Those who see worldly life as an obstacle to Dharma see no Dharma in everyday actions; they have not yet discovered that there are no everyday actions outside of Dharma. — Dōgen Zenji [1200–1253]
![Those who see worldly life as an obstacle to Dharma see no Dharma in everyday actions; they have not yet discovered that there are no everyday actions outside of Dharma. — Dōgen Zenji [1200–1253]](https://i.redd.it/uugngwhryg011.jpg)
Posted May 27, 2018, 9:52 PM UTC
![Those who see worldly life as an obstacle to Dharma see no Dharma in everyday actions; they have not yet discovered that there are no everyday actions outside of Dharma. — Dōgen Zenji [1200–1253]](https://i.redd.it/uugngwhryg011.jpg)
Posted May 27, 2018, 9:52 PM UTC
Bozos
According to the wikipedia on Huayan: the Chan school took influence from it and the page includes this tidbitidbit on the things about stuff.
According to Fox, the Fourfold Dharmadhatu is "four cognitive approaches to the world, four ways of apprehending reality".The four ways of seeing reality are:[16] [22]
All dharmas are seen as particular separate events or phenomena (shi 事). This is the mundane way of seeing.
All events are an expression of li (理, the absolute, principle or noumenon), which is associated with the concepts of shunyata, “One Mind” (yi xin 一心) and Buddha nature
Shi and Li interpenetrate (lishi wuai 理事無礙)
All events interpenetrate (shishi wuai 事事無礙), "all distinct phenomenal dharmas interfuse and penetrate in all ways" (Zongmi).
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Huayan_school
And in the Dharma article we find:
In Hinduism, dharma signifies behaviours that are considered to be in accord with Ṛta, the order that makes life and universe possible,[11][note 1] and includes duties, rights, laws, conduct, virtues and "right way of living".[1] In Buddhism, dharma means "cosmic law and order",[11] and is also applied to the teachings of the Buddha.[11]
Dharma in Jainism refers to the teachings of tirthankara (Jina)[11] and the body of doctrine pertaining to the purification and moral transformation of human beings. For Sikhs, the word dharm means the path of righteousness and proper religious practice.[13]
I'll add: https://i.redd.it/n27pm6omdwz01.jpg which I regard as the level above shishi wuai.
Similes of illusion being a level above the intermingling of phenomenal dharmas? Which way is up?
This is the perfect insight.
Those who seek anything past themselves in the name of Zen are misguided, Zen is everything.
"If you are unable to find the truth right where you are, where else do you expect to find it?"
-Dogen
Hey! You support a cult leader, right?
Are you willing to acknowledge that sex predators can't be Zen Masters?
So clumsy and obvious. That whole "sex predator" strategy of yours will never work against the Soto school of Zen, you know. What do you think people are going to do, abandon Soto over the words of an unskillful and abrasive troll over a real Zen lineage that is over 750 years old? hahahaha
Didn't anybody tell you not to feed the trolls Ronin?
I think you need some more 走 and less 言 [apologies to Chinese comrades if these don't mean what I think they do].
More "go" and less "saying"? I think I get it. Not bad.
Also, that is nearly impossible not to feed the trolls when they constantly chase you around, begging for scraps. I have much pity for them! haha
[deleted]
I was 100% sure I was going to see a certain recurrent comment pop up on the replies to this. Meh.. Good post. Just a shame it attracts the same old behavior on here..
Thank you. The forum is the same old forum, so it seems that there's always going to be some sort of argument or upset, no matter what someone presents. You get used to it.
I am used to it. Was just pointing out the obvious. It actually doesn’t bother me one bit. Everyone’s contributing to the best of their abilities.
If you really believed that Dogen was legit, you'd be posting and upvoting over at r/Soto.
You can't be a content brigadier and a sincere cult follower.
You realise YOU DON"T HAVE TO BELIEVE in Soto Zen to appreciate Dogen's insight right?
You are honestly such a perplexing figure ewk. Edit: imo, you don't seem to get that all this [buddhism/ zen / dhyana whatever] is just a vehicle. Have you heard the parable of the raft?
That's absolutely BS, dude.
That's like saying L. Ron Hubbard had insight into science.
Further, let's say Dogen, like Osho, was a cult leader, but hey, cult leaders can have good ideas, right?
