[PTS0.7.7P2]Narai have been overtuned?

Question

Is it just me or have Narai been made too difficult to 4 or 5 star in random que? Playing on PTS 0.7.7 P2 It took me 7 games(4 Helena, 3 Lyon) to get 1 3 star finish, and all the games I had were good games(150K+ for Helena, 200K+ for Lyon etc).

The problem imo is timing & route of the Carrier & Cargo Ship secondary and their escort ship.

It is very difficult for a random team to split 3 ways properly, most of the time in my 7 tries 3 or more ships splits off from the main team(and most of the time this includes 1-2 BBs). The split off ship rarely get back to the main action in time before the rest of the ship are overwhelmed by the main attack wave. Plus this happens right as the transport ship is about to enter the enemy base. Which leads to the following:

The carrier/cargo ship escort DDs torp the transport ship from both flanks, at least 1 transport ship sinks and loses a star.

The St.Clair(deceptive fast ship) escapes as it is the fastest ship have the shortest route to escape, then the 1-2 ships going that way to intercept taking forever to get back to the main action.

Too many ship goes for the side objective, not enough ship is there to clear the enemy base and hold off attack wave.

The Carrier escapes despite 1 ship going for it because its route is shielded by island most of the way and its air wing is too strong for the AA of the intercepting ships. Fact that a Lexington is 7kts faster and have 13K more hp than Ranger seem to have escaped from the devs.

If this version of Narai gets released in live, I think it would be a struggle to even 3 star 50% of the time in random que, 4-5 star finishes probably need a full 7 ship division.

Posted Jul 13, 2018, 1:17 AM UTC · edited

1337
Zanurath•

God forbid this game has fun operations can’t have people having fun outside pvp

27
NegZer0•

This seems to be where they want to tune the Operations to, if the others currently are anything to go by. Aegis and Final Frontier are both stupidly difficult now too, ever since they fiddled with the AI gun accuracy.

WG don't want the mode to be an enjoyable and lucrative way to play the game apparently but rather than just nerf rewards they made them stupidly difficult to beat with a random group.

9
Draken84•

how else can they claim that they "tried" but "it didn't work" and then ignore the whole thing ?

3
heishnod•

Aegis is still very easy, it's just not the easiest one now. Cherry Blossom is now the easiest operation.

What are your difficulties in Aegis?

1
_Cats_Paw_Fuyukai Desu•

There is some crazy RNG in Aegis when it comes to spawns now. I played one a couple of days ago where the initial wave of ships were ALL Ishizuchis. Every single one of them.

Turns out when you get this spawn and have a light cruiser heavy team it takes way too long to get rid of them. Unless you can get some torps on them (we couldn't) the Ishi armor scheme is a tough nut to crack for 152mm guns. After you get bogged down the northern spawn ships pincer you and disaster ensues.

Sometimes it still feels easy, but there is more variation in it now. That may not even be a bad thing, but I think they needed to tune down the AI tendency to focus fire the lowest HP ship if they want their accuracy to be higher. It just feels too harsh/aggressive to get melted in a matter of seconds when things don't go right.

2
ItsJustDeltaRanked: Where dreams go to die•

Without getting into how ridiculous the enemy bots have become in regards to things like fire chance or full AA spec, it seems to be ridiculously easy for potatoes to mess things up. For example, lots of DDs want to rush north immediately, which forces the northern group to spawn early and puts the fleet in a crossfire. Other times the entire fleet tunnel visions hard on the NW CVs and lets the transports be gunned down.

On another note the transport AI seems to have issues re-finding the correct path if they have to divert at all to dodge torpedoes. Had a run yesterday where one of the transports ignored the safe zone and ran straight into the enemy fleet. The player fleet was doing well, but the AI went full potato and threw a five-star run.

TLDR: Enemy bots became scarier while teammates have continually gotten dumber, so has the friendly AI.

1
NegZer0•

What are your difficulties in Aegis?

