I really miss martial arts.

I Will try to make this post as short as possible, about 6 or 7 years ago i was really into TKD, i had a black Belt, i was fit and i loved training. The thing is i had to stop because my knees started hurting. Ive seen some doctors and therapists but long story short i can't walk run or jump much. Ive gained Weight Since then, Ive tried swimming and Weight lifting (surprisingly my knees are ok with that), but i miss martial arts really really bad, lately Ive Been wanting to Join a bjj place, Since most of what they do is on the floor, but they still do some stuff standing, wich im not very sure i can do, and i would be a bit embarassed telling everyone i can't do simple stuff like running or Jumping Jacks. Could bjj be considered low impact or close to low impact? Am i crazy? Should i accept my martial arts days are over? I'm 25 so i'm still very capable of physical activity, i just have shitty knees.

Posted Jul 18, 2018, 9:33 PM UTC

3729
KatsuhayabiSōke of Fung-Kwang Hwi-Wu - Black Belt 25th dan•

No reason to get embarrassed over that.

I had a severe leg injury from judo (4 fractures, half torn achilles tendon, severely sprained ankle, torn knee ligaments).

Couldn't do judo at all for couple of years, went kickboxing after a long brake, explained my injury- wore a brace, no one tried lowkicking me too hard, stretched or did sit-ups while everyone ran for warm-up, skipped all repetitive exercises (including jumping jacks) that put pressure on my foot, obviously no jumping rope, used the step-in instead rotating on the ball of the foot for my kicks (while literally everyone else got chewed out for being lazy if they did that), and this went on for a year and a half before i joined in with everyone slowly.

Nothing weird about it. Just don't stand around doing nothing while others exercise, no one will give you shit if you do push-ups, sit-ups and squats instead w/e else you say you can't.

23
BluDavidOP•

Thanks, ive decided i have to at least try. Sadly this is something i'll never recover from but i Guess i'll have to make then most Out of it.

3
new2judo•

Could you tell me how you got so injured?

2
KatsuhayabiSōke of Fung-Kwang Hwi-Wu - Black Belt 25th dan•

Was in a tournament, i'm a heavy guy (was some 140isk kg at that moment) my opponent was also a heavy guy (some 110-120).

Already had injuries from before in that leg from a random (non-judo related) accident i never let fully heal, so my ankle ligaments were weak.

Long story short i start lifting him up for a hanae goshi, and he tries holding with his foot around my standing leg, i slip a bit from the sweat i guess in the moment i was supposed to execute the throw, and as i try making my balance back i double step with my standing foot... 2nd step i dont step with the sole of my foot but the side of it, you can imagine some 260kg and opponents foot preventing me from shifting weight or straightening my leg in a what usually would be just a sprained ancle situation... both kept going sideways over the leg and broke everything we needed to finish getting to the ground.

Got silver. Got a cast too. Really a freak accident that happens once in ever.

5
new2judo•

Wow yeah that explains it.

1
fat_camp•

i knew an older guy in bjj who had knee issues and he still trained, i wouldn't say it's low impact but the instructors took his knee into consideration for certain moves. so definitely speak to the man/woman in charge about your health issues

11
fridgefucker12•

Hell that's all us old guys in bjj

13
reality_beast•

I feel your pain, man. I dwell on my own knee problems all day ever day. I did TKD for over 20 years, and BJJ for 7 years or so (with a few years of overlap). My honest opinion is that BJJ would probably be a godsend for you. I don’t believe BJJ to be high-impact at all.

Of course for the first few months you’ll have to be observant, as BJJ will put your knees through situations and angled pressures that you have not experienced before, but if your only issue is high-impact - you should be just fine.

My problem nowadays is that over the many years of TKD, soccer, and jogging, all the high-impact stuff has really done a number on my knee joints - and they “pop out of place” temporarily (until I flex them straight, which pops them back in) during certain sweep techniques. I have long, lanky legs, and sweeps are a specialty of mine - so it’s particularly annoying that this issue is becoming more frequent.

Give BJJ a shot! It’s one of the best arts ever created.

6
Jitster•

See if you can find a recreation-focused BJJ club with some older people in it (rather than one that's mostly young guys focused on the tournament circuit, etc). A club like that is more likely to be accommodating re: any knee issues, etc. you might have.

You'll be spending a lot of time kneeling in one way or another in BJJ though - not sure if that kind of pressure on your joints is a problem for you or not.

5
BluDavidOP•

Not a problem, only running and Jumping hurts. I hope i can still compete at some level, i used to love tournaments

4
Jitster•

The only other potential issue I can think of is that some BJJ techniques involve carrying your opponents' weight with your legs - not sure if that's an issue for you. Here's an example: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=2P0dDGRJqeY&t=111s

Hope it works out for you - BJJ is a lot of fun!

3
cold_moon_55•

This is completely off topic but DDP yoga has had some real success with helping extreamly disabled people get completely back into working shape. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=qX9FSZJu448 I dont know what your knee issue is but maybe it can help you too.

3
BluDavidOP•

ill check it out, thanks :D

1
TwitsMcgeeKung Fu Kyokushin Sanda Modern Wushu Mantis Shotokan•

I don't know your exact condition, but I have osteoarthritis in one knee and had tendonitis in the other which has since cleared up. As long as I take all the necessary steps to help out my knee (RICE after a hard workout, lots of warm up and stretching after) I am able to train in most martial arts just fine, as long as I am not doing any extremely low stances or jumping. This did force me to quit modern wushu, but other martial arts are open to me.