Zen Masters reject "good ideas" as an opening gambit. That's the thing. You can't use play the "good idea" card in this forum.
Try r/perennialist. There is no science in Scientology.
Further, let's say Dogen, like Osho, was a cult leader, but hey, cult leaders can have good ideas, right?
Have you read or heard Osho? He is definitely a pretty transparent cultist but the only way he was capable of being such is because he had something to say that resonated with people. Its like I said before about the raft parable, idc what vehicle you use so long as you cross the river.
I post and upvote wherever I feel like it. It’s the whole shtick of the Internet.. FREEDOM. Ewk honest question.. no irony, no nothing to it.. Don’t you get tired of acting like the Zen police?
lol.
So... you can't address my comment?
You don't post or comment at r/Soto, but you do encourage content brigading?
Huh. It's not that I'm the police... it's that you don't seem to want to take the medicine you encourage others to take.
I replied to your comment. I post wherever I feel it’s appropriate or necessary. I think it’s pretty obvious I am a Soto Zen practitioner and we both know you and I don’t see eye to eye and never will. It just so happens that most content that pops up when I open Reddit comes from this sub .. if there was anything from r/Soto that popped up and I felt compelled to reply or comment I would. I would never encourage anyone to do something I wouldn’t.
Sadly it seems that it’s pointless to talk to you. Oh well.. have a good one ewk!
I'm not sure what you mean... was that aimed at me? I like to be absolutely certain about these things.
No.. I was replying to ewk.. I don’t know what happened!
Dude. You just said that content brigading is justified on religious grounds.
There is no coming back from that.
I would maybe consider replying if I had an idea of what this ‘content brigading’ thing meant.. which I don’t. So yeah..
Ewk is really a strange type of fellow, isn't he? He's so static and rigid in his ways. I even heard a rumor just yesterday that he just likes to mess with people's heads and isn't even a Zennist! haha
Let’s not pay attention to rumors. Ewk is Ewk.. strange? Meh.. who can say? Aren’t we all strange? 😄 rigid in his ways? Maybe.. but then again so are we. Does he like to mess with people’s heads? YEAH! Lol I am sure even ewk would say yes to that. Personally I feel like there’s nothing for him and me to discuss since we do it in 2 very incompatible ways. So then why bother and why create unnecessary tension?
Cool you find truth in his words, but in case he really was a sex predator, would that change them for you?
I'm not interested in adding pointless controversy; I'm interested in wisdom.
Most of us are. I don't think it's about controversy, more about whose words to trust. what if ..I don't know.. let's say Hitler had some words of truth on matters. Would that be wisdom as well? You think it would matter whose words they are? What about Ewks words ?
At this point, I would say that every person that has ever been born and lived long enough could share some wisdom. I try not to discriminate with wisdom if I can, and it usually is quite apparent when you hear it.
The thing is, for me at least, all the words I speak and hear are false per definition. It's just a finger pointing at the moon. They may or may not become true when you hear and process them. But it does matter who is saying it and whether their actions correspond with their words. Although I'm hesitant I might accept Hitler's words on zen if he'd have them, but definitely not on the topics he's so well known for. Are you familiar with occams broom?
[deleted]
Dressing up church pamphlets with pretty pictures and fancy words is an old trick. These preachers always expose themselves as pious windbags.
Some people never learn how to test themselves or anyone else. Mostly because they have an objective, and its an ideal, an ideology. Does zen have such an objective, such an ideal, such an ideology? Exposed!
What seems to be the problem with sprucing up the place every now and then with some art? Also, if someone doesn't find any merit in Dogen's teachings, then they are free to ignore them. People will find the historic teachings of the original Zen Masters when they want to.
Nothing wrong with nice pictures. Dressing up church pamphlets is was I said.
This is a subreddit about zen, not religion.
Don't worry; I try to get it right every now and then too.
Teachings like this would let the Dharma perish imo. You don't have to believe in a religious manner Soto Zen to appreciate Dogen's contribution as I see it.
What was Joshu's contribution? What was Mazu's contribution? What was Bodhidharma's contribution.
You are talking about religion. Why not study zen while you are here?