HE spam. Ridiculous RNG on the spawns. Potato teammates. Teammates that take a Destroyer into the mode. The fact it feels tuned for T7 ships instead of T6 (there are often far too many T7 enemies IMO). Shitty friendly AI. The lack of any island cover.

I'm sure it's quite doable with a good group or if you're a super unicum player, but I'm mediocre and my runs at it have been more failures than successes since they fiddled with the AI.

1
AOSPrevailsOPIGN: DLAsia•

Aegis is still pretty easy to 4 star, and I am having no problem getting my average 150K+ cruiser or 200K+ BB game in it. The fifth star needs a bit more teamwork and luck than it used to, it have been a 25% chance for 5 star these last few days.

I wouldn't lump it in with Final Frontier.

1
NotHere001God Mode > ACTIVATE•

Oh god, the new Narai is hard, right? 100k was not enough, 200k was not enough, putting my tryhard hat and doing nearly 280k dmg was not enough. And i didnt even get 3 stars XD

5
MrRockitHMS KGV (review done)•

With randoms everything is too difficult

3
lumphinansNavy Brat•

Yeah we were humping along quite nicely then the next thing I knew Raptor was dead.

2
enxyoClosed Beta Player•

I would love to see the hard mode finally. Need for coordinated 7 man division with good rewards. Maybe with once weekly container drop or something, to minimize hardcore farming.

1
heavynine•

Its difficult to predict how balanced the operations are on the PTS because of how flaky PTS players are ... I could only 1 star win a single game out of 6 during the daytime. At night, my teams won several 3 star victories.

0
dreiak559The starch is strong in this potato (DrEiak@NA)•

So I am just going to say it. Operations are all stupidly easy, and the only reason any operation is hard is because people playing are usually terrible at the game and play PvE to escape from the challenge of being any good in randoms.

I know that probably sounds harsh, but here is a reality check. I play primarily random battles, and some operations for commander XP that is super easy to farm because operations are super easy to farm, and what people get upset about is having their XP Cash cow reduced.

I wouldn't mind operations that actually require decent teams to complete. If you aren't looking for any challenge there is always coop.

Here is to hoping they add a hard mode and make some operations for DDs speciffically like the Dunkirk one, and for T10s.

If you really like operations, and you think they are too hard, perhaps you should learn how to play the game? What works in randoms still works in operations, and I can't tell you how much IFHE has turned the player bases brain to mush when it comes to ammo selection.

There is more to life than HE spam, especially if you play cruisers.

-4
AOSPrevailsOPIGN: DLAsia•

know that probably sounds harsh, but here is a reality check. If you really like operations, and you think they are too hard, perhaps you should learn how to play the game?

I have a 56% PvP winrate playing solo(and mostly T8+ ships), so please drop your PVP elitist stat shaming gimmick.

Ranked Maps don't ask 7 ship team to split 3 ways to win, this new Narai ask you to make a coordinated 3 way split in a narrow timing window(after Missouri is down and before attack wave spawns from the map edge) and then rejoin in-time otherwise you can't five 5star.

Different Operations have different difficulties, Cherry Blossom is an easy 5 star, Aegis is a cake walk 4 star, The New Rescue Raptor is tricky but doable with half a team knowing where to position, the re-done Final Frontier is a struggle most of the time with randoms, and this new Narai is an exercise in futility if your hope is to get 4-5 star consistently with randoms. I am only suggesting WG check if they over-tuned the difficulty of the last one.

5
dreiak559The starch is strong in this potato (DrEiak@NA)•

Elitist bullshit?

If Stephen Hawking told you your astrophysics was off would that be elitist bullshit?

Elitist bullshit is what people say when they are mad because they aren't elite. Who do you turn to to get the best advice? Jo radom scrub or an elite?

If you want someone to fly a plane or do brain surgery you want an elite, and if you want a team or division mate you probably want an elite too.

My win rate is better than yours, but honestly that doesn't matter. I play ops too, and I see how random players play ops. Most people in operations are not good. Sure most players in randoms aren't good either, but not being good against humans and not being good against bots are different categories of not being good.

