Chat is completely and utterly broken now

[Discussion] -- Developer response

I'm not sure who it was that "updated" the chat suppression mechanic, but as pretty much every one knows, it is completely broken now.

I'm in a party with one other person, in AB, trying to ping the Chak Hollow waypoint ([&BEkIAAA=]) and getting "Your message was suppressed due to excessive messaging". This is absurd. If I'm in a party with one other person, why the hell am I getting suppressed? Furthermore, if I try to send a waypoint to that person in a private message, I get the "The player is already in another party, squad, or guild" error, which tells me that whoever wrote this new chat suppression system really screwed it up.

In an online game, based heavily on communication between players, this is beyond unacceptable. u/ChrisCleary claimed here that this was fixed, but it very clearly is not.

Posted Jun 7, 2018, 8:20 PM UTC · edited

465116
ChrisClearyTip of the Sword•

Looking into this more now. It seems there's something specifically going wrong only with chat links. It doesn't seem that standard text is getting suppressed in moderated channels but chat links are (by moderated, I'm referring to player "owned" and operated channels). Apologies, we'll get this fixed, but first we need to find out what's going on.

For clarification - Chat Link suppression is suppose to occur in non Moderated channels (Say/Map and eventually Team). If suppression is occurring in Party/Team/Squad chat right now that doesn't involve chat links, it would be great if you could take a screenshot and share it here.

Extra clarification - This system is designed to allow us to change the previous suppression system into something that we can control at a much more granular level on a channel by channel basis. It'll be tuned on each channel in a way that it won't impact standard chat practices for those channels and game modes. Right now we feel that the current levels are in need of tuning, but this will happen over time and with feedback. The chat links in the moderated channels are triggering suppression that's outside of what is actually defined for those channels, and that's a bug.

127
maybenguyenWeaver? I haven't heard that name in years...•

Please please please do not put this in team chat. This kind of system does not belong in team chat. There are many reasons to spam a waypoint link in team chat. The very few times I've had a problem with someone spamming random chat codes in team chat, I muted them and moved on. It wasn't even a mild inconvenience, so this less than a mild inconvenience does not warrant a system to stop them from doing it again.

190
man_0fbassheal scourge OP?•

Seconded, EWPs need to be spammed.

49
Keorlgw2organizer.com•

I usually spam it several times ... in a single message. Visible enough. You don't actually need to spam. For this, use shift instead of ctrl.

7

No, thank you. I like for the EWP to take up the entire chat box. No sarcasm. It's way more important than whatever else is going on in chat, and it disappears fast enough that the call-out won't last for that long anyways.

It's helps to snag the attention of less attentive WvW players as well since really all you need are a bunch of bodies.

5
JasonLucasFurry is legal•

I have had some problems with people spamming in WvW team chat, but it's very rare, perhaps we could get a more passive suppression for team chat, but when triggered is more aggressive. So, only people who spam absurd amounts of chat links without non-stop are caught and suppressed for a long time.

8
MithranArkanere🌟 SUGGEST-A-TRON•

At the very least waypoint, objective and point of interest links should never get one's chat rights suppressed in team, map and squad chat, just collapsed into a single line if repeated.
Let people block spammers themselves. It would be even better if there was a "temporary" block that blocks only for the current game session in addition to the current permanent one, when you just want to shut up someone annyoing for a bit, but don't care for them enough for a permanent block.

Ideally suppression would prevent you from linking any more chat links, but take longer for writing without chat links and still allow you to write without links until you get the separate spam cap..

7
scienceboyroy•

I think he meant that if you keep doing it, eventually the suppressor is triggered.

1
Funkativity•

There are many reasons to spam a waypoint link in team chat.

no, there isn't

spam is never useful

-64
momoa1999Thicc Support•

Double or triple spamming a waypoint draws more attention to it than just a single link.

54
slippycheeze•

Spamming them 1,000 times draws even more. Shall we start doing that, then?

-45
Funkativity•

no, not really.

and the more people do it, the more it clutters chat channels which leads people to turn them off to reduce noise, thus reducing the effectiveness of said channels.

also, the people that will "double or triple" spam rarely stop at that amount. when people spam waypoints it's usually much closer to a dozen times than twice.

