How were Sacred Prostitutes selected in Ancient Times?

NSFW

Additionally, was every woman obligated to engage in temple prostitution? Was the role limited to women of a high social standing, or did peasants and slaves also participate? Who selected them? What was the average age of a sacred prostitute? Could they leave the position if they so desired?

How was the practice different in Mesopotamia? Sumer? Greece? Babylon?

Any knowledge you can share would be very helpful, thank you!

Posted Jul 19, 2018, 10:41 PM UTC

286
Naugrith•

As your question reveals, it is widely believed that sacred prostitution was prevalent in the Ancient World. However, like so much that is common knowledge, the evidence for it is much less solid.

It is true that we have several sources from the ancient world describing sacred prostitution: in Corinth, Babylon, and in many other places. The claims about Corinth have received the most attention from modern scholars for a very good reason. As Robin Osbourne argues in The Oxford Handbook of Ancient Greek Religion - sex in Greek sanctuaries was considered absolutely unacceptable, and therefore the claims made by Pindar about Corinth have been much debated.

Alongside the claims regarding Corinth we have the famous story from Herodotus regarding the temple to Aphrodite in Babylon. But Hannah Wiley argues in the same book that few scholars now accept that sacred prostitution ever existed in these cities. She points out that these tales often stretch plausibility in their details. Lucian for instance provides us with a detailed description of the Temple of the Syrian Goddess at Hierapolis, telling us that it possesses a number of 1800-foot phalluses which are ascended biannually by a man who remains perched on the tip for seven days, without sleep.

As Mary Beard and J. Henderson argue in ‘With This Body I Thee Worship”: Sacred Prostitution in Antiquity’, in Gender and the Body in the Ancient Mediterranean, these tales are often written as salacious tales intended as a practice of ‘othering’ by other Greeks, an argument also presented by Robert A. Oden Jr, who saw sacred prostitution as a literary motive used to denigrate an "Other".

One of the strongest writers on this is Stephanie Lynn Budin, who has attempted to conclusively correct the scholarship on this subject in her work: The Myth of Sacred Prostitution in Antiquity. She argues that the ancient evidence we possesses for sacred prostitution is based entirely on ancient ‘othering’ and modern misunderstanding. She begins her book on page 1 with the blunt claim: “Sacred prostitution never existed in the ancient near east or Mediterranean.” She then spends the book systematically refuting all the evidence that has previously been assumed to support this “myth”.

Budin argues that the overt examples of this practice from ancient authors originated almost entirely from Herodotus, and that: “Herodotus, like all Greeks, wrote about “barbarians” with the intention of proving the superiority of Greeks, and allegations of cannibalism and sexual licentiousness abound. In his descriptions of barbarian sexual mores, he may also have been trying to show the horrible results that could follow if proper women were not kept as guarded and secluded as they were in Greece. All the later Roman and Christian allegations of sexual initiation ultimately derive from this one passage in Herodotus.”

Budin quotes J. G. Westenholz who notes that “Such allegations [of sacred prostitution] first appear in the work of Herodotus (Hist. 1.199) whose view of Mesopotamian culture was considerably biased and whose speculations have been elaborated by Strabo in his Geography (16.1.20), and by other classical authors.” And R. Oden, in his analysis of the literary sources for sacred prostitution, concludes, “What appears to be a list of more than a dozen sources may in fact be a list of a couple of sources, perhaps even and ultimately a single source: Herodotus.”

Budin then moves on to Strabo. She argues that though 25% of historians’ evidence for sacred prostitution comes from Strabo, most of this is a mistake in translation by modern readers who have translated Strabo’s terms such as hierodule, pallakis, and even kataporneuô as referring to sacred prostitution when the language does not refer to any such thing. The only place where Strabo legitimately refers to sacred prostitution is when he speaks of Babylon, and this he derives primarily from Herodotus. Budin argues that: “Strabo does not function as independent, corroborating evidence for Herodotos in this case; rather, the Roman-age geographer merely repeats second or third hand what had been passed down to him in apparently garbled fashion. Strabo appears to be confused about Babylonian sacred prostitution, and his description, as we shall see, betrays his mistrust of the evidence.” Budin refutes the rest of Strabo’s evidence similarly, demonstrating how they derived from Strabo’s confusion over local customs.

Budin finishes her work by presenting a corollary argument, that sacred prostitution was largely a result of 19th century invention, influenced by James Frazer’s work The Golden Bough, itself based on biased Classical sources. She quotes G. Leick: “[T]he ‘sacred prostitute,’ who engages in sex as a magical rite in the context of some fertility cult or officiates in the rites of Inanna/Ištar, belongs to the ‘Golden Bough’ school of historical anthropology.” Budin then presents the argument by J. Assante: “This vision [of sacred prostitution] was largely derived from the 19th century view of ancient Mesopotamia as a forum of naive and primitive sexual freedom allowable before the Old Testament prophets imposed their more austere mores. The notion of Mesopotamia's sexual freedom … was anachronistically based in the 19th century version of it as an exclusively male preserve.”

