Super shredder element?

I’ve got 2 super shredders, ones legacy with affliction and ones fire with 5 hs in a row perk I want it for teddshot jess and I’m not sure if I should just recycle my fire one and make the legacy one physical or energy and upgrade it perks. The super shredder mostly for mid range as I’ll be using a whisper .45 for the closer husks to get charge fragments