-56
morroIan•

Spoken as someone who doesn't play WvW when an emergency waypoint is triggered.

22
Funkativity•

no, spoken as someone that frequently has to turn Team off because spammers are creating too much noise and Map tactical info is getting drowned out.

having more than one EWP link doesn't make it any easier to use.

-30
FloweryFluff•

But how will I know that Bay in red BL is about to fall when I'm all the way over in EBG?

6
RadiantVes•

bay doesn't exist in RBL ;(

-2
theotherdanlynch•

Why is Party chat ever moderated at all? It's MY party, not yours. I'll decide if somebody should be removed from the party for spamming chat.

Why is Squad chat ever moderated at all? It's my squad. I'll decide if somebody should be removed for spamming chat.

Even worse, in what freaky parallel universe would it ever make sense for a Squad leader or lieutenant to get suppressed in squad chat for any reason? If I'm the Squad leader and I decide to spam 400 chat links in 12 seconds, it's my damned squad! What happens in the squad chat of MY SQUAD is none of your concern.

92
KondibonIt's not sand it's salt. My salt.•

I think he meant player moderated.

18
HealyUnitOPbrb lab on fire 🔥•

It's MY party, not yours.

I completely agree with you, but I couldn't help but read this bit like this dude: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=YoaUjUCQbMo

9
theotherdanlynch•

LMAO

2
TehAn0mollieNuReddit is fugly•

There is no access control to, nor ability to remove anyone from, team, map or say chat... I think that's what he meant by them being "non moderated."

When he said "moderation" I think he was speaking of fellow party/squad members ability to kick others, rather than Anet staff or whatever auto-mod-like functions (like spam detection/suppression) may run on the chat server.

I did have to read it a couple times though.

4
vicolgnr1•

I would like to give you more upvotes, cause I understand you and hate this "chat mechanic" that much, as well!

1
choconnects•

An extra perm to have mentor and party to appoint leader (comm tag) where chat can be moderated via mute individual in squad or party would suffice. Rest I'm in agreement with you.

1
Zarzhar•

I think it was made clear that suppression isn't intended for party and squad chat, and that it is a bug so you can calm down about it.

1
ExsOhs•

I think this is a performance measure. A way to reduce requests fired from the client to the server.

I think this is how it works, but i might be wrong...

For each ping you fire a request to the server which has an impact. So if in a second 500 palyers ping 5 times its 1000 x 5 requests 5000 in that second.

Its a lot... This way we might get better server health. But maybe I am completely wrong here...

1
theotherdanlynch•

Chat is handled by different servers than game-play. At least, that's the way it worked during the early years of GW2. No idea if that changed.

1
gulesaveDamn the Meta•

It's my party, and I'll spam if I want to,

Spam if I want to,

Spaa~aam if I want to.

1
theotherdanlynch•

lol

1
indigo121Dra Keln.2015•

He just said it was a bug chill out

1
xtian88•

Well apparently someone didn't ready the TOS .

Hate to break it to ya bud, but you signed your life away and anet owns EVERYTHING. You don't own anything not your account, not your gems, nuthin.

-13
SaiyanOfDarknessRIP What.CD, You Will Be Missed :(•

eventually Team

RIP.. EWP spam lol

25
scienceboyroy•

I think he meant that if you keep doing it, eventually the suppressor is triggered.

1
HealyUnitOPbrb lab on fire 🔥•

Hey Chris, thanks for responding. Unfortunately, this seems to be a "it's fixed now that you don't look at it" issue (i.e., I can't get it to reliably break now). I did submit a bug report/in game screenshot via the report thinger, but basically:

  1. I was in a party with a friend. Just me and her. We were going around Auric Basin, doing mastery points/map stuff.
  2. During this, I'd often ping a waypoint - i.e., Chak Hollow Waypoint - usually just once to be like "let's start from there for the next thing".
  3. We fought the Chak Lobster HP just south of that WP
  4. I ran to Southwatch Waypoint, which I did not have.
  5. I pinged the Chak Hollow waypoint, and was suppressed.

