Yeethoven II Orchestra: Discovering why Kanye is interesting to classical composers
time.com/5051044/yeethoven-kanye-west-beethov...Posted Jul 3, 2018, 4:25 AM UTC
Posted Jul 3, 2018, 4:25 AM UTC
I love some of Kanye's music, especially Yeezus, but his lack of traditional musical training really lets him him down when he tries to sing. The songs Runaway and Dark Fantasy literally have out of key notes in the vocals that ridiculously made it onto the finished record... I don't believe for a second it was intentional, just sounds really amateurish. 99% of listeners don't seem to care though, but I still cringe when he gets called a musical genius but can't hear basic harmony.
The singing on Ye is somewhat better but I wish he would stick to his strengths.
Edit: Also, (sorry for wall of text but i find this interesting!) whilst I think sampling is a completely valid and interesting way of making tracks, does it really make sense to orchestrate this stuff when basically all his most iconic moments are samples? https://youtu.be/aJ4vr2ex4L4
I'm sorry but it's only Americans who would consider Kanye interesting compared to classical music. He's not worth mentioning.
I'm an American who is not particularly interested in Kanye who could not help but notice that one half of the duo who is heading up this project is from Sweden. So, yeah, nice generalization. A post on an American website about an American music project - who would have thought it?
What's your point?
Don't be sorry, they're the one who should be.
What confuses me a bit is how there is a lot of talk about how Kanye West is "an iconoclast" and "a risk taker, really innovative" who "pushed his artform further, just as Beethoven did his," and about how hip-hop and classical music share "a common musical and cultural backbone."
But there is very little in the way of explanations of how these things are the case. It would have been interesting to see some actual explanations of the developments Kanye West has made and how these relate to Beethoven's accomplishments.
This lack of interest in the particularities also makes their stated goal of "trying to figure out why classical musicians find Kanye so compelling" ring untrue.
I'm also not sure if the way they were so easy to switch from one composer to another ("We talked about comparing [Kanye] to Stravinsky and a bunch of other classical composers, but we settled on Beethoven.") inspires a lot of confidence in this project.
Neither does the way one of them responded to "You’ve spent a lot of time exploring the Kanye-Beethoven mashup. Are there any other pairings you’re interested in?" with the answer "Personally, I think something with Daft Punk would be cool," right before his partner pulls back on the idea.
I'm with you. The article and title are big on bombastic claims but little on support for those claims.
And just as you've pointed out, I felt like Kanye could have been matched with just about any other classical composer or even other big names outside of classical music. I saw nothing in the article that required the connection to be classical and certainly not just Beethoven.
In the end this was a fluff piece. We were all expecting something with some meat to it that would allow for a deeper discussion but it was just cotton candy.