Dogen was the L. Ron Hubbard of Japan. The frauds, plagairism, and lying that he found necessary for starting his own cult have been well documented in texts like Dogen's Manuals of Zen Meditation, which proves that:
The OP knows all about this, and refuses to publicly state that sex predators aren't capable of transmitting the dharma... even though the OP isn't affiliated with Dogen's church at all (it's a troll thing). Check out his history of deleted comments/posts! He has used a bunch of different Reddit accounts over the years and often forgets to pretend otherwise:
WanderingRonin is a multiple accounts alt_troll and self-anointed "internet guru" who stalks and harasses people who expose his self-certification scam and content brigading. He also claims to be in touch with "modern Masters", by which he means new age spiritualists. Best part: WanderingRonin77 defends the enlightenments of "sex predator lineages". He thinks his made up religion is "powerful and effective" though, and people who say it is made up are "afraid". He is only a little proud of his harassment.. He had been surreptiously editing and deleting comments to cover his tracks, but now he is bragging about it because the forum no longer takes him seriously.
Trolls in this forum like to swear on their bibles... but they can't provide any textual support for their claims.
Watch and see. Trolls can't quote, cite, or source... and they can't disavow sex predators.
I genuinely appreciate the bulk of your comments, and feel that you’re a valuable contributor here, but I’m curious why any mention of Dogen sets you off so much. Nothing about this quote is problematic. Nothing mentions sexual predation or could be read as supporting that in any way.
In fact, the quote seems to be talking about the same concepts contained in the Blue Cliff Record and Gateless Gate. There is no evangelism of Dogen in either the picture or the quote posted here, other than the obvious promotion that comes with sharing someones words. Admittedly, OP has mentioned they are a Dogen fan in the comments, and I’m aware from past discussions here that they are, but it really just seems silly to respond to every single post that mentions Dogen with accusations that his modern lineage is full of rapists, when when no one is promoting Soto cults and even if Dogen had a good idea.
If an L Ron Hubbard quote supporting nuclear disarmament was provided, would I be wrong for agreeing with him?
TLDR: Isn’t it more interesting to discuss the idea itself rather than focusing criticism on the person who communicated that idea?
Since Ewk probably won't bother to respond to your thoughtful post, or say something flippant and disrespectful if he does, I'll share with you a few of my thoughts if you don't mind. Ewk seems to be on some sort of one-man crusade against anything to do with zazen meditation. Ewk thinks that Dogen was the creator of zazen and lied about his Zen lineage, therefore the entire Soto Japanese lineage and school of Zen created from Dogen is completely invalid. It is obvious that Ewk is trying to attach the term "sex predators" to the Soto school in a misguided effort to discredit or slander their good name.
Not trying to be argumentative, but I actually agree with many of his criticism of Soto and the connection to new age spirituality being “not zen.” They are well researched. They just don’t really have anything to do with the odd quote from Dogen that gets posted here that clearly indicates Dogen may have had some idea of what the zen masters were teaching, even if Dogen didn’t come to those realizations by actually speaking with zen masters.
That said, ewk clearly cares a lot about these issues and is undeniably educated on the topic. I’m just wondering, from his perspective, what the problem is with focusing on these ideas, because it seems to me like there’s probably a reason he feels like he needs to call this stuff out.
Well put. I think hes probably projecting. Perhaps hes to lazy to do zazen so hes decided hes going to argue its unnecessary for "awakening"- just btw, a term I think is pointless and not useful, to quote someone I consider "awakened" [again pointing out I think its silly and more of a barrier than anything- which makes sense I guess], awakening or liberation is:
a tale
Told by an idiot, full of sound and fury
Signifying nothing.
The fringes of Japanese zen are full of such characters, for whatever headache-inducing reason.
The problem with these sort of characters is that they siphon attention and energy away from where people should really be focused on, which is discussing and learning more about Zen. I feel that it would be quite unfortunate for someone new to Zen who comes into the forum in a genuine effort to learn about the subject.
If there isn't some larger scheme troll going on I would say that ewk is probably just lazy and bitter and doesn't want to/ cannot find/see the benefits of zazen. I mean the whole insight v concentration thing is just ridiculous- whoever takes a sectarian approach where one aspect is more important that the other is distorting the dharma and poisoning the sangha, imo. Concentration [zazen / chan/ dhyana/ Jhāna] and insight [Vipassana] are like two legs that help us walk to liberation. Yes insight can be sudden but without concentration it won't have effect, yes concentration can be pointless if not accompanied by insight.