I have five stared every OP. Every single one. And guess what? They are all easy, and if you fail them it was because the team was a failure, not because the OP was hard.

You think getting over 200k damage in an operation is somehow special? That should be the norm if you are in a cruiser at least with how random players play, and you aren't going to five star it with random players until they have had time to potato in it for a few weeks.

Go play with good players and tell me a single OP is actually hard.

Oh, and hell yes I am an elitist, because why the hell would I take advice from people worse than me? If I want advice I seek it from those who are better and I would HOPE that players of all skill levels would do the same.

Elitist bullshit hahaha. How about we use the term Scrub Lord bullshit? Can I start telling people to stop with their scrub lording? Because the real bullshit is the stuff clueless players say because they don't know what the hell they are talking about.

It's a team game and you aren't going to win the ops if you are the only one on the team being useful. Maybe that is how it SHOULD be.

-2
AOSPrevailsOPIGN: DLAsia•

Go play with good players and tell me a single OP is actually hard.

That's saying the only way to improve random WR is to play in divisions. Operations should be 4-5 star-able on a regular basis with random que, else it is not a viable game mode.

I have five stared every OP. Every single one. And guess what? They are all easy, and if you fail them it was because the team was a failure, not because the OP was hard.

I have fiver stared every single one except the new PTS Narai, and that's totally beside the point. How many times have you played each one, and what are your average 5 star rates? I play each one at least 50 times a week and almost all in random que so maybe I actually have more experience in them than you do?

Do you even have a 5 star finish with the current PTS iteration of Narai? with random teammates? (If so do share a screenshot). Seeing its difficulty is the main topic of discussion here if you don't then you don't really have any credibility as the playstyle and level of coordination required is completely on a different level with the old Narai.

5
fordnutUnited States Navy•

You're not wrong. You're also the type of player who abuses these missions to the point they are nerfed for people who have a lot less skill, for reasons perhaps beyond their control.

3
dreiak559The starch is strong in this potato (DrEiak@NA)•

Not really.

I play mostly randoms. I litterally hate grinding. So more like I am the type of person who will get a daily win in an operation for the commander XP and move on with my life.

The ops get "nerfed" because of a massive number of players who grind them into Oblivion so they can have Missouri or Musashi with minimal effort, or reasons similar to that.

I have 11 T10 ships and 4k games. I will let you do the math, but I don't have time for that kind of bullshit. I play to unlock ships quickly with the least amount of tedium or repetion whilest not skipping stuff with free XP conversions. If I don't like a ship or don't want to play it stock I might bring it into OPs as well so I don't have to suffer in randoms feeling neutered, but I don't think you can blame me or my kind for ruining OPs. I think you can blame the army of 48-52% win rate 70% population that play them because you don't have to worry about winning in randoms to get decent XP or silver, or non premium players who litterally play ops purely for silver profits if they don't have a better moneymaker.

WG litterally has never done anything ever to cater to their top tier players. It's (simply put) just not a big enough player base. If they catered to competitive players Asashio, Conqueror, and GZ wouldn't exist (as is at least), and low tier CVs would still have manual drops.

-1
fordnutUnited States Navy•

I blame your attitude. It's toxic, it's selfish, and it's offensive.

And no, 'massive number of players' do not grind them into oblivion. Most, in fact, do not. Only the min/maxxers like yourself.

You've got some kind of sense of entitlement that doesn't belong in the game. WG owes you precisely fuck all beyond what they've already given you. People who cannot play to the level you do, or do not want to spend the money you do, deserve to have a fun and rewarding PvE experience without little min/maxxing monkeys trying to grab all the bananas before anyone else.

5
dreiak559The starch is strong in this potato (DrEiak@NA)•

Lol.

I am not toxic. I am accurate.

To you people who say "try getting better" is toxic.

You want to know what is toxic? People that don't know what they are doing and don't care, and people like yourself who fond it easier to complain online than adapt to change.

Step 1) get over it.
Step 2) get better.
Step 3) win.

You follow those three rules and come back here and tell me I was toxic because I told you to get better.

