r/EDH•
beyonddevnull

Announcement - June 2018

META

Hi everyone, mod team here. We heard your feedback asking for additional moderation and subreddit changes so without further ado…

AutoModerator - “Beep boop I’m a bot” on the moderation team giving you a weekly rotating posts for some of your content that was outside of the self post scope of the subreddit. You will start seeing daily posts that are rotated weekly.

u/beyonddevnull - Hi everyone, “dev” here. I’m joining the moderation team as an automation expert. I will be managing the the technical work with AutoModerator, code / automation tool development, and occasionally helping out in the modqueue. I have been playing multiplayer highlander variants before the creation of EDH. You might have seen some of my work on the popular EDHrec website (alternative outcomes) where I demonstrated how to utilize the power of technology to build unique brews. I love taking a deck idea or budget to the limit providing maximum value. Looking forward to helping grow the community in this new role. Cheers!

u/cromonolith - Hello! I'm joining the moderation team as general help with whatever needs doing, and to help organize/create new threads when new commanders are around (though someone beat us to it for M19!). I've been playing Magic since around Ice Age, and playing commander since around Return to Ravnica. I don't have a chance to play in paper with my playgroup as often as I'd like, but I'm theory-crafting decks constantly. I'm a fan of mono-coloured decks (Norin and Barrin, particularly), and durdling a lot.

u/smileylich - Hello, everyone. I've been playing casual multiplayer since Magic first started. I'm a big fan of dumb/janky theme deck ideas. I've been active in the community and am here to help out in whatever is needed.

The daily (weekly rotating) posts are currently set as follows:

  • "Moanday Mourning: Vent about your playgroup troubles!"
  • "Tuesday Rulesday: Ask your rules questions here!"
  • "Midweek Bling: Show off your bling!"
  • "Lonely Hearts Thursday: Looking for a Commander?"
  • "Find a Friend Fridays: Looking for a group or new players?"
  • "Spicy Saturday: Welcome to the spice bazaar!"

Any post on this subreddit that should belong in daily (weekly rotating) threads will be removed.

You have also probably noticed that there are only four topics and seven days in week. If you have any ideas for improvements to the weekly threads, we would love to hear them in the comments below or in a mod mail.

Since we have joined the moderation team just last week we have developed the rotating threads, updated the sidebar for M19 with new graphics and links, started working in the mod queue, and began development on the “new” reddit (the upcoming redesign of the website as a whole that is outside of our control).

As we continue to work on this subreddit please keep in mind that we mods are human and mistakes might happen as we grow into these roles. If something seems awry, please do not hesitate to reach out to us through the many channels we make ourselves accessible to including, modmail, direct message, and the EDH discord server.

Cheers!

EDIT: The daily posts are going to be flaried as "Daily". On the sidebar, there is a filter for this flair so you can easily search for your desired daily post even when the sticky has been removed.

EDIT2: Per user suggestion we have added two new daily threads (check in main body for them). We have also added date/time stamps for future daily threads. We have made some additional changes to new subreddit as right now, disgusting dark text is being forced upon us (and the rest of reddit). Once we have additional controls, we'll work to make the "dark theme" (for those you that stare at screens all day) that you deserve.

Posted Jun 25, 2018, 10:45 PM UTC · edited

11637
EAgamezzKruphix, God of Mana Addicts•

I'd love to see the occasional group finding thread. "LFG at ___ school/area/other location."

Edit: Also welcome new mods!

56
farhil•

Petition for "Find a Friend Fridays"

43
CupinacupProssh|Meren|Ur Dragon•

Excellent idea.

3
sechamilton•

Came here to suggest this. Would be a great feature for the subreddit

9
beyonddevnullOPMODMeren Midrange | Chain Veil Teferi | Baral/Tarland Draw-Go CTRL•

This is a great idea. I'll be working to add that.

5
BarbecueStu•

I would most welcome this addition.

3
Warloean•

Having rules questions only allowed one day a week doesnt sound great. Lots of people play on weekends which can generate lots of questions

Edit: it seems i have been correct in that rules questions arent allowed any day.

17
huckaNajeela!•

its still better than the current zero days a week, no?

9
Warloean•

Well there isnt an organized one now but the wat it was worded was any random post asking rules would be taken down

5
huckaNajeela!•

thats how it currently is, yes. per rule nr 6 (i think) rules questions arent allowed and are indeed taken down rather quickly at the moment

8
Warloean•

Ah i did not know that thanks for informing me

1
cobblepottLabManiac Brews•

Use Ask the Judge instead. Turnaround is really fast and answers are always good.

7
P3RS3CUTR0LL•

What you could do is come on the discrod server, there is a "rulesquestion" channel where you can ask about ruling and get an answer relatively fast, I'm using it myself and always getting answered while playing IRL. There is also the magic judge IRC chat where you can get answers ;)

2
beyonddevnullOPMODMeren Midrange | Chain Veil Teferi | Baral/Tarland Draw-Go CTRL•

Reddit only allows us to have two stickied posts at a time. Each day will get it's own 24 hour "stickied" period, but the original post will still exist, it will just not be stickied. You can continue to ask your questions in the un-stickied post. We're still exploring additional ways to keep the non-stickied posts easily accessible.

