Why doesn’t valve just use per particle damage for the flamethrower?
Posted May 28, 2018, 4:10 PM UTC
195
Posted May 28, 2018, 4:10 PM UTC
They wanted to make the DPS more consistent.
If your opponent is standing in the fire visual, they take fire damage, i like it better that way honestly
Back when that was how they worked, it was super inconsistent. Now that JI tweaked the flame particles themselves (i.e speeding them up, toning down momentum inheritance & letting them linger) it’s possible we could go back to that, which could make it easier to skill-index the flamethrower’s damage compared to the current ‘check’ system. Risky, but possible.
Was the damage-per-particle system the main cause of the inconsistency issue? In the old system, did particles disappear as soon as it hit the target?
Edit: grammar, question
The hitboxes did disappear once they hit something, but there were other issues that caused the inconsistencies. There was a serious disconnect between the flames' visual particles and the actual hitboxes (i.e visual particles would bounce and run along walls & edges while the hitboxes stopped the moment they hit something). The momentum inheritance on particles (which is still there to some extent, to make sure the flamethrower's range stays consistent) was really extreme as well, so the places your particles went often depended more on your movement than your crosshair placement, making tracking feel awful. There was also an issue the community called 'Flamethrower Mojo', which could cause ridiculous disconnects between where the visual particles end and where the hitboxes end due to ping fluctuations. If you wanna learn more, check out guys like TMP and HA Johnny on Youtube (KenonArtulii and Whispy, the Whistling Pyro respectively) who have some great videos explaining the issues with old flame particles.