I'd also note that I was switching between local and party chat a bit during the Chak fight. I don't think it'd be enough to reasonably trigger a spam filter (I'd said stuff like "Stand up here" twice, and that's about it), but I do realize that me saying it doesn't particularly help the issue.

Lemme know if you need more info. I can probly try to run another character thru AB or TD and see if/when i get suppressed. Oddly, as you said, it did not occur with normal text; I could type out messages normally. It only occurred when sending a chat link. I also noticed it sending me the "This person's already in a group" error when i tried to directly ping them the link via PM.

10
DarkLeafzThe Dark•

Can you fix the LFG Suppression?

Example: I want to do a test Fractal run with specific classes (Druid,Berserker,Thief,Engi).

I add those classes to my LFG and remove each once one of the listed classes after they join the party.

Sadly after the 3rd LFG editing to remove the thief from the list i will get suppressed.

And if a wrong class joins and i will have to re-add thief to the list - I wont be able to due to suppression.

Either remove LFG suppression or make it so we get suppressed after 10 LFG edits or so.

8
BackIsBachus•

Before it is fixed there is a "trick" that allows you to go around this LFG update supression. Let's say you are in the Fractal lobby and your LFG update gets suppressed, go out of the lobby to LA (or Mistlock or whatever) and then your LFG "rate limit" has been sorta reset. Same goes for Raids where you can go back to the Aerodrome if the LFG get supressed and you are in the wing (basically going to another map/instance does the trick).

3
AnzeG[PORT] Guild leader•

Or just go to character select and back and completely reset it

3
2girls1upOneUP.3024 | Quantify [qT]•

This is the one i hate the most. Then pugs join and you have to tel them that you dont need dps and they get angry because your lfg said dps.

2
JkTyrantExalted Legend•

Don't see what the problem was to begin with. Apart from a few trolls, it wasn't really an eyesore. A small group of folks were effected at best, now you have the entire population being effected...

6
thevogonityO Freddled Gruntbuggly•

affected

0†
blocodents•

Party chat and the Commander's voice on the Squad should not be surpressed in any way. There is absolutely no reason for it.

5
RLellingOpenCommunity Admin•

If suppression is occurring in Party/Team/Squad chat right now that doesn't involve chat links, it would be great if you could take a screenshot and share it here.

This to me implies that the intended place for bug reports - the bug report function - just gets ignored. Otherwise you would not need screenshots here, since we've been sending reports about this from the hour the patch hit, when we got suppressed in squad chat for linking waypoints during a bounty hunt run (the suppression was all chat wide, btw, so couldn't even link them in another chat afterwards).

3
gaspara112•

He already has a direct link to this. Collating tons of similar/identical bug reports is difficult and finding the precise one of those tons of bug reports on the same thing to get to the screenshots can also be difficult.

So its much easier to come back here to find the screenshot then to say post a bug report and then come here to tell me which bug report to look at.

1
Rainwhisker•

Well, no, because if the bug report feature actually was in a usable and/or useful state, then the bug report list is -all- that you need to look at, no need for reddit at all.

3
gaspara112•

They don't look at reddit specifically for bugs they look at reddit for fun but occasionally they see something that applies to them on it.

So, yes, the bug report list all they "need" to look at but coming across a bug reported elsewhere doesn't mean they will just ignore it.

1
Ilyavi•

Or maybe you can stop all of this and just leave the chat system untouched and functional like it was T_T

3
[deleted]•

[deleted]

1
Triglby•

i noticed after i sent like 1 or 2 links that my next message was surpressed

1
Yung_Chipotle•

Applying suppression to team chat will be greatly detrimental to wvw as suppression is far too aggressive.

1
angelar_•

I have troubles with this even with trying to link a list of waypoints for daily mining in a private guild. The suppression is also so criminally long that I literally just cannot even go about what I'm trying to do. It's aggravating and pointless. Normal players shouldn't ever have this issue in average use.

If it's that much of a pain to make it work in a way that isn't obstructive to normal gameplay, then make an "echo" channel like on FFXIV that prints a message in chat only for the person sending it and don't apply any spam control to it.

