InV15iblefrog•

I'm not sure I understand

32
echoapolloOP•

These sports show segments live on discussing hypothetical scenarios. Show like this usually have a graphics department to crank out these visuals (generally static images of players with game statistics superimposed). Using Excel came off like a shortcut to switch between scenarios, without having to map out the discussion in advance. If they had broken down the segment into a series of talking points/scenarios like:

  • Scenario 0: Lakers keep current roster
  • Scenario 1: Lakers acquire player X, trade players Y and Z
  • Scenario 2: Lakers allow contract for their center to expire, sign two one year contracts to leave flexibility for next year

... (ad nauseum sports hypotheticals, half of which are absurd and only mentioned for shock value)

  • Scenarios n : The Lakers waive all contracts and convert the Staples Center into a gathering place for frozen yogurt enthusiasts. They spend the remaining salary on turning the scoreboard into a beautifully inefficient dessert option menu.

If they had mapped out the scenarios ahead of time, they could have just made like 4-6 slides in powerpoint, impress.js or whatever the latest hot in-browser presentation library is.

tldr: Their solution works, but the duct-tape is shockingly visible.

-2†
Eureka22•

Your title makes it sound like you are telling them that they should use excel. It is confusing.

51
asad137•

Why go through all the trouble of doing that when they could just use excel?

Most of this sub is people using tools to make graphics that are inscrutable. And here you are complaining about data that are presented clearly?

21
pink_echoes•

Because just dumping numbers is far from data science/visualisation. Yes, it's easy to fuck it up, but not doing it isn't really good either.

-1†
asad137•

The whole point is that it doesn't have to be a visualization at all. It's just numbers. What matters here are the numbers. The clearest way to present these data is to just show the goddamn numbers!

15
echoapolloOP•

They had someone moving the cursor and editing cells live (video)

20
KopfJ4ger•

Why reinvent the wheel when Excel works just fine for this? He's a Salary Cap Expert. Seems like Excel is his tool of the trade.

45
droans•

Plus, Excel would work perfectly if it's unscripted and they're changing things on the go. No need for specialty software when all they're doing is changing the numbers around.

20

Are you making fun of the demo technique that got us through a round of funding?

15
asad137•

Sounds like a good use for Excel, TBH.

9

That's balls out. Somehow admirable. Might not be Excel. (even better)

13
droans•

Nah, that's definitely Excel 2013.

8

But one day it won't be AND THEN WE'LL SEE WHO'S FAT!

2
[deleted]•

[deleted]

1
ItsMeMudkip•

Excel is perfectly fine here if a bit dull

10
ncist•

I'm torn because the use of Excel in a TV segment is sort of remarkable. But it's also like... not malpractice in terms of presenting information. It's better for sure than a lot of TV segments that get posted on this sub

6

It's only remarkable because we've gotten used to billion dollar empires spending thousands of graphics editors for an hour of TV.

5
knife_in_guts_out•

Excel might be ugly, but if its inventors wanted me to erect a temple of adoration and perform blood sacrifices for them, I'd do it. That's how much I love it.

4

The worst bit about this is the person using the cursor instead of the keyboard.

2