cokoopOP•

Arbitration is fine for the waitress opening a savings account at Wells Fargo or a plumber buying a car at Autonation but it's too fraught with peril for our best and brightest young legal minds who have taken contracts from the nation's preeminent legal professors?

10
janethefish•

No (pre-dispute binding) arbitration agreements are terrible for everyone.

19
looolwrong•

Why? What if arbitration clauses limit a firm’s exposure to lawsuits and they are better able to compete on price, which some may prefer?

Consumer choice.

Equally, consumers that don’t like arbitration clauses can transact with firms that don’t use them — they’ll price it in. If consumers truly prefer that, they’ll have a differentiated product with a competitive advantage over those that don’t.

Why must it be one-size-fits-all “terrible for all”? Isn’t it far more likely that different consumers have different preferences?

-10

Why? What if arbitration clauses limit a firm’s exposure to lawsuits and they are better able to compete on price, which some may prefer?

The CFPB "did not find statistically significant empirical support for the theory that companies pass savings from their use of arbitration clauses onto consumers," at least in financial services.

Also, you assume those lawsuits are all frivolous, as opposed to representing actual harms to consumers.

Isn’t it far more likely that different consumers have different preferences?

No, it's far more likely that laypersons have no idea what arbitration is, the implications of it, or how they should price it (as in, comparing two products identical in all respects except one having arbitration, what is the fair market value of both?).

16
AHLondon•

Is layperson knowledge better for the intricacies courtroom procedure? Plus some of the formalities in pleading, discovery, etc. add on administrative and cost burdens for the consumer. Really all of this puts laypersons at a disadvantage in general.

-3
looolwrong•

And Treasury found the CFPB’s finding to be highly dubious:

First, the Bureau’s analysis itself notes that the standard errors are quite large, which means the econometric analysis had little power to detect what could be an economically large effect on consumers. In other words, there could be pass-through, and it may be quite large, but the methodology does not have enough precision for the Bureau to say definitively one way or another with the data available.


The Office of the Comptroller of the Currency (“OCC”) conducted an independent review of the Bureau’s data and econometric analysis and identified many of these very concerns. OCC concluded that there is an 88% chance that the total cost of credit will increase as a result of the Rule and a 56% chance that it will increase by three percentage points or more. This independent review underscores Treasury’s concern: that the Bureau’s analysis does not convincingly rule out higher credit costs for consumers.

The CFPB itself isn’t entirely convinced: in its anti-arbitration final rule, despite its earlier study, the Bureau “acknowledges that most providers will pass through at least portions of some of the costs described above to consumers.”

Since the prices won’t in fact be identical, consumers can discern the value of forgone litigation through price differences. For those who care enough, that is. For those who don’t know and don’t care enough to know, that is itself an expression of the value attached to litigation by consumers who prefer to remain rationally ignorant; many don’t care about non-price terms like loyalty rewards either, so what? The answer is not to ban credit cards that don’t offer rewards programs.

-4
gnorrn•

Equally, consumers that don’t like arbitration clauses can transact with firms that don’t use them,

Got a list?

14
looolwrong•

No. But feel free to shop around: “while most credit card agreements include arbitration clauses, the substantial majority of credit card issuers (247 of 298, or 82.9 percent) do not use arbitration clauses in their credit card agreements.”

If there’s consumer preference for agreements that lack such clauses, then there’s a market for it, and firms can profit by serving that market. If there’s not, then there won’t be.

-6
jorge1209•

The problem is not that it isn't feasible or possible to find an alternative, but that its not reasonable to look for one in the vast majority of our day to day transactions. And for the more exceptional stuff (like significant purchases or employement) there is often less flexibility which leaves the consumer at a disadvantage (Do you not want the job after all? Would you rather starve?).

The average person, who is not trained in the law, is not going to sit there and read a 20 page contract before they sign up for something small like a music streaming service, or something like instagram.

Either the courts need to realize that people aren't reading these contracts and figure out how to handle that situation, or we need some laws to prohibit or discourage these kinds of contracts for more mundane transactions.

Maybe companies should be required to pay people minimum wage for the time they need to read a contract. Figure the average untrained layperson can read 200 words per minute, and cut that in half when dealing with a legal document. So if you are instagram and publish a 3000+ word terms of use, then it would take the average person 30 minutes to read and understand the damn thing. So instagram needs to cut a check for $3.25 to every new user to reflect the time it would take them to actually read the damn thing. If they don't want to do that, they can make their contract shorter.

7
looolwrong•

No need for all that. If consumers don’t care enough to look, then they don’t care enough. And if firms thought they did care, they’d highlight the lack of arbitration clauses to differentiate their product from those with such clauses, and therefore gain a competitive advantage. The market usually finds a way. And it’s almost always more efficient than a choice-limiting market intervention. Let’s not make the cure worse than the disease.

-5
johnwhardinesq•

The sample arb agreement atl posted a month or so ago was pretty ridiculous. you had to agree to binding arb + NDA for sexual harassment, racial discrimination, basically everybody's favorite civil rights arising out of your summer associate employment/ 8-week booze cruise. its not quite as shady as being a redskins cheerleader or working at the weinstein co., but these were purely to protect racist-when-drunk/ touchy-feely-when-drunk/ alex-kozinski-when-internet-not-blocked-at-work partners and their firms from liability and showing up on atl/ jdunderground (is that still a thing?). this is pretty cool that the T14 said fuck that noise, and the AMLaw firms capitulated. i'm sure 80% of the T14 students would have mutinied/ sued if the firms called the bluff, but still pretty cool.

6
AHLondon•

Binding arbitration and NDA for sexual harassment and racial discrimination? Frankly I’d probably rather chance an arbitration than the Title IX committees ruling campuses these days. If arbitration agreements are problematic for these topics because they take the conflicts out of courtrooms, then the TIX tribunals are questionable too. At least with the arbitration I’d possibly get an arbitrator or say in the arbitrator, set rules (I assume they would use the New York rules), and the hurdle of adoption of the arbitral finding by a court.

4
johnwhardinesq•

yeah campuses are nuts, but these guys aren't bound by student handbook for summer job at private firms. they get to go to court/ eeoc if they refuse arb+nda. this is what they leaked title 7, ada, fair pay, fair housing, age discrimination (are there 40y/o summer assocs?) cali's extra stuff.

5
DemandMeNothing•

This is ridiculous. Either arbitration is a fair remedy for legal disputes, or it isn't. Carve-outs make no sense.

1
cokoopOP•

And that's the point. The smart guys, the guys that understand what arbitration is all about, know that arbitration isn't a fair remedy. Acting in some loco parentis capacity the law schools won't let it be foisted upon their knucklehead students.

But for some schmuck that just spent 8 hours on a car lot, slipping it into paragraprh 18 of the sales contract is just fine.

2