Questions About Open PVP Servers
I've been playing MMO's since I was nearly 7 years old (I'm now 25), but I've never actually played on a dedicated open PVP server as I've always been a somewhat casual PVE player. Recently, though, the idea has started seeming very interesting to me. Since I've seen quite a few folks around here advocating for one or more of these types of servers, I figure they'd be pretty familiar with how these servers work, and I have some questions about 'em. My questions are mostly about what sort of restrictions are usually in place, if any:
- Can anyone actually be attacked by anyone else, anywhere and at any time? Or does it tend to be limited to certain areas with everywhere else being safe zones? The former sounds pretty exciting.
- Are there typically restrictions on what players you can attack based on level difference, faction, race, alignment or equipment?
- Does there tend to be leaderboards for these servers? If so, would there be restrictions based on leaderboard rating/ranking?
- Do mechanics such as invisibility or healing tend to break the balance of things or kill the fun of it? Is it usually better/more fun for classes and such to be perfectly (as much as possible) balanced or is it actually ideal for there to be wild imbalances between classes that make them more niche and specialized, or is the ideal somewhere between the two?
- Other PVP games are sometimes plagued by rampant trolls and griefers. Is this a major problem for MMO PVP servers as well? How do you avoid or counter these types of players?
- How strict is the "open" part of an open PVP server? If I'm grouped/raiding with other players, do your abilities only affect mobs and players outside the group or is "friendly fire" on permanently?
- Are there usually rewards for killing players beyond just feeling the satisfaction of besting another person? For instance, looting other players' items, gaining influence or bounty, faction hits, experience, etc.
- Can you recommend any MMO's that are playable now with open PVP that I can try out and see for myself?
That's it for now. I'm just looking for answers based on people's experiences specifically playing MMO's with Open PVP. Thanks for reading. I'm really considering making a server like this my home because it sounds adrenaline-pumping and unpredictable. Even if I do, I'll probably still have some toons on a PVE server to play with my friends anyway.
Posted Jun 21, 2018, 11:48 PM UTC · edited
I'd like to start out answering you by pointing out that there are all sorts of PvP 'flavors' as it were, from a variety of games and what not. Understand that I've played just about every 'old school' MMORPG out there and several newer ones, and played on PvP servers every time (though, some did not have a distinct PvP vs PvE environment, some were just mixed anyway) and I don't really know what works best long term, but I'll answer to the best of my ability here.
The most typical style of PvP server is the FFA/Faction based, meaning wild west anywhere, anytime style of PvP so long as its against an enemy faction. This is what you see in most games since World of Warcraft and kind of taken as 'the norm'. There are some games with PvP servers that have certain safe zones, such as guard protected areas/cities that PvP isn't possible, or is more or less strictly prohibited via guard whack (insta kill) when you do attack a player.
In a FFA/Faction environment, typically no there is no restriction except maybe a Faction (2 or 3 of them) war style (WoW, DAoC, some old EQ servers), but there have been some games with only restrictions in terms of level difference (Rallos/Sullon Zek from Everquest servers come to mind for this mostly). In level based games, I feel for the sake of anti-grief and a more sense of journey and less rush to end game atmosphere, you WANT level restriction PvP, otherwise people get a bad taste in their mouths for PvP. Being low level and being ganked by high levels isn't fun at all and just ends up being frustrating. That isn't what PvP is about to me personally (though obviously lots of people love to do it, so it remains a feature in most MMORPGs today). The problems with dealing with level base restrictions is having proper features in place to deal with out of range healers -- ex: Theres a 5 level difference for PvP, I'm 50, my target is 45, he has a healer friend who is level 42 and is healing him while I fight the 45. I cannot do anything to the level 42, so I typically lose or leave. One way to deal with this is to make it so after one or two heals, you are flagged to anyone in combat with that person, making you attackable by them for up to X seconds/minutes, etc. Easy enough to code, in most games (I've done it).
