[iChase]World of Warships - Boise WiP - Disappointing
Posted Jun 17, 2018, 4:58 AM UTC
Posted Jun 17, 2018, 4:58 AM UTC
I still don't understand why this ship is being made a Pan-American ship. WG is missing out on a lot of potential sales (me included if it gets buffed) from players that need a USN cruiser trainer for the new line. It will be useless as a captain trainer for the Pan-American line until WG makes a full tree for them, which is highly unlikely.
I still don’t understand why people don’t want to see another nation (nations) added to the game. If you want a USN CL trainer buy Atlanta, she’s a great fit.
Think of it this way, if you buy Boise and train up a 19 point captain, when (if) we get a full Pan American line you’ll have a 19 pointer ready to go. Which will have made it a great captain trainer.
I still don’t understand why people don’t want to see another nation (nations) added to the game. If you want a USN CL trainer buy Atlanta, she’s a great fit.
I don't understand people that don't see how we can have both USN Boise and its ARA version. We already have Graf Spee and HSF Graf Spee, Tachibana and Tachibana Lima, Kamekaze-R & Fujin, Kongo/Myoko/Atago and their ARP equivalents.
Release both, and let people choose which one they want to buy, WG get the maximum number of sales and people who enjoy the ship and have too much cash might even buy both, minimal work on WG's part required( different camo scheme is all that's needed).
That’s a reasonable suggestion. Though I would say that all of your examples remain their same nation as far as crew training goes? Also I would think if WG do that they might to make the ships slightly different.
Dedicated captain for a "nation" with no other ship
Warspite was out forever before we saw any tech tree British ships. Lo Yang and Anshan the same for PA.
I’ve not done the research but I have some vague recollection that there is a reasonable amount of ships to build a Pan American line.
Well I have several reasons.
The Boise had a much more interesting service career in the USN than it did as an Argentinian ship.
The Atlanta doesn't work well as a cruiser captain trainer due to the need for a specialized build and costs $41 to buy.
The chance of seeing a full Pan-American cruiser line is extremely low given that there simply isn't really anything to add.
Furthermore, if a line were to be added I highly doubt it would be another HE focused light cruiser line. This means that the Boise would be an unfitting captain trainer unless they made some weird tweaks to make the Boise use the same build as the mainline ships.
Why not just sell it as both a US version and South America? It's not like we don't already have cross nation clones.
Why not just sell it as both a US version and Pan Asian?
I didn't know Argentina was part of Asia.
LoL spaced there. Fixed.
WG turned this ship from an instabuy into a neverbuy.
Interesting.
I like that WG won't just release an otherwise unmodified tech tree ship + radar as a premium, but it seems just a tad overnerfed.
In my opinion... they should just throw out the radar and modify her otherwise - but since that's not going to happen:
I'd suggest re-adjusting the speed and turning radius to Helena values, keep the range nerf and maybe slightly buff the reload to 9-9.5 seconds (not that 10 is so bad, if you have 15 barrels).
EDIT: Knowing WG, their solution will probably be to nerf Helena. Don't downvote the messenger... /s
10 second reload puts her equal to Schores for HE DPM but Schores has longer range and much higher velocity guns so she can stay at range and put that DPM to much better use. 10 second reload with USN arcs will make her the lowest average damage T7 cruiser easily.
But Schors is made of paper. Paper and citadel.
And Helena doesnt have any speakable armour neither, besides 13.6 Km range is way too short
Helena is made of paper too and it needs to be much closer to engage targets so can’t dodge well at all either.
Imo losing the range is worse than the reload. Not having as much DPM sucks but not having range as a light cruiser is crippling.
Indianapolis also give up much compared to the New Orlean to get the radar, seem fair.
On the other hand there is the Belfast...
[deleted]
Armor, it gives up loads of armor
10 Sec reload are OK she is like a mogami with 155 and trades radar for torps and speed Wich is ok I think.
It's likely played like a mogami or cleaveland sit back and wait until everybody has lost theyr aggressions and you can hunt them down
Actually playing the Mogami is easier than Boise despite the radar, you are 4.5 knts faster, you still have better range fully upgraded, you are also stealthier due to the T8 upgrade slot, and hitting target with Mogami will be easier thanks to higher muzzle velocity on the 155 and you don't have the American arc thingy going on the Mogami, even with slower turret travel time Mogami still has the advantage for having a better turret layout. Idk about you but I'll play Mogami over this any day ¯_(ツ)_/¯.
I know I'm comparing a T8 ship to a T7 but hell, I'll even play the Helena over the Boise.
Wait, iChase is in CC program again?
AFAIK List of things you give up on the Boise for Radar(compared to Helena)
Without considering this will go into the game as a Pan-Am ship with associated restrictions: have to level up a new 19pt captain and unable to participate in Operation Hermes.
This is fixed, now both ships have turning radius of 710m. Boise also now have faster rotating turrets, 18sec to 22.5sec, and way better dispersion, 99m to 133m.
I agree that Boise is sacrificing a lot for that radar, but radar is very powerful tool, especially 9.9km one at T7. Boise detection could be lowered to 10.1km with CE which mean that when she is spotted she could almost radar and see who is spotting her. I agree that range is mediocre and should be increased to be at least same as Helena. I also agree that speed should be increased to. Brooklyn class could manage 32.5kn so I don't see why WG would nerf it to 30kn. But I'm against increase of RoF. If you want a ships with higher RoF play Helena, if you want a radar ships with more precise guns play Boise. That should be trade.
For 25sec of radar duration, Boise can shoot 2, in same case 3 salvos. That is 30 to 45 152mm shells. Considering that T5-T6 DDs have between 10k-13k HP, some stock version have even bellow 10k, this, while maybe not be enough to kill DD by herself, is enough to cripple a DD and make it useless for the rest of the game. Especially considering that improved dispersion.
Increase range and speed, maybe tweak some other parameters but keep RoF and she should be a decent ship. In the end premium ship could be buffed but very hardly nerfed.
The range is BAD, the only T7 Cruiser with a worse range is AFT Atlanta/Flint by 300 meters and Atlanta can use a lot more islands than Boise thanks to its higher arc. Helena's range is what you call mediocre, not Boise's
Indianapolis(not going to argue this is a OP ship are you?) as-is have 10% less DPM than New Orleans(14.3s vs 13s reload) and also 700 meter more range(16.9 vs 16.2km). On the other hand Boise loses both 17% DPM and 1000 meter in range for its radar and also 1 less consumable slot(Boise have to chose between Hydro and DFAA instead of having both, whereas Indianapolis can have every consumable New Orleans get).
Both are cases of a Radar Premium getting a trade-off in DPM for radar so it should be equalized, Boise should have 10% (9.3s reload) and not 17% less DPM than Helena, and it should have slightly more range(15.2km) not less than Helena, the difference in speed should be equalized as well, the dispersion buff can go away for all I care so long as the range is improved.