1
Blue23345•

Didn't Bless Online -just- get a lot of flak for having a very similar problem involving excessive chat moderation? All of their players have been fleeing and a lot of them have been looking to Guild Wars 2 as their alternative.

Do you really want this to be the first thing they see? 4 chat links (WITHIN AN HOUR), and suddenly you can't link -anything- for an obscenely long time?

Map chat, sure; say chat, sure; party chat, uuuuh no?

If you have a problem with someone spamming, you block them and the issue goes away.

If you have a problem with wanting to send waypoints or skills to someone or some group of people whom you are trying to guide but can't because of suppression... that -is- a real problem. You can't do anything about that unless you plan to PM EVERY single person with the same information (By the way using the up arrow doesn't copy the links, so you have to link all over again every time!)

Seriously, was any thought even put into this change before it was implemented?

0†
Zanai•

Of course thought was put in. It's a bug, bugs are by their very nature unintended. This wasn't a design decision

-2
HGLatinBoy•

and while you're at it can you add Chat Bubbles to /team. I'd like to tell my teammates in a PVP match something without them having to look at the chat box.

-2
HealyUnitOPbrb lab on fire 🔥•

Chat Bubbles

I assume that's when the deep sea dragon gets really talkative?

5
ocathalain.6791 •

Pretty sure it's still broken. I pinged my portal twice in squad chat for Escort earlier and was suppressed. Not being able to communicate quickly afterwards that I wanted people to stack made it much harder than it needed to be, and the suppression was still there 20+ minutes later. If this is "fixed", it needs to be much more lenient.

121
antm753•

but it very clearly cleary is not

FTFY

36
mammothxing•

Why would they implement such changes in the first place? What’s was wrong before?

26
Heukalyptusbring back the aura visual 2K18•

conspiracy theory : dev joined raid squad, didn't have KP to spam-ping, gets kicked, make it impossible to spam-ping again

53
isairr•

With how stupid and pointless change this is.. I'm willing to belive this.

25
Hrafhildr•

Typical "Let's fix something that isn't broke oops we made it worse" nonsense you see a lot in games.

17
BackIsBachus•

I'm willing to guess it was some update/fine-tuning that resulted on unexpected side-effect for chat codes specifically.

0
Incrediblezagzag•

They've suggested that the change was needed to fix some kind of bug/exploit that was allowing people to bypass suppression.

0
FroudactylHA HA wait what?•

It's been awhile since this happened, but we had a few individuals in wvw bypassing the old chat filter with chat links. They flooded the chat with a macro spamming links and they did it so fast that you couldn't even block the person as the chat moved so fast. Only way to block them was to switch maps, block and go back to the one you were in. Doesn't sound too bad, but this is a bit troublesome if the flooding happens when there are long map queues and a keep is under attack. Cheap tactics, but also effective as nobody can tell what is happening and where.

0
King_MarioOnly one character, only one life•

What I don't get is why do I get this "Your message was suppressed due to excessive messaging" message when I'm

  1. The Commander in my squad of 30+ people who are doing bounty/SW/META trains.
  2. Only linking WPs and Abilities
  3. Im ONLY talking in my Squad Chat

I really don't know why this change was made.

16
morroIan•

Reading Chris's reply its a bug. His post isn't clear but it seems there shouldn't be any suppression in squad chat.

2
RLellingOpenCommunity Admin•

We already weren't able to mail guildies quickly (sending a newsletter to 400 members takes ~7 hours due to having to avoid suppression), now we can't whisper our guildies properly, and can't command in squad chat anymore.

Looks like Anet just wants us to stand vaguely next to each other, never communicate, and just play solo while other players are essentially NPCs that help us kill stuff.

8
ciyanax•

I have played this game since launch. 5+ yrs already. And never Have I ever run into a situation where someone spam squad/party/whisper chat to the point that makes me feel like it's a problem. Who the heck on anet side decided that this game warranted this change?

You wanna make some useful changes on squad/party? How about give us option to blacklist someone from joining that particular party so we can stop the FOTM troll until the party is disbanded? Or automatically blocks someone who blocks you so there's no idiotic whisper block unlock whisper block unblock harassment?

