r/DJs•
Kobinks

Am I the only one who doesn't play requests at all? (Rant)

I'm just wondering if this is remotely feasible, been doing a fair few club nights recently and I refuse to accept literally any requests anymore

I don't care if you know the manager I don't care if you're leaving after this song I don't care if you're going to complain I don't care if you think I'm shit

On no fucking planet am I going from 128 Bpm to Mr Brightside

This sort of bollocks is starting to wear me down i'm not Spotify, at this point I'm more than willing to lose all of my gigs and just say fuck you to all of this

Posted May 20, 2018, 10:21 AM UTC

60112
Timzor•

I generally don't play requests, but I always listen to them.

39
Tanaka-san•

Same. Sometime people will recommend something good which will fit the vibe of the set and it will work well.

I quite like Mr Scruff’s attitude towards requests

31

Yeah same here. I find I spend the entire night trying to work out what song will get the dance floor going. And then here is someone from the dance floor actually telling me. So why not play it?

17
Bluebuilder•

This is a nice balanced and respectful attitude.

6
blueberrymuffin420•

I play in clubs which don’t allow requests haha, that’s why you should become a techno dj ;)

34
M-Rich•

To be fair, most people at techno events and partys simply don't know most of the Tracks, sometimes even when they hear it every night they are out. Techno crowds are more in for the experiences. And If the request on of the popular songs the DJ mostly will have it anyway. I don't think that's bad, just to be clear.

Because of the big influx of localised EDM bubbles f.e. you will have way more "this Trap guy that I found in a small spotify list my friend does has 2000 Facebook Likes, why don't you know it" moments.

9
Tellor01House Techno Underground stuff•

Same in france for underground House venues in Paris there are no request

3
willbowen98•

Completely unrelated- could you possibly recommend me some cool spots in Paris for a Friday/Saturday night? I’m English and going with my brother & both of our girlfriends (we aren’t cunts)

2
Tellor01House Techno Underground stuff•

Of course but first what is you're type of music ? Commercial or maybe House Techno ?

1

very true, in my history of clubbing at techno events I've only seen one person ever make a request and she got sort of elbowed away by the crowd pretty quickly haha

7
ryeisadj•

I still got the “it’s my birthday” girl one night at my techno residency. Worst is she asked for Martin Garrix. I most likely was playing rominimal.

6
i_am_ghost7•

romanian minimal. rominimal. I like it :)

4
ryeisadj•

I like it more than micro house for sure!

3
EddieGrant•

Remixes ftw. I've had a similar thing and played a tech house remix of Animals. Same with Despacito.

0
ryeisadj•

I have some interesting remixes but not anything modern pop... I have this super cool Black Sabbath bootleg I’m excited to share with the dance floor.

2
soopadook•

why in the world did this get downvoted

1
i_am_ghost7•

hahaha, I couldn't play requests even if I wanted to. Unless that person has got a usb stick with rekordbox and the song on it (or the vinyl if it is a vinyl set), and I have an open usb slot on the cdj/xdj. And even then I would probably just tell them no. And they wouldn't even be able to approach the decks anyways unless they scrambled around somehow

2
trxracer•

I don't know a single DJ that does play requests...

13
blueberrymuffin420•

same here haha

4
StuntHacks•

I know some

1
EddieGrant•

I guess you don't know many DJs, haha. But seriously, there's so many types of DJs, plenty of pop DJs that will take requests. I do many styles, but primarily trance, and I've never had it during a trance gig, but sometimes I'd get facebook messages, or twitter DMs beforehand asking if I could "take" a certain song with me.

1
trxracer•

I own event companies in both California and Minnesota. We do everything from underground raves to weekly clubnights. Djs I know play everything from jungle, dnb, to trance and house. They have played everywhere from your college bar to the Sound Bar in Chicago. From the church basement to the warehouse rave. Pop music is the only time I could imagine requests being viable. That said I don't waste my time or my promoters time with it.

1
HonkyDonkyFunky Stuff•

What event company in MN do you own?

1
trxracer•

Opsec

1
Mellonote•

The best way I saw a club DJ deal with this was to use a clipboard with a pen and a 'Request sheet'. If ANYONE went up to the booth he'd just point to the clipboard, they'd drunkenly scribble down a song then go away. It was amazing.

12
REricDdit•

This is exactly what I do now. Except it doesn't work when there are super drunk bitches who refuse to write it down and just wanna yell at you over the music. I had to tell this one chick 5 times to write it down and they she threw a temper tantrum that I was "mean" and the "worst DJ ever" for not taking her request. Bitch almost spilled wine on my gear. I was pissed.

2
Beepboop00•

My High school Prom DJ did it the sane way. He would point to the clipboard whenever someone came up to him.