Anyway as you like it.
I don't think you can argue that me typing the same thing two or three times a week is me being "set off". It's like answering fan mail at this point, since the people who post about Dogen are trolls.
Dogen, like Osho, "seems" to be talking about whatever has a paycheck.
Read FukanZazenGi. Read Pruning the Bodhi Tree. Find me a single Zen Master in the history of Japan.
Go for it.
PS. Your first mistake is assuming that there is "wisdom" to be discovered. There isn't. There is no analogue to nuclear disarmament in Zen... illiteracy is always the tricky bit, isn't it?
Your hypocrisy is disgusting,
put down your blunt sword,
take up the fight with yourself,
to let down everything.
No evidence? Just accusations?
Let me guess... you are ashamed and embarrassed to be caught in a church, sucking on the anti-historical dogma candy cane?
Get over it.
Read FukanZazenGi. Read Pruning the Bodhi Tree. Find me a single Zen Master in the history of Japan.
I read pruning the bodhi tree and really enjoyed it. I’m not claiming there are zen masters in Japan. I agree with your main criticism here.
PS. Your first mistake is assuming that there is "wisdom" to be discovered. There isn't. There is no analogue to nuclear disarmament in Zen... illiteracy is always the tricky bit, isn't it?
I’m genuinely confused by this. This quote seems to be talking about experiential realization and everyday tasks being done in an “enlightened” manner. Is that not the same thing zen masters have discussed?
I’m perfectly literate, just not as well versed in Zen literature as you :)
PS. I never met anybody before that said they "really enjoyed" Pruning the Bodhi Tree. I felt like I was in a graduate class in Buddhist studies that I didn't sign up for.
On that basis alone you should be on an advisory panel somewhere.
Okay. My point was this, which is referenced on the r/zen/wiki/buddhism page:
Buddhism requires faith, words, and the use of the [Buddhist wisdom] to choose the truth... the Zen allergy to the use of words is [Zen not Buddhism]. -Hakamaya, Critical Soto Buddhist
I think this works for Buddhism as a whole. I think Buddhists require wisdom and truth for their doctrine to work. Zen Masters reject both wisdom generally, and metaphysical truth specifically.
There is no "enlightened manner"... at least in the Shunryu Suzuki sense. Zen Masters repeatedly preference the ordinary and disdain the notion of the enlightened.
Although you wield some power, you are simply a bad leader and that is why your way eventually loses over time. One of your most glaring oversights is in only punishing people who post threads about subjects that you see as unfit, while ignoring when someone actually does get it right and post about verified Zen Masters. That's part of the reason that I'll never bow down and follow what you have to say.
It's supposed to be the carrot and the stick, remember? If you only use the stick to beat people when you see them as wrong, then you are only sowing the seeds of discontent and revolution becomes inevitable. I'm actually somewhat surprised that you don't know any of this, or is it that you just don't care?
You're on the wrong subreddit, dude
Nope. r/Soto. That's the only place where frauds and sex predators are safe from criticism about their messiah.
Rinzai does zazen ykno
Now you're labelling the people who simply mention Dogen's teachings as sex predators...
Nope. I'm saying that people who won't disavow sex predators have no place in civil society.
Holy hell, ewk is evolving.
Nah. I've been typing the same schtick to the same new age trolls for years now. I can do it in my sleep. They are afraid of books, so they try to talk smack about me... but the books crush them. It's the high school book report standard... to think of all the time I could have saved by just becoming a high school teacher at Troll Academy.
Notice that the OP can't provide a single reason, cite a single source, to establish Dogen's link to Zen.
Just like L. Ron Hubbard couldn't prove he was related to aliens, or Jesus to Yaway.
They are afraid of books
A special transmission outside the scriptures
Not founded upon words and letters;
By pointing directly to [one's] mind
It lets one see into [one's own true] nature and [thus] attain Buddhahood
...so your point is, they shouldn't be afraid, because nothing in a book is going to be a foundation?
I agree.
What is interesting is that the E.W.K. 2.0 ZenVirusX is evolving into something a little more, human perhaps... which makes him a slight bit more of a threat than usual. He has been studying certain behavioral patterns of his perceived anti-virus human enemies such as myself in attempt to seem a little bit more random and personable. Every now and then, you may even hear him share a "joke" in an attempt to seem non-threatening.