2
Freakjob003Always pay the 1!•

Plenty of other subs keep a catalog of old discussion threads, perhaps you could ask the mods of those subs how they manage them? r/CriticalRole is the first that comes to mind, they have the episode discussion threads from wayyyy back still easily accessible.

1
beyonddevnullOPMODMeren Midrange | Chain Veil Teferi | Baral/Tarland Draw-Go CTRL•

Thanks for the idea. For clarification, are you referring to this link from their sidebar. If so, I think they're just using a custom flair and that's definitely something that is easy to implement. Once you confirm, I can bring this up with the other mods as this would also require some modifications to the sidebar in addition to automoderation configurations. Making things look pretty is not my forte.

4
Freakjob003Always pay the 1!•

Nope, I'm referring to this page - looks like it's a wiki, actually. No idea how that's set up on a subreddit by subreddit basis.

Wouldn't be a bad place to stick various threads we want to direct people towards, such as crom's aggregation of commonly repeated threads.

1
maximumtaco•

Good ideas and nice to see the team grow :)

Best of luck to you guys. Maybe one tweak to the rotation - "Midweek Bling" could be "Wandering/Wondering Wednesday" or similar to find commanders for playstyles or game plans for commanders.

Then you could have "Lonely Hearts Thursday" turn into the more alliterative "Topdeck Thursday" to talk about bling, great plays, that one cool thing that happened this week, etc. :)

4
MagicalHacker•

This sounds like such a great idea!

2
P3RS3CUTR0LL•

Mods who are casual players, that's great! I'm particularly please to see weekly/daily thread, it can make the sub more "alive" so to speak.

3
FritzH8u•

Smileylich is the best!

3
Freakjob003Always pay the 1!•

Glad to hear you folks are taking the reins; looking forward to good things going forward!

3
Guesty_MODMurmaider•

Cheers, lads!

1
kellis12594Gisela, Blade of Goodnight•

As of this posting, every day has a sticky but sunday. How would a “show-off sunday” work? It would be a place for people to show off their deck(s), but in a more analytical sense; going through how to pilot the deck and the ins and outs of it.

1
HydroStaticSkeletorI am the Flavor Police•

You could have a daily thread for deck tuning/tweaking/critiques.

1
wrookzTazri Allies / Edric / Zada / Shu Yun / Cats / Nath Discards•

Welcome u/beyonddevnull, u/cromonolith & u/smileylich!

Love the LHT and Spicy Saturday weeklies.

1
[deleted]•

[deleted]

0†
Freakjob003Always pay the 1!•

Out of curiosity, what sort of moderation do you think this sub needs?

Myself, I can't see much in terms of actual moderation needed, if we haven't had any highly active mods in months but no outbreaks of rude people, unrelated posts, etc., the sort of problems we really need mods for. Occasionally our "X should be banned!" threads get a little heated, but that's it that I've seen.

2
spicy_af_69Ruric thar Primal surge•

I don't know what he said but I imagine he was upset at the general lack of follow-up and impact that the mods promised they would have on the subreddit 2 YEARS AGO. Theyve been pretty irrelevant in both adding freshness to the sub, because let's be honest most days this subreddit is the same subset of 5 posts and it needs all the help it can get.

I personally have applied as a moderator multiple times because I love this sub and I want to see it thrive, and the current moderation team has utterly failed at that. This sub is boring, bland, and lacking weekly threads (another thing that was promised to us). Hopefully these new bloods can come in and make some changes but holy shit this sub has been dealing with absentee mods for years.

0
Freakjob003Always pay the 1!•

I honestly don't recall either, something along the lines of, "finally, some fucking mods."

I can't remember which old mod said it, but they stated that if they didn't allow deck help threads, this sub would be dead. And it's true. Annoying, for those of us that've been here for years or know how to use the search function, but true.

Going forward with the assumption that we can't make drastic changes to how this sub hosts deck help posts, I'll state my question to you, as someone who's got a +22 upvote count from me, according to RES: what sort of moderation do you think this sub needs? I don't think we have a problem with trolls or the types of unpleasantness other subs deal with.

Personally, I'm happy with the announced weekly threads - I'm sure even they'll get stale after a while, but it'll at least be nice to have a place to shunt the discussion and prevent the volume of repeat posts. I can't remember who it was, but someone with a mono-blue flair and deck used to run a weekly thread where you'd post your deck but had to leave a comment on someone else's deck; that was a good one.

Which brings me to the question: if what this sub needs is more active discussion of non-repeating topics, is that up to the mods to bring to the table, or for us as users to come up with? After all, 50,000+ people will have more ideas than three people.

3
MissesDoubtfire•

The only thing the mods are currently doing that I heavily disagree with is forcing threads to be tagged and hiding untagged threads. "All posts need a descriptive title" is much better. If you turn off the subreddit theme, you will see untagged posts that have replies. I don't like there being 2 versions of the subreddit.

1