bambarasta•

if and when LN becomes so widespread as to fuck the miners' revenues at that point there is no need to for BTC and you can have any coin to settle LN with. Or, you can just remove layer 1 because LN will be self contained and voila! You have modern banking again.

15
etherael•

voila! You have modern banking again.

[Ohhh no, that sucks.] (https://youtu.be/0S1jcjbGBZU)

1
donkeyDPpuncher•

Her intentions fall, to the floor.

2
joeknowswhoiam•

So in this scenario that has "a greater than 50% chance of coming true" according to the author, why is there no mention of:

  • The effect of the supposed success of LN on Bitcoin's price and the positive outcome it implies for miners' rewards valuation implicitly. Miners also have an interest in seeing the network function as efficiently as possible, it gives value to their rewards (and holdings for the ones who do keep them past their lock time).

  • The fact that miners can see an opportunity in running their own Lightning Network nodes and still collect some of these fees this way. They have full nodes at disposal and the requirements to run LN nodes are not really that costly.

  • The fact that there will still be a need for many transactions on the first layer even if LN is adopted by a lot of users because:

    1. Opening and closing LN channels require on-chain transactions.
    2. LN is, as described on its whitepaper is "a network of micropayment channels" (emphasis is mine), and transactions of large amounts of Bitcoin are not really the use case envisioned by the authors or the actual developers. While possible such transactions would have a harder time finding routes with sufficient liquidity unless everyone starts opening channels with large amounts, and unless this happen such transactions would be much easier on-chain.

It can be a fun thought experiment to make predictions like these, but honestly if the author is going to only look at the negative impact an event can have and discard anything positive it can bring you cannot really end up with a balanced and probable outcome... you just get a worst case scenario that is possibility but a very unlikely one (aka not "a greater than 50% chance of coming true").

1