Sometimes there will be leaderboards, not typically for the open world kills, etc, but sometimes. Usually its more for arena/battleground stuff.
I don't think PvP gets ruined or breaks balance from invisibility/stealth or healers, etc, no more so than classes that have high burst and can kill quickly. It just brings a more interesting dynamic to combat. Typically, the best way to balance PvP is to think in terms of Group vs Group rather than individual Class vs Class.
Absolutely, there are griefers and trolls in any game you'll play. That said, in a game like Pantheon (and Everquest, FFXI, etc. The more rugged/classic style) you'll run into less riff raff due to the fact it takes longer to progress and get to the point where you can really be a dick. That said, it's a toss up really depending on content and class features. It'll happen. The only real way to deal with the trolls/griefers is to not play with them. Leave, go elsewhere, etc., or beat THEM into submission using their own tactics if necessary. Prime examples of this would be 'train wars' in Everquest back in the day. Monks, Necros, Clerics and Shadowknights constantly training mobs on people/groups until they leave or find a way to deal with them. It happens, but you learn to adapt. Once you get frustrated, you've already lost and its better to just move on and not frustrate yourself any longer.
Friendly Fire is completely dependent on mechanics/features and rulesets really. It's a toss up on if it makes sense or not. Typically I think its best if AoE mechanics do not affect your group, but that's just my personal opinion -- it leaves more room for better group play/fun. That said, it really depends on the features/abilities, etc.
Rewards for killing people really depend on the ruleset and such, again. Sometimes its just honor/a sense of accomplishment or satisfaction. Sometimes, you get to loot a piece of gear. Sometimes, the loot you get from someone is random off them. Other times, it's completely full loot everything. Just depends on the game and ruleset. In my personal opinion, you need a risk vs reward when it comes to PvP servers. If there is no risk, it makes griefers that much more prevalent since they have nothing to lose other than their time (and if they are spending their time griefing, they probably don't value theirs). Having some risk (whether it be losing EXP on death to both PvE and PvP, losing an/some/all items, having a corpse run that makes it hard to get back into playing your character again, etc) just makes you take the game more serious and in general you'll have a better time with the game. Having things on the line makes for a better atmosphere than not having ANY risk at all.
There are a few that I could suggest. I am unsure if its allowed here or not so Moderators, feel free to strike this if its not allowed, but here are a few I'd recommend checking out (some are open/ffa with some restrictions, some are faction based, etc): Albion Online, Ultima Online (emulator or otherwise), Project 1999 Red (Everquest emulator server w/ PvP -- there are other solid PvP emulators within the EQEmulator community), Dark Age of Camelot, Darkfall (New Dawn or Rise of Agon, they are pretty poor games in general but the PvP is very fun. They are slowly getting better, but they are remakes of an old failed game at any rate), Legends of Aria, some WoW emulators (Project Ascension), Gran Skrae Online is a new indie game that looks promising for an old school MMO feel.
As you can see, most of those are old games with emulators, but to be fair very few newer games (within the last few years) offer what I am looking for in an 'open' PvP game. I know I'm niche, I know the majority of people looking for a game like Pantheon (remake of EQ basically) are niche players. It is what it is, I like what I like, sadly I am definitely in the minority. PvP in a game like Everquest was just fantastic, because it was straight up an afterthought. The best PvP games are the ones with good PvE roots, and typically end up being a wonderful mistake/accident (Ultima Online's pvp, Asheron's Call, Everquest, etc). I think this is something most "PvP" MMORPGs of the last few years have forgotten and just haven't really been able to replicate from decades ago.
