Homegrown CM

I assume there are some people who already did a career mode only using youth academy players. How was this experience, is it hard or does it get boring after a while? What teams do you recommend doing it with?

I'm looking for a bit of challenge here so fire away!

Posted May 14, 2018, 4:36 PM UTC

74
JustJosh1203•

It's interesting and fun scouting the players, my only problem is when it comes to developing the youth prospects into well balanced players.

Even with limited training, the game has a habit of over-levelling very specific stats, for example you'll have a 20yo winger YA prospect, with 99 dribbling but only 75 ball control.

The development of stats like composure and reactions is awful also. You don't really notice it until you start using 85 OVR YA player with awesome stats generally, but only 58 reactions and 55 composure. Their high stats generally count for very little at that point, because those mental stats are so important.

And I won't even get into the physical development. It's so poor.

It's a unique and challenging career for sure, but i also found it very frustrating, personally. For the reasons I just stated above.

Try it out, see how lucky you get. I have had three or four amazing players from the YA. But I've had hundreds of unbalanced ones.

5
FCMC_•

It’s hard if you don’t have money to buy the best scouts. I don’t think it gets boring. You could do a RTG YA Team like Forest green rovers and do a financial takeover or you could do a big club YA like Man city.

1
Texszn•

It’s actually challenging. Right now I took over SM Caen, and 19 games in my best player is a 76 ST and I’m in 11th place. GK is a 70 right my LM/RM at 72/73 each. Got some cheap potential players and trying to raise them up.

1
Andres_Iniesta•

I am in my 7th season. I have one 95 OVR, 3 91 OVR and one 92 OVR all academy players. Now it’s about bringing up the best YA with best physical attributes slowly to the first team

1