Greatsword (UGS) OR Great Club

So I like both weapon, but unsure which one to stay with. Sadly, the OCD in me is irked by the 2 WHOLE POINTS WASTED if I do choose GC. I know it ultimately doesn't matter tho. Point is, which one is better for PVP / PVE.

Yes, I know they are slow and can be easily parried, but I want something hard hitting and big. Not compensating or anything lmao

So, which one is better overall? No zwei since I want a weapon with "GREAT" in the name

Posted May 29, 2018, 1:04 AM UTC · edited

110
Cerokun•

Don’t forget Demon Great Axe and Great Machete.

3
Blood_AddledOPCurrent char.: Moon, If you find me, duel me!!!•

But I don't like axes, although Great Machete does have Great on the name.

1
Cerokun•

I’m typically not a fan of them either, but the DGA has a space launch R2. It’s so much fun to land.

1
Blood_AddledOPCurrent char.: Moon, If you find me, duel me!!!•

Thanks! I'll check it out

1
barneezyjoneswhat's for breakfast?•

Great club! Way better backstabs, way better rolling attack (breaks infinite poise, up to 161 full havels armor + wolf ring monsters) just don’t ever whiff your r1 attacks, or it’s a free backstab!

The only redeeming factor on the greatsword is the r2 thrust; yea it does huge damage, bonkers when paired with Leo ring, but really only works against baiting out attacks from slower weapons, aka it’s a cool gimmick, not much more.

2
Blood_AddledOPCurrent char.: Moon, If you find me, duel me!!!•

Greatsword can let you aim the r1 with a wide arc. You can also manually aim the R2 until the last second. Now that makes the decision harder!

But you are right, Great Club backstabs, even without hornet make it extra deadly. and the rolling r1 is nice, but I rarely roll since I am mid-rolling. This isn't Roll Souls 3 mate

2
barneezyjoneswhat's for breakfast?•

Oof, mid roll does make the rolling attacks almost negligible. Tough call then, greatsword would be the more fun to use between the two, as pretty much the whole move set is viable.

3
Blood_AddledOPCurrent char.: Moon, If you find me, duel me!!!•

I did notice the clubs arc is mostly down and narrow, which would suck against ganks, which now are the norm for ANY invasion.

I know people hate midrolling, but if you barely roll, it does work for poising thru mostly anything at higher END. Rolling in DS1 is a mixed bag, yes MIGHT dodge the attack or get backstab'd

1
Wespie•

I chose great club for DSR. I have 600 hours on the weapon in DS3, but finally I’m trying something different and using strength / faith with +15 and buff. Not leveling endurance once, so running around naked. I’m enjoying it a lot and PVE is very easy so long as you can roll iframe everything. It just comes down to style man, forget which is “better,” this is Dark Souls!

1
Blood_AddledOPCurrent char.: Moon, If you find me, duel me!!!•

STR/FTH is the best, same build but with END and Faith for buff. I would not run around naked with no poise tho, but you are a madman!

1