{Set} Protocol Tokens as Collateral

{Set} Protocol provides some smart contracts that let users bundle different tokens together into a new ERC20 token. The benefits to such an abstraction are many and the whitepaper covers those in detail.

Could {Set} tokens be considered as a collateral type? I suppose each Set would have to be considered individually and I don't know what types of technical challenges might come with it, but the idea of creating a CDP with a diversified basket of assets as its collateral seems like a very appealing idea that falls in line with Maker's own design ideas.

Posted Jun 25, 2018, 11:19 AM UTC

214
Rune4444•

Yes, this type of system is great for more advanced collateral. There's also BSKT which have created an erc20 index https://blog.cryptofin.io/announcing-the-ethereum-10-the-first-decentralized-index-for-native-ethereum-tokens-3733e237c0fd

We can easily support both in the future, once we have risk assessment models for the individual tokens.

13
catfoodlover•

This is an excellent initiative.

It will allow

  1. a possible expansion of the number of coins that can be used for CDP collateral as low turnover coins become less risky.

  2. individual CDP owners can take higher risk by bundling low-risk token together with high-risk ones.

Only downside is that it could be hard for Maker goverance to judge what debt ceiling to give these bundled tokens.

5
markr5•

I don't know if it's exactly apples-to-apples but this comment put me in mind of the scene from the Big Short with the Jenga blocks. What would be the purpose of bundling low risk and high risk tokens together except to hide the risk behind a cloak of 'diversification'. Maybe I am misunderstanding what you mean. But that parallel would have the Mkr token voters acting as the equivalent of the ratings agencies on a large number of blended assets, seems like a bad outcome. Unless the risk rating is systematically derived from the underlying coins risk, with no additional brownie points for 'diversity', I think that is what Rune is decribing one comment above.

3
catfoodlover•

I think I agree with you.

3