1
Meowingtons_H4X•

I've instead resorted to displaying a Snapchat QR code that people can message me track requests at - displaying the QR on any screens or on posters in the smoking area is there is one.

1
stringermm•

Theres always a few people in the place that didn't read the flyer or poster on the door. No, it's a disco night and I'm only playing records. I don't have any of the new childish gambino.

11
Agent17•

I don't get DJs who DON'T play request, its part of your job. As long it fits the night you should do it. It gets people on the dance floor, which should sell more drinks for the bar. Hell if anything it makes your job easier. I blame this on the whole mentality of "im not a dj, Im an artist" when in reality you're a giant wanker.

10†
Tim_TheoryDeep Trap, Future Airhorn, Ambient Gabber•

its part of your job

DJing isn't a job for me. I play music that I like and that I think people will like to dance to, and sometimes I'm invited to do that at parties or clubs or whatever. If people want to hear something that I don't have or wouldn't like to play, then they don't have to invite me.

14
[deleted]•

[deleted]

4
Tim_TheoryDeep Trap, Future Airhorn, Ambient Gabber•

Good question - only a few times a year.

5
[deleted]•

[deleted]

3
Pooptimist•

As a techno or house DJ it's your job to make people dance and freak out. They most likely come to hear the music selectiob the DJ plays. Going up there and requesting something would and should result in them getting kicked out

11
DerStahlRaumfahrer•

If you're paid to play house and somebody comes up and says they want to hear trap well they're shit out of luck.

Not everybody's an openformat DJ.

10
Agent17•

You did see where I said if it fits the night

8
KobinksOP•

My jobs to provide a night of house music, I cater to the vibe that that was advertised, If they want to listen to top 40 they should go to a top 40 club

8
ungr8ful_biscuit•

As a house DJ, you don’t need to play requests. As a top-40 Dj, you should at least listen. As a wedding DJ, if the bride asks, you play the request.

14
Armenoid•

Come on, please play Stardust

2
Sparkly1982•

Exactly this. I play top 40 at a couple of local bars, and my standard replies are "if I can fit it in" and "probably, in a bit". Unless, as happened the other day, someone fights their way across a packed dance floor to ask for House music. I like House music well enough, but seriously, take a look around. Also, no means no. Coming back 5 minutes later will not endear you to me.

2
saintpetejackboy•

My only issue with this, is when somebody starts to offer absurd amounts of money to play a certain track. I know of a guy from a while back in particular that used to come in and request some Bleeding Love track by Leona Lewis (I might be remembering the artist or track name wrong). Either way, it is the type of terrible track that will make most people look over to the booth and question the skills and judgment of the DJ.

His starting bid was always $20, and I'd seen him ratchet it all the way up to $100 before with enough resistance. Are you going to take that $100 and have everybody laugh at you? Is it worth it? Then it comes down to this, as my manager says: Are you more worried about YOUR pocket, or the venue's pocket?

If you strongly support the venue, the crowd and your reputation, you can politely decline the $100. Or, go try to find some kind of remix of their favorite song that fits more in the format, if one exists.

1
_skoinksDrum & Bass•

"I work in a bar as a human jukebox playing top 40"
Good for you mate, I play at events where people are there for the music, and the venue's profits are covered because we've paid them. Guess I'm a wanker because people come to hear my taste in music, good to know.

5
ebbomega•

It depends 100% on the vibe, the venue, and the crowd.

I'll listen to a request but most of the time I won't play it, because most of the time I won't have what they requested. Plain and simple.

I take it you've never been to an underground techno show?

4
saintpetejackboy•

If you are unable to quickly grab a track off of youtube and load it up onto your other table before the track you are playing is finished, either blame the venue for not having sufficient wifi, or blame something, because I have no problem taking requests all day and night for extremely absurd and obscure shit, and usually can download the track (and/or video) and fade it in before the track that is playing ends.

1
ebbomega•

If that works for you, you do you. But as a house/techno DJ I'm sometimes playing dicey venues where if you ask for the wifi password someone will laugh at you (rarely get WiFi out in the bush).

If you're open format/top 40 that makes sense. But frankly if someone asks me to download a track I've never heard off YouTube I'm going to tell them that's not how it works. Depending on how insistent they're being I may laugh at them.

2
saintpetejackboy•

Only thing i have learned to do is to check the lyrics for too much vulgarity, check the bpm and try to learn about the artists and genres. I mostly dj strip clubs, so i mainly get requests from girls who want to get naked to stuff. Most gitls these days, about 90 percent, like to dance to r&b or hip hop, with a few outliers that can and will dance to edm flavors or other genres. That said I never make girls dance to stuff they so not like, so i get creative with requests as much as possible and have learned how to divert requests over to similar but more acceptable tracks.