Also you have no clue what you are talking about when it comes to players like myself lol. I litterally told you I only play maybe a few ops a week max for daily wins, and that I don't grind, and you are already telling ME how I play.

But then again I am sure you are good enough at the game to be talking to me about game balance. I mean surely you know all the rules and mechanics and your stats reflect that right? If not how about you fix yourself? Nothing worse that crappy team mates, especially in coop where you don't have to worry about guys like me being on the red team and ruining your day.

0
_Cats_Paw_Fuyukai Desu•

For people who want the challenge such as yourself WG just needs to actually enable the Hard Mode button they've been teasing since operations began. Easy peasy.

You have every right to want a challenging mode, but not everybody wants to be pushed to 100% every time they play a game. The devs were shortsighted to overtune the operations this way in their Normal mode. They should have implemented the hard mode and nerfed the economic rewards for the normal mode to reduce farming efficiency.

2
dreiak559The starch is strong in this potato (DrEiak@NA)•

If I want a challenge I play solo games on randoms. I play ops to farm XP like the rest of you, but I don't agree that your complaints are valid. The truth has been spoken no matter how unpopular it is. If you aren't winning in an OP it is your teams fault. Either organize a team or convince the whole internet to get better. Either way the ONLY reason people think an OP is hard is because people in the queue either suck really badly, or they have no idea what they are doing. Likely the problem is both.

The easiest solution is to fix yourself, but I guess complaining online is even easier than that, though that doesn't solve anything.

Ops aren't hardcore, not a single one is. Try getting a 60% solo win rate with Monarch. That is hardcore. Last patch people were bitching about whatever other ops we're reworked and are now "too hard" and I don't even remember which one's because they aren't any harder.

If you know the basicis of how to play the game no OP is hard. Problem is, do you?

-3
_Cats_Paw_Fuyukai Desu•

convince the whole internet to get better.

Somehow I think my proposed solution is just a bit more practical.

3
dreiak559The starch is strong in this potato (DrEiak@NA)•

No. Your proposal is basically complaining that WG made a bad change, and now you complain, when the reasons you bring up to complain are litterally why they changed it to begin with.

You are only downvoting me for telling you the hard truth. Clearly making OPs easier is better than making you either a better player and or able to out together teams to complete them. Or simply waiting long enough for the randos that grind OPs to figure out the minimum amount to complete them, which is usually a week or two.

-1
LordFjordSenior Gamer•

Remember the unholy amount of "mimimi" when the first operation was tested as a Halloween event?

Well, after two weeks or so the people have figured it out - its doable if you learn where stuff comes from, how the scenario works, then do the right things and work as a team ( I know its hard).

I don't mind at all that they are becoming hard (are they really? they still seem mostly easy to me, we like to stomp them here and then with the clan). Anyway, hardmodes for T8-10? Where are you? :)

0
AOSPrevailsOPIGN: DLAsia•

Well, after two weeks or so the people have figured it out

People figured out that(Halloween 2017) Operation to the tune of a sub 5% 5 star rate, and when WG announced that stat they were so harshly criticized that they never released win & star rate stat for any Opereation ever again.

3
heishnod•

I was very surprised with the 70% failure rate of the Halloween operation.
The all you had to do was have the CV player press the "Time Stop" button as soon as it was off cooldown once the Nikolai spawns.

0
dreiak559The starch is strong in this potato (DrEiak@NA)•

Haha I am already at minus 2 for saying the same.

Operations are easy. Call people out on their bullshit is a good way to get minus karma here.

2
AOSPrevailsOPIGN: DLAsia•

Operations are easy. Call people out on their bullshit is a good way to get minus karma here.

5 star Narai with random team on this PTS, at least post a screenshot before you start claiming something is easy.

3
dreiak559The starch is strong in this potato (DrEiak@NA)•

Can't help if your teammates suck. Try it with your clanmates.

The reason people fail is because they don't know what they are doing. In a few weeks it will be part of the regular grind.

I mean PTS is probably the worst possible argument you could use. It's well known what the quality of PTS players is and you are seriously using that as counterpoint?

-1