If communism or socialism is so good, why not just implement it now?
[removed]
Posted May 18, 2018, 11:23 AM UTC · edited
[removed]
Posted May 18, 2018, 11:23 AM UTC · edited
And then you realize that some big corporation is selling their things off at a loss and you can't compete. Or someone makes a law banning what you do, because you are disrupting the economy or something like that.
some big corporation is selling their things off at a loss
The corporation cannot sustain that for long, and because you have so many people in your group and are spread over multiple sectors, you can spread the blows and survive this.
This practice is called predatory pricing, it is illegal in many countries, even though it barely happens.
Or someone makes a law banning what you do,
Could happen, but how do you know if you don't try?
By the way I see my self as a classical liberal or libertarian, and I would unironically fully support the rights of any group trying this.
Are you sure anyone hasn't already tried?
I am not personally aware of any such endeavour, which is attributable to my lack of research.
Paris commune. They slaughtered them like animals. There was an all out nuclear arms race last time communism was on the rise. Thinking they will just leave you be is so naive it's almost cute...
Gladly. Just give us some few million km² of land with all the resources available on Earth in it, and we'll get right to it.
Under all the supporters together, you must certainly possess that right? If not, you can save up until you can buy it.
Buying land is inherently capitalist and even if we had billions of dollars for that, that land would still be under the legal juristication of the country it belonged to.
Besides that why should we buy land that has been stolen from us instead of taking back what rightfully belongs to everyone?
legal juristication of the country it belonged to
True, although if you have enough land and enough supporters you can try to declare your own state. Separatist movements are occasionally successful and your chances increase if the population is behind you. Which of course it is because it is your own group.
taking back what rightfully belongs to everyone?
So the Native Americans can take back North and South America with violence from white and black people? You cannot use violence to punish people for their ancestors' transgressions.
Unironically yes, they have the right to. Violence is a necessity. It would not be the Native Americans wanting to employ it. In this case they would have to use it if the colonialists refuse to peacefully return the land. That makes violence necessary and justified.
This theft has happened, there's no denying it. And no one has been punished or rehabilitated for it yet. This is something that still needs to happen. Capitalists will need to return everything they've stolen from the people over the centuries.
Not everyone is capable of leaving everything to go live in a commune or find a cooperative to work in. Some do and that's good.
There are problems with cooperatives competing with businesses. Corporations have an advantage over small businesses and that's true for cooperatives as well.
What really needs to happen is unions. Organized labor can fight capital directly rather than playing its game. You might be interested in the idea of a general strike.
I'll take not understanding anything about communism for 500, Alex.
I want to elucidate a little further. Marx predicted, mind you centuries ago, that it's the nature of the capitalist system to tend towards collapse. With each collapse, smaller firms fail and get eaten up by bigger ones. Today, it's very hard for independent brilliant minds without any wealth of their own to compete with the trans-national corporations who have the power to bend laws in their favor. Corporate consolidation is only growing and this will only become harder.
Even further, these companies have a permanent leg up for their access to foreign laborers that work under slave conditions, they're driven by profit-motives that allow them to ruthlessly disregard human interests for monetary ones and the environment. There are worker co-operatives, and they're very successful, but they don't always adhere to respecting the rules I mentioned above, because they still are mostly motivated by the profit motive! Where capital is introduced, you introduce individualist notions of success. What incentives do small business-owners of abandoning their dreams of becoming super-millionaires for the benefits of others? None. Capitalism is infectious, and to eliminate these cycles of exploitation it needs to be abolished completely.
Everything you mentioned are things communists do. Minus the ones glued to their computer chairs, successful communists are everywhere in their communities, expanding revolutionary class-consciousness while also fighting for reformist solutions.
What you are describing is utopian socialism, which was a school of thought which existed before Marx and Engel. Communism is specifically scientific socialism.
I suggest reading Socialism: Utopian or Scientific.
But you are also discribing Duel Power in which communists build a state apparatus along side the capitalist state but even then there still needs to be a revolutionary event in which one side takes over the other
Everybody getting together like that would itself be an act of revolution. Also, the world isn't fair and communist revolutions like you mentioned and the system surrounding it (capitalism) don't exist in bubbles. It wouldn't be a friendly competition between capitalism and communism, the US invades and overthrows socialist revolutions all over the world in the name of protecting US foreign interests. Not only that but there would be a heavy onslaught of propoganda against such a community, kinda like there is now. In reality, such a movement wouldn't even be allowed to gain steam, it would just be crushed.
You need to change class consciousness first. It is a large-scale (debatably global) event.
Basically just describing the types that live in communes at this point. This doesn't solve the problem of capitalism and its need to be abolished.
There is a 99.99 repeating chance of this never happening.
Any threat to the capitalist system as a whole is immediately dealt with. There is a reason that "communist countries" (even if they were never anywhere near communism or even going towards it) were attacked through physical war and economic hardships (sanctions, et al).
As if having no legitimate reason to complain has ever stopped anyone about anything.
Socialism nor communism can exist within capitalism. Even if you went exactly as you described, as impossible as that may be, you would still be operating under capitalist law and in some cases "beat up" by other capitalist players in the global system.
Let's pretend for a moment that socialism can exist within capitalism. That's called a worker cooperative. They exist already. They are worker owned and run enterprises that exist within the capitalist framework. They are already better in about every way to privately held businesses. So by your logic this should be the dominant system in the world today, but that's not how the world works. What is best is not what is always used.
Why? It happens all the time that poor people climb up and become rich, founding successful ventures. If you have a large group, the law of large numbers dictates that as a group you should be able to do this.
That's great, there should be more of those!
Specifically because you are operating within a capitalist framework (and the laws therein) and competing against capitalist businesses, which if it were a fair playing field wouldn't be a problem, but it isn't - the capitalists can and do use slaves, sweatshops, abuse national and international laws that were designed for them specifically, etc etc.
Worker cooperatives are great, and as I said do work better on average than other businesses, but that is on a business-to-business level. Once you incorporate the logistics of land/rent/towns/industries/etc into trying to create this hypothetical communist society within capitalism, the laws of the current system are working hard against you at that point and are subject to get worse.