I try to be realistic about it, but it honestly does not affect me much as long as I take the right precautions. I would also reccomend trying fish oil and collagen supplements, they can sometimes help joints.

3
TedtheawesomeZen Do Kai/wma•

I pretty much destroyed my knee the other year broke the leg and tore/ripped every tendon in my knee , can take any impacts or sudden changes of direction ...i too miss training but i terrified of someone forgeting and hitting the knee and stopping me from working or living :(

2
NinjatheClick•

I can only promote things I've actually done so spare me for not mentioning MMA or BJJ.

I would assume Inosanto Kali might be okay on the knees since a lot of my fellow students can't bend theirs far, and another is an amputee. They have to make modifications for the kicks and sweeps sometimes, but for the most part its "step here, hit there." My experience so far has been with stick, knife, and empty hand. The footwork pretty much stays the same, but the hands do different things based on what you're armed with. Various joint locks are also taught, which increased my subject-control skills at work big-time. Our training at work was largely CYA training, and barred us from doing skillful things. Kali changed that, but honestly, my school does blend JKD and BJJ into it pretty seemlessly, so I sometimes struggle to differentiate which techniques hail from where.

Systema is an art I took before. The jury is out on effectiveness with most people, but my perception is that it is what you would get if the military got really into Tai Chi. Lol. Its very gentle, and helps you open your hips and learn to move fluidly, which is great on the joints. Big time. My friend had two knee surgeries and that was the only art he practiced consistently with me. Now, my teacher was certified by Vlad, but didn't learn from Vlad. I was lucky to have a teacher that was more focused on the efficiency of movement and practicality of a technique. I'll tell you this. If you have a school that's local. Check it out. The videos on youtube so far seem to leave a lot of the good and practical stuff out. They just show you the magic tricks they known and it looks way too woo woo. If your local school is woo-woo then gtfo. Every style has bad schools trying to teach it. Use your judgement, but finding a Systema school is a lot easier than finding a Tai Chi school that teaches actual combat applications, in my opinion.

There's a lot of good arts, but those two are the ones that were easiest on my aging body.

2
maaaaxxxx1•

It may not be for you, but I recommend wing chun. There's no need to jump or run and I can't think of anything besides the kicks of course (which are a very small part of the style) that would bother your knees

2
Be--BopKendo, Iaido(Musō Shinden-ryū), Jodo & Kenjutsu(Shintō Musō-ryū)•

Do not be embarrassed, I have crappy knees, so I had to take a break from Iaido, but later I talked to one of the Sensei, and he told me I could do it while standing (this sensei had worse knee condition than mine). I returned to practice Iaido, and now I am better than ever. Still can't do anything on the ground, but I am working with my physiotherapist on that... I practice Kendo, Iaido, and Jodo daily, and my knees are okay. Sometimes I use KT Tape to support the area (especially for Kendo), which helps after my injury from last January (which I still haven't recovered from) and my general crappy knees.

I don't know much about BJJ, but don't let your injury stop you from doing what you love. Find a way around it. If BJJ isn't the answer, find a different martial art that fits your condition. In Jodo, I have a limitation in the way that my hand can't move all the way as required for Dobarai Uchi, that doesn't mean I will stop doing Jodo.

2
thesnakeinthegardenKung Fu, Shuai Jiao, BJJ, Boxing, Muay Thai, MMA, wrestling.•

doing bjj at a top school for 3 years (other places before that) not once have we don't jumping jacks or any warm up that isn't related directly to rolling. Check your ego and just come and roll. You're gonna have to check your ego anyway.

Part of BJJ is learning not to be embarrassed when someone is pressing their butthole/gentials violently against your face. You'll be fine.

1
BluDavidOP•

hahaha thanks, my main concern was everything that happens before people go to the ground, but hopefully i can take it. once in the ground im sure my knees will be fine.

1
thesnakeinthegardenKung Fu, Shuai Jiao, BJJ, Boxing, Muay Thai, MMA, wrestling.•

most bjj gyms start on the ground to avoid injuries. They do this with a certain amount of shame as this is an admittedly bad way to train to fight.

2
yoshieslunchboxBJJ•

I don't think there's ego in trying to avoid injury. Just the opposite.

1
thesnakeinthegardenKung Fu, Shuai Jiao, BJJ, Boxing, Muay Thai, MMA, wrestling.•

He said he'd feel embarrassed. That's all I was talking about.

1
shiranaihito99•

If you do BJJ you'll also have to avoid rolling with leg attacks or even entangling the legs.

1
ukam61500Taekwondo (6 yrs), Wing Chun (10 months)•

I don't know about BJJ but have you tried something like Wing Chun or Tai Chi?

Wing Chun is a very low impact type of class and focus mostly on hands. Depending on the school you probably wont see a lot of sparring but do a drill called "Chi Sau" which is considered sparring to them.

1
bdt00•

You were a black belt under the age of 20? Be prepared for some real martial arts when you start BJJ.

-2
BluDavidOP•

I Was a black Belt at 18ish wich is fine in my book, started training very young too. I know black Belts are hard to get in bjj but mine did take years of good effort. It's just a color, i'm not claiming to be a martial arts expert, just a guy who Loved it and misses it, TKD is an olimpic sport, it has real merit.

6
mugeupja•

Don't worry, I guess Judo isn't a real martial art because you can get a black belt by the time you're 15/16 XD And since BJJ is Basically Just Judo... I guess BJJ isn't a real martial art XD God, I love the snobbery.

4
BluDavidOP•

XD yeah, i don't know why people obsess over stuff like this, i try not to mind much but it's a bit hard.

3