1
REricDdit•

You obviously haven't done a party where there are a ton of drunk annoying people who request non danceable horrible songs like "the theme from titanic"

3
WHSK3•

This is the biggest problem. I’m a full time DJ in a popular tourist area. Technically open format as it’s whatever the night calls for, but 90% of the time that means I’m a Top 40 DJ. Do I listen to requests? Every time. Do I actually play them? Rarely. And for only one reason. The vast majority of the requests are just plain bad. Either they don’t fit the mood of the room or they’re slow, dragging, non-club songs. If it’s “what the people want”, cool. Fine by me. But usually it’s what just 1 drunk person wants and it would dump the rest of my house.

3
saintpetejackboy•

Yeah, this is a common problem. One solution I've found to meet people somewhere in the middle is to find EDM remixes of those type of tracks.

I'm a strip club DJ, and I rarely make girls dance to stuff that they don't want to dance to, but very often, they make absolutely insane requests that do NOT fit the crowd, do NOT fit the format or are unplayable for other reasons (like I'd be fired for the vulgarity in the tracks during my shifts, as it is an up-scale establishment).

Finding clean versions of songs, finding remixes, those are some of the things I end up doing on a regular basis anyway. Tired of hearing "Mine" by Bazzi on a daily basis whenever one of four girls who like it gets on stage? Find all the remixes. I also refuse to play the same song twice during my 8-10 hour shift every day, but will sometimes make an exception for a remix of a song I've already played if enough time has passed or the crowd has rotated enough.

2
Tellor01House Techno Underground stuff•

But the crowd in commercial don't know anything about electronic music and have bad taste that's all

2

Depends on the type of DJing. If you're DJing a general purpose club night or a wedding or whatever, sure, yeah, you give the people what they want to hear. If you're performing at a specific show (rave, genre-themed show, etc.) then the crowd is there to hear YOU play your selections and a constructed set. You play what you want to play.

2
saintpetejackboy•

Even in circumstances like this, you may have initially not judged the crowd, or the time of night or where everybody is at mentally. You might launch into a super-high energy set, and expect to see everybody skanking out on the dance floor, and instead you notice a general malaise in the room and people not really paying attention, or starting to clear out, so you can make some adjustments, sticking in the same types of EDM, but lower your energy level a bit, or having something a bit more spacey come on for a second, or even something abrasive or very technical, to try and capture back lost attention.

DJs who go into a gig with a pre-set track list and set in a specific order mind as well have just have had the whole thing pre-recorded. It ignored the feedback loop between the crowd and the DJ to play that way, in my opinion.

A lot of people are out of touch, also. Especially in EDM. They prefer a certain type of EDM they got turned on about 10 or more years ago and then show up to a show where people are all half their age and expect their set is going to hit everybody with the razzle dazzle, and it doesn't. That is when it is good to have a thesaurus of similar tracks to what the other artists that night have had (or will have) success spinning.

1

Very true. I always have my "set list" that I intend to play, plus at least double or triple that in "rescue" tracks if my set starts going off the rails, whether I need to tone it down or up.

2
saintpetejackboy•

Yeah, I agree with this. I DJ probably 9+ hours a day, 5+ days a week. Requests are part of the job. The problem is that you have a whole set of DJs who think their job is to force everybody else to listen to what they like, instead of to play what the crowd wants to hear.

Wow! You took zero requests and one Edgelord in the back that spent $0 at the establishment complimented your choice of obscure garbage.

Versus, you played a show full of tracks you'd never play in your own home or ride, but the whole crowd was electric and enjoying themselves, and several customers came up to tip you and compliment you for your track selection or for playing their request (and then steering your set towards the tastes of the crowd).

DJ'ing is an active experience, it is a constant stream of feedback and adjustment. No matter the genre, the venue, or the crowd. DJ's who do not see that feedback loop are pretty much blind and deaf.

You don't have to honor all requests, but you should always take them into consideration and be friendly with the people coming into your establishment(s) and learn their name(s) and what they like and be able to identify them on future visits.

If you were such a great "artist", you'd be spinning sets of all your own original tracks you produced and headlining the event. If you're just a DJ and not also a producer, you should be taking requests, because at that point, you're just playing a playlist what you think sounds good and ignoring the fact that not everybody else in the place might want to listen to what you want to listen to.

Are you on tour? Play only your own tracks. Are you trying to get a residency or got invited out to an event to DJ? Do some research and play to the crowd.

2
drukenhard•
9
AgentDucky•

I happen to be a big fan of Bicep and own one of their T-Shirts so the only time I ever make a request is by pointing to the logo and winking at the DJ. Works every time!

5
djunagi•

I think the big thing most don't get is that djs vary in style. Not all will take your requests. If I'm at an underground, playing or attending, requests aren't happening. If I'm in a club and the booth is extremely accessible, I might expect requests. Same with wedding djs.