Hope this helped spark some interest in a PvP server for you. Hope to see you on Pantheon's :)
Thanks for the detailed reply. It was helpful. :)
I kinda noticed this as well. WildStar was like that as well. It was definitely meant to be a game heavily focused on PVE content, but I ended up having a blast in their battlegrounds to my surprise. That's actually what kinda sparked my interest in MMO PVP. Then they started actually focusing development on PVP which might have been a bit of a mistake, though in the end it didn't really matter. From what I've heard WoW took a similar path as well, but with much greater success obviously. I feel like in a game like Pantheon, the experience could really benefit from open PVP. Of course players are already competing over completing PVE content but being able to actually duke it out with other guilds/groups would probably add a whole other layer to it that I just hadn't thought about before when I played EQ a ton. It sounds awesome to me.
You're absolutely welcome!
You're very right in regards to Pantheon benefiting from having an open PvP ruleset/server. There is a niche to be filled there for one thing, and you really don't need to add much extra side development time save for a few choice things depending on how some features go.
PvP in Everquest added a really awesome layer on top of the base game, being able to fight over spawns and raids, being able to lock people out of a zone you really want to farm etc., having to be on your toes is just a great addition to it all.
> Absolutely, there are griefers and trolls in any game you'll play. That said, in a game like Pantheon (and Everquest, FFXI, etc. The more rugged/classic style) you'll run into less riff raff due to the fact it takes longer to progress and get to the point where you can really be a dick. That said, it's a toss up really depending on content and class features. It'll happen. The only real way to deal with the trolls/griefers is to not play with them. Leave, go elsewhere, etc., or beat THEM into submission using their own tactics if necessary. Prime examples of this would be 'train wars' in Everquest back in the day. Monks, Necros, Clerics and Shadowknights constantly training mobs on people/groups until they leave or find a way to deal with them. It happens, but you learn to adapt. Once you get frustrated, you've already lost and its better to just move on and not frustrate yourself any longer.
One thing I think has to be pointed out is that there are those who for some paradoxical reason, join PvP servers, purposely and knowingly, even though their attitudes clearly indicate that they believe PvP is inherently and innately toxic, and that they believe they are being griefed if they are attacked even once. Once per day, week, month, they don't care. I think the views of such players have to be low-weighted accordingly when it comes to pvp.
I also think it's the duty of the gaming company to provide a sandbox PvP environment where there is some form of innate balance achieved through game mechanics that apply 100% of the time, because they're the laws of nature and physics in the game, NOT rules that can be applied differently for different people or by different CSRs. What I mean by balance is NOT achieving some sort of 1:1 power ratio among every class, because that is an impossible task; what I mean is, for example:
there should not be level 50s ganking level 5, a +-4 level range would be much more reasonable. This would cut a lot of the potential corpse camping right there
Hardcore people will disagree til the end of time, but maybe respawning with gear should be seriously reconsidered for PvP servers. Being PvP makes it pretty hardcore right there.
XP gain could be more on PvP servers could be more than PvE to account for time spent PvPing. Isn't there a precedent for doing this in some games already?
If training is allowed (I would like to say it shouldn't be, but, I can see how it would cause overload on CSRs), XP loss on PvP server deaths could be reduced. I mean PvE deaths; I don't personally believe in actual player kills causing XP loss, at least not on standard PvP servers. Maybe on Sullon-zek type hardcore servers.
as far as PvP-enabled zones, I kind of like how EQ turned out - there's a very few zones where PvP doesn't work (like PoK, nexus, bazaar) but nearly everywhere else it's enabled. Guards in cities will defend people with better faction (though the EQ AI on that point could stand to be improved a bit). Some cities might have complete anti-violence policies regardless of standing.
With things like the above in place to provide some minimal form of balance, I think a server should not have rules against corpse camping, KOSing, or even persistently pursuing your enemies (I've never seen a server with a rule against chasing someone all night long, but, you never know what people will come up with).
It also depends on how the game works in terms of, is it possible to escape/avoid enemies? If someone that's better geared than you pops a SoW-potion equivalent and you don't have one, does that mean you're toast even if you see them coming from a mile away and still can't get away? That's probably not good design either.