How to make good Chord Progressions
Posted Jun 12, 2018, 6:14 PM UTC
Posted Jun 12, 2018, 6:14 PM UTC
What did we learn ... major/minor chords, what a 7th is, what an inversion is. Voice leading (although you didn't call it that) but you missed out the specifics of good voice leading. Does any of that tell us about how to write a good 4 or 8 bar chord progression? Not really. Still, I don't know what I expected for 3 minutes. The good news is that it was quite funny. Maybe go into comedy?
Thank you for the criticism! I was trying to give people tips on what type of chord progressions you can make and also how you can change them for the better which I think is pretty usefull for beginners. However I should have maybe broken down the chord progressions more into detail with the though process behind it etc.
What's good voice leading?
You are covering a big topic so you will need many videos to get the detail in there :) I like this guys channel as an example: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=HLVt5xWOVyM Honestly you should do purely humour videos based on news and stuff, that was the best part of the video (your editing). Edit: oh and voice leading, there are some good rules of thumb like no parallel octaves and 5ths, and some others like don't duplicate 7ths or 3rds. Rules are made to be broken of course, too, but understanding what makes good voice leading is a big topic.
Oh my god, that video just changed my whole perspective about laying down melodies and harmonies i hear in my mind.
Thank youu
Glad you enjoyed! Whenever I watch his video I realise there is so much I don't know, but it also gets me started on thinking about composition in a much deeper way. It helps that he explains things very well and is a great musician to boot. The short chord progression he whips up in the video is really amazing.
Good voice leading is a subject that is very context specific. What’s good voice leading for a i - ii^ø4/2 chord change won’t be the same for a i - V^4/3 chord change. Harmony textbooks primarily deal with context specific voiceleading along with harmonic function, and if you’re interested here is a definitive resource, a good primer resource and a condensed list of voiceleading rules.
Have you considered not making tutorials about things you clearly know almost nothing about?
What was wrong about the tips?
You introduce major and minor chords by saying it's the gap between the notes that makes them major and minor, but then contradict yourself by talking about inversions later in the video.
Power chords are chords without the third, whether the octave is there or not doesn't matter.
The idea about semitone steps is kinda interesting and I hadn't thought of before but there are much more common and obvious ways of building tension, like functional harmony, dominant chords etc.
Not all seventh chords are common in future bass and you made no effort to distinguish between major, minor, dominant sevenths etc which makes a huge difference to the chord sound
You kinda have the ultra basics of voice leading in there but don't know the words to describe it.
Idk if I understand you correct. It is that gap between the notes that makes them major/minor chord. But if I invert them of course the gap might change but it will still be minor/major..?
Every metal song always has 2 octaves and a 5 when I made that music so I actually though that was the case. So yes you are correct the extra octave was unnecessary.
Semitone thing is just something I learned on my own, I don't really have any known theory behind more than I know it works for me. So yes there should be a better way to explain it.
About the seventh being a future bass chord is a bit of a joke, but generally future bass chords have more than a triad being it 7th 9th or a 11th etc.
I've not looked into voice leading so yeah I don't know about that.
Thanks for criticism, I appreciate it!
The clickbaity title kinda pissed me off, sorry to be so harsh.
There are three common kinds of 7th chords: major 7th, minor 7th, and dominant 7th, which all have really different sounds and uses. You really should specify which one you're talking about because it makes a huge difference.
There's also no mention of what a chord progression is and how to intergrate it into a track, which I feel is really essential on such a basic video. People will go away thinking all chords are block chords.
Who hurt you my dude?
Learn jazz
yeah sure ok give me about 6 years
[deleted]
Thanks for putting out straightforward content for noobs like me, disregard the snobs. You're doing a rad public service, keep doing you brother 🤙.
Ah of course, the requisite "pointing out misinformation = snobbery" comment.
Thank you! :-)
So no one should criticize him?
Super helpful thanks brother!
[deleted]
the ending tho....rofl
Great vid, but primarily 'cos of how engaging and entertaining it is, rather than the info itself (although it does give some useful tips pretty quickly). Nice editing, man!
I don't understand shit about music theory. What I normally do is pick a scale like the one with E, F#, G#, A, B, C#, and D# (don't know what it's called...) then place notes while skipping a key or two when placing a note until it sounds good, but make sure you pay attention to your root note the most. I also motivate anyone to steal chords when they can, but just see to that you change it a bit so it doesn't sound cliché
Im going to be hyper critical about this for a second, but I would like to pretext this with the statement that I really did enjoy the style of this video, and I have become a subscriber. I just hate to see factually incorrect advice being thrown around.
I fail to see how semitone changes = tension. I have not heard of this concept in any harmony book I’ve ever read, unfortunately. Tension in progressions comes first and foremost from the context of the specific chord in a progression or the horizontal composition of the chord (major sonority vs a diminished one, for example). The example you used to demonstrate the difference between semitone steps and whole steps could be more accurately described as a difference in chordal contexts and horizontal structures.
When counting semitones between notes, you count from the first semitone to the destination note itself. So a major 3rd above a C would be 4 semitones apart. While you are correct about there being 3 semitones between the chords, this isn’t what is commonly practice and can lead to confusion for people that read up more on this subject.
“Chord Cuddling”, is a really funny term for voice leading. I might start using that because of how cute it is. I think expanding on voice leading technique would have been a good idea, or atleast giving people a good resource to expand their knowledge on it.
The first part of this is not true, a chord inversion is when you use a note in your chord, besides the root, as the new bass. Simply flipping notes around besides the bass changes the chords voicing, not inversion (in your example progression of I^6/4 - iii - IV^6 - V^6, you moved the 5th of the your V^6 an octave up, this did not create a new inversion but Instead an open voicing). It’s also important to note that when you move the bass of your previously iii^6/4 chord an 8va up, you create a root position triad, not an inversion. I can see this coming off as very confusing for newbies.
While you are correct about inversions creating a new feeling and sound for chords, it would be more understanding to classify inversions as creating more unstable chords due to the lack of the root being in the bass.
Despite all of this, I really enjoyed the editing of this video. You kept me engaged the whole way through and your intros antics genuinely made me lol. I would suggest reading more deeply into the subjects that you’re going to talk about before making a (very well done) video about it. Taking about harmonic functions, modal mixture, cadences, sub dominants, chromatic Harmony, chordal extensions beyond a 7th and voiceleading would be more concrete topics for a video like this.
These are the moments when I realise how bad I am at music theory.
About the semitone changes = tension is honestly something I realised myself. Like I said in the video it depends on what kind of chord progression you have just like you mentioned now. However I don't know the theory behind it more than it works for me. But you explained it now!
Thanks for clearing up difference between voicing and inversions.
I might do a followup with the things you mentioned in the end if I ever have the motivation to read more in depth about it. Thank you for the huge feedback and I'm glad you liked the parts that wasn't wrong haha!
So why are you making a video about it filled with misinformation? Really...this is such a problem in this sub. People giving out advice about things they don't know a lot about. I'm far from a music theory master, I know enough to be competent, but I have the self awareness to know that I probably shouldn't be teaching advanced jazz harmony on Youtube.
It's great that you want to help people and all, but like, it's important to have some perspective.
Agreed. There are definitely some good posts in this sub about mixing techniques and stuff, but the music theory posts are usually terrible.
How to make a good chord progression? Study theory and take some piano lessons.
**OR STEAL THEM CHORDS!!! **