Silicone O-ring safety

Retaining

Has anyone researched the chemical safety of the basic hardware store silicone o-rings people are using?

I understand that there are various grades of silicone, including food grade, and levels of medical grade from intermittent use to prolonged use to permanent (implants for example).

I'd be pretty surprised if the plumbing-type o-rings are medical grade, but then again, I don't know what danger non-medical-grade silicone might pose. Any chemists among us that can shed some light?

Edit: A search on reddit taught me that platinum-cured silicone is the safest. Other silicones are cured with tin or peroxide. And many silicones have fillers and additives that can leach out. Apparently 100% pure silicone will not turn white if twisted, it will stay clear. None of this tells us whether the hardware store o-rings are unsafe or not, of course. But it would be interesting to source medical grade liquid silicone to produce our own.

Posted Jun 29, 2018, 2:22 PM UTC · edited

78
tchap4Restoring | CI-3•

The silicone o-rings sold by Chuck (DTR maker) are food grade silicone, which would indicate a certain degree of safety. There is a noticeable quality difference between those and the ones sold by Amazon (probably the equivalent of hardware store). The molding/flexibility is better on the ones Chuck sells.

7
YesRebootRestoring | CI-3•

yeah that's where I got mine, never had any irritation or problems. I wouldn't go to some random hardware store unless i had some background information that would let me trust the source.

1

On a pack of o-rings from the Home Depot there was a warning that “this product contains substances known to cause cancer”.

6
GerhardtRestoredRestoring | CI-2•

I would only trust it if they are specified as food grade silicone o-rings. You can get them from mcmaster carr if you’re in the states. Read up on silicone rubber. It should be safe on your skin.

3
resensingOPRestoring | CI-3•

Some of the reddit posts I saw about silicone safety (try searching related keywords like silicone, platinum, food, medical, etc) mentioned that food grade silicone can by US FDA law include additives like formaldehyde and preservatives (presumably to prevent food spoilage or something). Don't know the validity of this, but it gives me pause on the food grade status.

1
GerhardtRestoredRestoring | CI-2•

I did a little digging and rubbercal summarizes the FDA code for elastomers (with a link to the code)

From the link ~

Medical and food applications must use the FDA-approved silicone materials to avoid any health safety risks to the public. There is an emphasis on rubbers being suitable for repeated use, meaning it shouldn’t harbor contaminants just as it shouldn’t give them off. Food grade gaskets and seals should be able to function for long periods of time without falling prey to harmful contaminating agents, or degradation, no matter what type of product the food may be.

2
resensingOPRestoring | CI-3•

That's a helpful start, thanks!

1
theBlueProgrammerRestoring | CI-4•

I'm curious about this, as well.

1