This looks like someone sat on the computer behind the scene and said "hey guys, it looks like people are "abusing" this link command so let's restrict it without considering any contexts whatsoever!". Too much free time, anet?

6
Raadfast•

i haven't had any of these bugs happen to me, while whispering and getting whispered to. I was in a party with a new player yesterday and guided him around "spamming" information to him to help out.

Are the bugs only related to squad?

5
ninja_slothreddit•

It's not intentional, they know it's still broken and are working to fix it.

5
Purple_Miku•

Yeah this is stupid, I pinged literally two items in party chat and bam... message suppressed and I'm forced to use whisper to talk to them for like the next 10+ minutes...

5
RLellingOpenCommunity Admin•

Glad you could even use whisper. You now get suppressed after whispering 3 different people in short succession.

3
2girls1upOneUP.3024 | Quantify [qT]•

I can't even ping a whole armor set. After 3 pieces I get blocked. Have to ping everything with shift

5
thevogonityO Freddled Gruntbuggly•

Why don't you ping all six in a single message?

0†
Reynbou•

I find it looks much cleaner with each piece on a new line, as well as easier to click each piece on a new line.

Having it all on a single line looks messy.

It's very minor, yeah, but not something that should cause a chat restriction.

1†
EchoFalls27Cockney Girl Gamer. Loud, random and ASD•

Becsuse some pug groups require a spam to try and prove it's not a chat code I think

1
xAtri[DONE][SLAY][iNs]•

Though this is kinda a good thing, I hate people who ping every single piece in a different message.

And in most cases pinging a single piece of gear is as good as pinging the whole set.

-9
2girls1upOneUP.3024 | Quantify [qT]•

well its how me and my friends do stuff between each other and we like it that way. Its not like we are spamming all chat with it

2
WyvornCharr Master Race•

As someone who raids, not really. Ctrl+click is essential so you can tell the difference between someone who actually has the armour and thus fits your lfg requirements and someone who copy-pasted a few chatcodes from wiki in hopes of getting carried.

The suppression should have never made it into squad/party chats.

0†
howaboutsomefish•

Not sure if someone mentioned this yet, but if you try to link something from the trading post in party chat or whisper you get a message that tells you you cannot do that from your current location, i went to orr, ebonhawk and lion's arch still get the same thing which is really annoying.

4
GunnhoCthulhu fhtagn ^(;,;)^•

often during guild missions, we talk amongst ourselves with a lot of chat, for the leader to get thru to us, he will spam a chat wall of the WP we're supposed to go to. the spam wall is big enough to interrupt our chat to be noticed.

i really appreciate this spam wall in chat or i might have missed the wp

please dont remove the leaders spam wall in chat.

4
sipso3•

Great testing as usual.

4
dons90SECOND CROWS•

While we're at it, can the suppression mechanic be lifted for mails and LFG? It's incredibly frustrating when I try to gift things to guildies/friends and having to wait up to 90s after sending just 2 items.....

4
Qweeerty•

I got suppresed in pvp, lol ANET#WINNING

3
LiliOnRedi•

Intresting "change/fix" or w/e just before the WvW week... Who needs to communicate in WvW ;o

3
turbochoco•

Had to leave couple fractal groups cus i couldnt link kp for like 15 min after my firts group fell apart.

3
Qlii256•

Exactly! It was supposed to be hotfixed, but I have noticed no change at all. I do Auric Basin event runs and I just have to type the waypoint everytime we move, pinging does not work, not after 1 hour and then trying again, it's just telling me that it's being filtered because of excessive messaging. They really need to fix that asap. It's super annoying that people have to open their map, search for that specific waypoint, new guys already forgot the name, have to close map, check chat, reopen (and map opening is slow with animation). It's just not fun to command in open world anymore. I wonder how WvW is right now :O

3
nexolight•

I demand that these changes get reverted ASAP!

I'm not a communicative person and did not run into it yet. But this is just an utter garbage concept in such a game.

One can customize the chat tabs and channels and there's not even much annoying spam in map chat. Most of the time it's entertaining.

This system has a great negative impact on the game experience.

How and why the heck did you came up with that ANet?

2