r/redesign•
Neobim

New changes are a lot more like the classic design (and I love it!)

Seems like an unpopular opinion judging by the rest of the hot posts on this sub right now, but I actually really like the new changes.

Lightbox

The lightbox for viewing posts was neat, but it left a lot of unusable space around the edges of the post (where the 'background' page was faded out) & didn't let me see any info about the sub the post was on like the old design did.

I much prefer having comments be on their own 'page', as it uses more of my screen for what I care about (the post) as well as shows me the sub's sidebar information. Hopefully this can be extended in the future to show more of the sub's customizations as well, like their banner.

I've always used my mouse's back button to back out of comments (including on the old design), so complains about no longer being able to 'click out' of the comments are a non-issue for me.

Sidebar

I also wasn't a fan of the sidebar taking up such a huge amount of screen real estate. I almost never used it, so to take up such a large portion of my screen despite not really being all that useful for me was a bit crazy.

Perhaps it could be left in as an option for those who liked using it, however whenever I would attempt to collapse the sidebar, it would always come back upon page reload. Unless that gets fixed, I'm glad it's gone.

This way leaves a lot more space to the content which is great, and it's a lot more familiar like the old design. The new menu of course isn't without issues, as you can't see it while viewing comments.

Verdict

Overall I think this is a great step in the right direction, as it's a lot more similar to the old classic design whilst still keeping all the nice new features of the redesign. It's a lot more compact and gives more space to the posts, comments, and content which is very much appreciated. Reddit feels like Reddit again! Thanks for listening to previous feedback and improving :)

Posted Jun 28, 2018, 5:28 AM UTC

07
jimba22•

I respect your opinion, but the fact that it brings me to a whole new page is giving me a headache

  1. I want to browse a sub by new
  2. I go to the sub, sort by new
  3. Click on post, get new page
  4. Go back, no longer sorted by new

I'll just leave out all the extra clicking I have to do

With the sidebar and lightbox, it was just 'click' outside the post and BAM, continue in the same sub/front page, sorted however you had it

How can you not see that it was easier that way?

3
NeobimOP•

I go to the sub, sort by new Click on post, get new page Go back, no longer sorted by new

This actually works just fine for me, after I go back it's still sorted by new. What browser are you using?

2
CyberBot129•

It’s not a new page - it’s still the same page, it just looks more like a new page. So if you’re using the browsers back button (or equivalent keyboard shortcut) rather than the close button on the lightbox (or keyboard shortcut for that), what you’re seeing would be the correct behavior, since you’re doing the equivalent of you being on a sub/front page and hitting refresh/F5

1
MajorParadoxHelpful User :cake:•

It's still a light box, but they hid the side areas to click. Sounds like they may look into bringing those back if they can without going back to such a small box. But for now, if back doesn't work, you can press ESC or click the close button at the top-right. Kinda of annoying, so hopefully they fix it soon.

1
Captainographer•
  1. Lightbox

I think one reason many people (including myself) like the light box is because it didn't take you to a different page, so you didn't have to load the home page or sub page over and over again. A great way to combat the problem of unused space would be the introduction of a feature where you could drag the edges of the light box to resize it, thus reducing blank space for those who want to while leaving the option to have that space as a click away area for the people who like that. On the mouse: you are a special case. That doesn't apply to the vast majority of users, so you can't wave that feature away as "Oh I don't need it so it doesn't matter."

  1. Sidebar

All you really say here is that you were annoyed by the sidebar coming back even after you hid it when you reloaded a page. That is definitely a problem and needs to be fixed, but it appears you have no real complaints with the sidebar in theory.

I think a lot of the debate here could be solved by increased customizability. The ability to choose whether you get a light box or not, hamburger menu or not, q-and-type or not, show sidebar on comments screen or not, etc. I feel like the reddit devs are not really taking this into consideration. If it's too hard to code, that's fine, but they need to say "We can't do everything because we actually can't." As it stands, it feels like they are just ignoring this option.

2
NeobimOP•

I think one reason many people (including myself) like the light box is because it didn't take you to a different page, so you didn't have to load the home page or sub page over and over again.

I agree that having options is great, however this isn't quite correct. The new design is built as a "single page app", meaning it doesn't reload the entire page while navigating within itself, and only loads the necessary 'new' data that needs to be displayed. Full page reloads still happen if you type in your browser's address bar, of course. The current way of navigating to and from the comments is exactly the same as the 'lightbox' previously, this one just looks like a proper new page with no distractions or wasted space.

As for the sidebar itself -- I still use that menu! Just nowhere near enough to warrant such a gargantuan amount of screen space. Having it in a nice neat little drop down menu allows me to use it when I need to (ie. for fast access to favourited subreddits) without shifting the entire screen sideways. It opens when I want to access it, I click a thing, and then it collapses away. Is it really that necessary to have it on screen at all times?

1
vanstinator•

I hit the hamburger menu the first time I used the redesign and can't say it ever appeared again without me summoning it.

1