Year of the Snitch is a concerning let-down.
I don't believe that I am the only one who thinks this either. On GP was the natural conclusion to the bands first incarnation. Stefan confronts the suicidal ideations and behaviour prevalent throughout his lyrics directly and without obfuscation. Ultimately, he finds resolve and the will to continue living, rising triumphant over his afflictions. Enter the track Death Grips 2.0. Here we bear witness to the band undergoing the process of metamorphosis into a new entity.
Bottomless Pit arrives and the band is on top and untouchable. Immediately after their most vulnerable moment (On GP) Death Grips release their most confident, self-asserting and dominating record to date. In Bottomless Pit the band takes ownership of and pride in the ugliness and trauma present in their music and turn it into something sexy and chic. Bottomless Pit is a flag-flying victory lap. Despite the records flawless execution, fun and colourful sound/aesthetic, it wasn't as much of an artistic leap forward as many fans had hoped for. This was mostly forgiven due simply to the sheer quality of the music contained and the faith that Death Grips would return with something new and challenging on their next project.
Then came Year of the Snitch. Unsure of itself, stale and resentful. I refused to give into the doomsayers fearmongering leading up to the albums release after singles like Streaky and Black Paint, but now that the dust has settled, I have to admit that they were right.
From its onset, it becomes evident that something is off with YOTS. Death Grips is Online is a subdued, sterile and unaffected portrayal of the phenomenon that the band has become and the superstar status that they have attained. It feels artificial and rehearsed, like the 'Death Grips is Online' retweets were. This track is the first of four that express the bands dissatisfaction with their current situation and doubt for their future.
Where Death Grips is Online raises a red flag implicitly, Dilemma states that there is a problem explicitly.
"I'm in the studio with Death Grips. They have a dilemma, but they'll win their dilemma".
I would love to hear any interpretations of what the dilemma is exactly, but I hold that it is at least partly about the disruption to the bands dynamic that has existed up until this point due to Zach and Andy entering into committed relationships and not knowing how to proceed as a band into the future because of it.
Shitshow is a behind-the-scenes look at the creative process of the band and it sheds light on how self-destructive, chaotic and messy the personal lives that produce their artworks are.
Finally, we get to the crux of the album, Disappointed. The purpose for putting this track at the end of an album who's second-to-last track is titled outro is made clear. The song is a reflection on the band and album itself.
Called shots cheap shots Slack jaws low blows Weak chins chin checked
Stefan sees the success and accolades that Death Grips have achieved as ultimately trivial.
Forlorn regime metamorph me into done for at last at least until my present shore has past
The life that the band is leading is harming Stefan. He foresees this being an inevitability until Death Grips have exhausted their current wave of popularity.
Ripper ripper skin tight, too tight Too tight holding solid moonlight moonlight Moonlight, kevlar coated slit moon, lunar gush Lunar gush carry on carrion never been far enough
Despite the bands success and lifestyle affecting him negatively, Stefan desperately clutches onto the limelight that the band currently has at all costs because it gives him validation. Because of how tightly he grips onto it, the moonlight is gushing out his hands and disappearing, like attempting to hold onto water.
Rot clot corpse cut Corpse cut your husk Shut the fuck up or fed Both you're Disappointed
Death Grips is getting old and rotting. Stefan asks himself whether to stop now or continue. He concludes that regardless of which path he chooses the fans and he himself will be disappointed.
I see the remaining songs on the album existing as separate entities and not contributing to the meta commentary present in the other four tracks, but they reflect the sentiment in those tracks by being derivative and evidence of the bands current predicaments.
Ultimately I found Year of the Snitch uninspired and lacklustre and due to the content in the album I am concerned that Death Grips are in a volatile place as a band. This worries me because although they have released many great albums up until this point, I still feel they have so much more potential and ideas to be fully realised in their 2.0 era. I hope that this album is a moment of necessary reflection and a turning point in the bands history before a newfound direction and not the end.
Posted Jul 14, 2018, 2:04 PM UTC · edited
I think it's disingenuous to say that Year of the Snitch is stale. It's also a fairly bold - you could say, confident - record. You don't have to like it, but it's a huge step for a band that constantly experiments with their sound. At every turn, YOTS defies expectation, from flow, to mix, to songwriting/structure, to instrumentation. It's got a snarky sense of humor, and a tinge of self-awareness (like the Dilemma moment you mentioned, or even the placement of Disappointed in the tracklist).
It's the kind of record that can only be made by an established band with a fanbase that fairly well understands them. It's a curveball, their first big one since NOTM.
I was admittedly dumbfounded at first listen, but after sitting with it I think it's a very strong record amidst one of the most impressive discographies from any band this decade, and I'm still gleaning new sounds, lyrics and ideas from it each listen.
I am continuing to listen to the album with an open mind but my opinion has yet to change. The Fear, Disappointed, Dilemma and Hahaha are unique and interesting, but none of them wow me. I find Streaky, Linda's in Custody and Black Paint to be stale, inferior versions of other Death Grips songs. While I might sound like I've made my mind up, I still hope that I will see the album in a different light in time.
The only track I still find stale is Little Richard, but it's basically an interlude/skit (or Death Grips' version of one). I don't like the melody on that one at all.
It's definitely more of a subdued album, I don't think it's quite meant to "wow" the say way an album like Bottomless Pit is meant to. My only advice is to try listening to it as loud as you can tolerate. Great car album.
Black Paint played LOUD is one of my favorite DG songs. Flies is really fucking awesome (especially as a synth enthusiast, I would love to pick Flatlander's brain about that track as well as the whole album). Dilemma is an insanely unique song for them, Ha Ha Ha is confident as fuck, Streaky is really really fun, and Linda's in Custody is a real grower: I really find it catchy now. The other interludes like Horn Section and Shitshow are also cool ~minute stretches of music (though I'm glad Shitshow isn't any longer than it is).
Edit: oh and the Fear???? GREAT FUCKING TRACK
My two biggest complaints on the album are Black Paint and Streaky. Streaky is just too thin and pales in comparison to similar tracks like Houdini imo. I feel the same about Black Paint and Turned Off. I agree with you on The Fear. It's like the anxiety and volatility of Come Up and Get Me met with the personal-ness of On GP.
I couldn't compare tracks from different albums like that if I tried. Houdini is soooo different from Streaky, that's a strange comparison. If anything, Streaky resembles Eh, but barely. Turned Off is an unhinged borderline hardcore/punk track, but Black Paint is a jammin tune that has a leisurely tempo, very confident with its groove that it doesn't have to go any faster. Like Death Grips' version of classic rock.
I'm liking this friendly debate, man. Discussing the criticisms of the album makes me like it more
I think you might enjoy the album more if you don’t compare things to other things so much.
So true. I think YOTS is an awesome (somewhat) new stepping stone for DG.