Do you know who you’re talking to?
Do I ever? Probably myself, but why do you ask?
Dōgen was not a fraud, and it has not been "well established that Dōgen has lied repeatedly during his short career" whatsoever. It merely seems that you made up your mind first about Dōgen, and then went looking for misinformation to support your case against him. This is opinionated fraud and libel against Dōgen, who will accomplish far more than you ever will as an r/zen troll. Where is the proof of any of this, and what are your sources? Furthermore, why do you tend to ignore any information that refutes these claims? Since you obviously can't argue against a single thing that I've shared here, you try to distract everyone with inflammatory and false rhetoric. Not everyone falls for such tactics.
The fact that you blatantly spew vile rhetoric about Dōgen as establishing a "sex predator lineage" makes your lies blatantly obvious to anyone with a rational and logical mind. Dōgen lived over 750 years ago, and to my knowledge there is no known record of any such behavior from him. You are practicing an ancient technique as old as war itself: you are creating an enemy in both myself and anyone in support of Dōgen in order to further your own cause and consolidate your power as a cultist leader. This is much in the same way as North Korea and Iran paint the United States as a larger-than-life enemy in order to distract their people from the real evils of their own governments and continue their subjugation unchecked.
For everyone else reading this, pay careful attention to Ewk and his tactics from this point forward. Not a single thing I've said here will actually be argued against, because Ewk has already played his hand. He will not challenge the information presented to him in any rational way, and he merely ignores anyone who truly challenges him in an effort to retain his power and control over anyone that he can in the Zen community. Those who follow Ewk before following their own path in Zen or the actual texts of the Zen Masters are making a mistake of epic proportions, merely falling into the trap of an obvious self-centered cultist. Nearly all discussions here are turned back to Ewk in some way, and if not he will make it about him by interfering with them nearly every single time.
Yeah, it's gross and pathetic... He's a loser to extreme proportions. Even if he was right his desperate attempts to tear down anything not perfectly aligned with his thinking is so juvenile and unattractive
But remember, how we deal with our enemies is also how we deal with ourselves in the end. Ewk is a person, and although his tactics are deplorable, we must see that he is still the essence of buddha nature just like ourselves. Have some compassion for him, because it is also good to consider what extreme situations could have brought him to this state in the first place.
Troll with 2 week old account says anybody speaking out against cults is "gross and pathetic".
lol.
Pwnd.
You're right. I feel shit about saying that... :/ Honestly, I don't know what came over me... Lucky I held myself back from posting this other dumb thing. Sorry for being a jerk
This guy's an idiot, don't listen to him ^
Uhhh, why do you care so much?
Why do born again christians get shut down in r/science?
On a side note, what do you think of Eagle in a Snowstorm? I've wondered every now and then if you actually have an appreciation for the arts, and the only thing I've heard of you liking so far is tea. Can we not talk every now and then and learn from each other? I'd like to get to know my enemies better since we spend so much time focused on battle.
Getting Sun Tzu vibes. Are you preparing for war by attempting to establish peace? editted
That didn't actually answer my question.
There is nothing about Christianity within scientific articles on the internet (so a Christian poster on r/science is pulling the connection out of their arse); whereas, you do find Dogen in zen articles, warranted or not. He's there! That's going to create interest in whatever he purports.
Why do you care so much as to attach your spiel to everything on this sub which is remotely outside of your opinions and world-view?
Anyone who's a true reader and researcher of zen will no doubt come to the same conclusion as you, wouldn't they? And everyone who only explores zen on a surface level, well it shouldn't really matter; they obviously don't really care to get deeper than that.
Effectively, your audience is the people that already agree with you. Everyone else just sees this obscene roadblock. You're discouraging people from exploring further by making this place seem like an aggressive shit show. Maybe that's your intention; unfortunately, that would categorise you as one of your own contemptible "trolls".
If you can't present a reasonable answer for your motivations that isn't ad hominen, then I'm forced to believe you're just one of the trolls.
Your argument fails since there is faux science that mentions Jesus.
Obviously my audience is diverse... here you are, trying out your poor logic on me.
