the scoring is correct in this instance.

2
tabarjackOP•

I see, so if the home team were the Freebooters, then the lead would have been lost and it all would have went to the relief pitchers, is this correct?

1
careagan•

If the Freebooters were the home team and all scoring prior to the ninth inning was the same, they would enter the ninth with a 3-2 lead. Their closer Frequin would have then blown the save by giving up a single run to tie the game.

But if the Freebooters then walked off by scoring a single run in the bottom of the ninth to win the game, Frequin would get the win as the pitcher of record at the time when the Freebooters took the lead for good (and simultaneously ended the game). Basically the last pitcher to pitch at the point at which the lead becomes permanent is the pitcher who will get the win. The exception is for starters, who must go five innings to get credit for the win.

1
tabarjackOP•

Ok, I get it now, off to apply to become official scorer for the MLB!

1