My answer is it depends on the environment. However I never take requests.

5
Tvoja_MankaBass•

What's 'an underground?'

1
djunagi•

As in those events in an unpermitted space. Could be in the mountains, a beach, a break in, etc.

1
LordPoopFart•

Completely depends on the venue. I bill myself as a “customer service” DJ for bars. I try hard to play requests and make the guests feel special. For the most part I play mainstream stuff anyway.

Managers love it because I don’t come across as one of those DJs who thinks his mix is so much more important than the guests getting what they want.

5
Rosskillington•

Why do so many DJ’s have so much animosity towards the crowd, if they weren’t there you wouldn’t be getting paid!

I listen to all requests, I play them if they fit with the set, simple. If someone gives me attitude then I won’t play it 🤷‍♂️

4
imLC•

You seem like you don't understand the role of a DJ. If you're at 128BPM you should realize a typical crowd even in the dance scene gets tired of kick drums on every quarter note. Learn to mix it up. Your job is to appease the crowd and that's about it unless you are also producing. Being a cunt won't get you anywhere as a DJ in the long run. All you have to offer as a DJ is entertainment through mixing and song selections that were made by actual artists. I'm not saying play all requests but also realize you are there to appease the crowd.

4
ZerkerOne•

I agree. Even if you refuse to play request you don’t have to be an absolute cunt. Just say “I’ll see if I can play it soon” or something

1
saintpetejackboy•

So much this. Being able to raise and lower the energy levels and introduce new elements can help capture lost attention or even direct new attention.

Two things humans like: things that are loud, and things they have heard before. A good DJ, IMO, should always be able to find a room-appropriate remix or two of a requested track (unless it is WAY off mark). There are so many EDM-variant genre mixes of popular tracks out there, that just a couple seconds vocal sample from the song they requested, if they've never heard the remix (or are unaware what a remix is, or if you are also mixing another record at the same time), makes you come off like a musical genius.

You know how many times I've played a remix and people thought that I was actually the one, live, with just turntables, performing the remix? It is astounding how little most of the general public knows about music and the capabilities of the DJ.

Pleasing the crowd s incredibly easy, especially if you focus them out and are able to really make somebody's day/night with your track selection catered around them.

1
soopadook•

its just contextual my dood

3
techsconvict•

I've been playing since around 98 and still don't take requests generally. If you're a tight friend or I'm playing a house party I will play a genre if you'd like but shy away from actual song requests, or if I do I queue it up to an appropriate time in the set.

Years ago I tried the wedding dj thing literally once. I was pestered to play "Yeah!" by Usher 7 times in a row and then nearly threatened by the groom's uncle because I wouldn't play Starland Vocal Band's "Afternoon Delight" in the middle of that. I watched the owner collect 3000 for the job, handed me $150, then got in his car and left. I did all the setup, all the set, and teardown. Never again I swore!

I played DnB back in the day, slowed a bit to electro breaks, and now finding myself playing a huge variety out now. Hip-hop to soul, bluegrass to ethnic folk music. I've played for myself and friends only and regret nothing. Seems the variety I like is also appreciated here in Oregon by older farts like myself. Must be the weed.

3
Armenoid•
2
DJworksalot•

I don't take requests, but it's useful to listen to get some direct info from the dancefloor. If I have an educated crowd, sometimes they've influenced the direction I go in.

And while I'm house/techno and can play pretty underground, I do carry a lot of edits and remixes of recognizable stuff to satisfy an audience that needs more accessible music.

2
PolyphonicChod•

It hardly ever happens. I've always said no, I've done a couple of weddings and it's much harder to say no there but I've found that mixing isn't as big a deal in those gigs anyway.

One time at a house party I had a pad and pen on a string taped to a shredder with a sign on it saying "Requests" which got a bit of a laugh most of all as latecomers who turned up late and already wasted actually feeding their slips in thinking it was actually an all request thing I guess.

2
johnnyhighschool•

I listen to all requests. I only play the few that are better than what I was planning to play next. As a DJ, you can't remember every song you have. Sometimes, the crowd remembers an old banger you HAVE to play. Listen to all, play few.

2
cleverkid•

You need the thin white duke remix of Mr Brightside. Having said that, always be really polite and just say you don't have that track, unless it's the million in one actual perfect suggestion for the moment. ( it does happen! :)

2
jayjak•

I feel like the majority of DJs who take requests are more bar DJs than club DJs. I play both fairly regularly and in a more relaxed bar style setting yea sure ill listen to what you have to say but probably only end up playing 15% but may take their general idea and play something similar. At the club? Screw off, I'm here to do my thing and that's why the club is paying me. If you want something else go to another club as I'm sure there is a line to get into this one.

2