Ewk is the ultimate troll, and nothing we ever do can change him. What may have some effect is if people like you and me continue to stay here and fight the good fight. If enough people work together here for the common good of the forum, we can drown out his rhetoric and get to the more important matter of discussing Zen.
I obviously don't want to advocate for sex predators, but I have been wondering for quite some time now:
Since you say that Zen Masters don't talk about moral and ethics and this is rather a Buddhist concept, whereas Zen Masters focus on non- duality and not creating concepts of good and evil, wouldn't it according to this not really matter if a zen masters engaged in sexual misconduct?
I don't want this sounding wrong, but just from a logical point of view if Zen unequals morality (including good and evil) and Zen Masters have cut up a cat in half to make a point, why would then some other bad thing (in this case sexual misconduct) matter?
I feel like I haven't really understood this yet
Zen Masters are public in their actions and discussions... sex predators aren't.
Further, while Zen Masters are non-moral, the religious cultists claim to follow the 8FP. So, obvi there is a problem... they can either have church or have Zen, but not both.
I'm fine with Dogen's religion being Buddhist and ordaining their priests, they just can't claim that ordained priests are Zen Masters, nor can they claim that sex predators can transmit the dharma while sex predatoring.
I sort of get it. but then:
we only know what has been publicly done and said by Zen Masters, because their students followed them in their public life, so I am not really sure if you can say that Zen Masters in general are public in their actions.
I would assume that some students of Zen Masters have done some immoral and bad things. So the fact that Suzuki (if I remember correctly) has given dharma transmission to someone who would later engage in sexual misconduct, doenst really mean Zen Masters never had a bad student under their wings, because you can't really look into someones future. I would understand the argument that only a true Zen Master could see something equal in another person and therefore wouldn't make this mistake, but I am not sure if that argument really convinces me.
I get the last part about: they can be whatever they want just don't call yourself Zen Master.
but the thing with saying no morality in Zen and then finding an evil behaviour as not Zen still seems counterintuitive to me.
Disagree. You have no evidence, and the texts offer evidence that contradicts you.
Shunryu Suzuki said a guy was enlightened. The guy turned out to be a sex predator. That means Shunryu was either a liar or an idiot, neither of those is compatible with being a Zen Master. Plus Shuryu admitted in his book that his church wasn't Zen: r/zen/wiki/fraudulent_texts.
It's two parts:
a) Zen Masters' records do not allow for secret relationships that involve lying to spouses, congregations, and the public. Nor do Zen Masters' records allow "forgiveness ceremonies" or a status as a teacher that allows one to not be accountable.
b) If Dogen's church ordains teachers, then that isn't being a Zen Master. If Dogen's church gives dharma transmission, then being a sex predator invalidates that transmission (and all students thereafter).
As usual, Dogen is right on point. I enjoy the painting which illustrates Dogen's insights perfectly.
Thank you for posting.
No problem at all, my friend. It's a great day, isn't it? All in all, those who can understand Dogen will understand him. There's a certain power and flow that I saw in this Japanese woodblock print, which is titled Eagle in a Snowstorm, 1933 by Koson, so I knew I had to share it with the forum. I appreciate your support.
Thank you for sharing.
No, thank you for your support.
kicks you in the shin
WHAT SUPPORT?!
"All in all those who can understand Dogen will understand him"
Dogen emphasized sitting zazen 4 times a day to get some understanding of zen. He would recommend even more if it wasnt for the work that needed to be done to survive daily. He felt it was the essence of zen. A pioneer of zazen.
You denounce zazen. LoL. You have no idea where Dogen is coming from.
Are gonna address this, or are you too busy sleeping?
If zazen works so well, why are you so obviously unsettled?
Its Dogen that feels zazen is the essence of zen. You think otherwise. And than your making claims that you understand where hes coming from but you couldn't sit zazen past 15 mins if your life depended on it. Lmao.
Its a joke already dude, im not unsettled, im laughing at this point.
Creepy religious troll claims cultist "on point".
So Dogen is a cultist now? Does your depravity know no end?
On a side note, good morning, Ewk.
Both of you obvi spend way to much time on the internet imo.
You're totally right, and it's a bad habit that I'm trying to overcome. Now that I'm getting more of a feel for what this forum is good for and what it's not, I'm going to start trying to cut back on it.