Selected Primary Sources
Herodotus, The Histories: 1.199

Strabo, Geography: 6.2.6; 8.6.20; 11.14.16; 12.3.36; 16.1.20

Lucian, De Syria Dea: 6

Pindar, Fragment 122

Selected Secondary Sources
Eidinow, E. and Kindt, J., (eds), 2015, The Oxford Handbook of Ancient Greek Religion, Oxford, pp 18, 70

Beard, M. and Henderson, J. 1998. ‘ “With This Body I Thee Worship”: Sacred Prostitution in Antiquity’, in Gender and the Body in the Ancient Mediterranean, ed. M. Wyke, 56–79

Budin, S. 2008. The Myth of Sacred Prostitution in Antiquity. Cambridge.

11
abby-anneOP•

Thank you so much! This was an incredibly informative and thought-provoking post! I deeply appreciate your time!

If I may ask a follow-up question, are the primary sources on priestesses who engaged in prostitution misread or misrepresented? (Ex: Shamhat from The Epic of Gilgamesh is stated to sleep with multiple men, including the two heroes, on demand and works for Innan, in the Sibylline Books, prostitutes played an important role in the Veneralia festival)

4
Naugrith•

Shamhat is an interesting example. Again, like with so many of the ancient sources, she is commonly understood to be a priestess of Ishtar or Innan, and as she goes out and tames the wild man Enkidu by having sex with him and then teaching him civilisation, this then leads some writers to call her a sacred prostitute.

However, in the Epic of Gilgamesh, in Tablets 1 and 2 where she appears, at no point is she ever presented as a priestess, or that she works for the gods in any sacred capacity. At one point she encourages Enkidu to attend the Eanna Temple, but she encourages him to go visit the city of Uruk to visit Gilgamesh as well, along with many other behaviours intended to teach him how to be civilised.

The modern misunderstanding seems to rest on the word used in the Epic to describe her role. She is called a harimtu. Wikipedia of course says that this was a 'sacred prostitute' but there is no scholarly support for this. Most scholars translate the word simply as 'prostitute', a normal, common, secular prostitute who commonly worked in taverns.

J.G Westerholz covers this in his work “Tamar, Qēdēšā, Qadištu, and Sacred Prostitution in Mesopotamia”. He points out that it was only the harimtu's place within the tavern that linked them to Innan and Ishtar as they were the patron gods of Taverns and their inhabitants. This patronage may well have included some form of ownership of the tavern and regulation of the business carried out there.

But Westerholz points out that here we have very little information as to the nature of the relationship between the Temple and the Tavern, and we can infer nothing about the relationship from the little evidence we have.

Indeed I would say it would be problematic to define sacred prostitution as merely the Temple owning or regulating a brothel. During medieval times for instance the Christian Church did this regularly, the brothels at Southwark in London were owned by the Bishop of Winchester for instance. But no one could accuse the Church of being involved in Sacred Prostitution.

Consequently Westerholz goes on to define harimitu as "one who is outside the culturally defined bounds of controlled sexuality." Julia Assante goes further than this. She rejects the argument that harimtu was even a profession of any kind, but just a label for a single woman who had authority over her own sexuality, and thus had the freedom to have intercourse with any man she chose.

Interestingly, this fits with the Epic, in which no money is ever seen to change hands between Shamhat and either Enkidu or the trapper who asks her to meet with him. With this understanding, instead of being a case of sacred prostitution, Shamhat is just a young woman who falls in love with Enkidu and tames him through her love (and six straight days of hot sex).

Regarding the Veneralia festival, there were two Goddesses whose rites were celebrated on the same day. Venus Verticordia (Venus, turner of hearts), and Fortuna Virilis (Bold Fortune). The wealthy Roman matrons would celebrate Venus Verticordia, asking her to turn hearts of women from lust to chastity. Fundamentally this was a festival of Roman sexual propriety and chaste behavior. At the same time, the earlier festival of Fortuna Virilis was also celebrated, usually by the poorer women, and among them prostitutes. However like Venus Verticordia, this largely involved the ritual undressing and washing of the statue of the Goddess, and also involved the celebrants doing the same for themselves.

But this was not for the purposes of licentiousness. It was rather the opposite. As Ovid writes: "Ye, too, she herself [The Goddess] bids bathe under the green myrtle, and there is a certain reason for her command; learn what it is. Naked, she was drying on the shore her oozy locks, when the satyrs, a wanton crew, espied the goddess. She perceived it, and screened her body by myrtle interposed: that done, she was safe, and she bids you do the same". (Ovidus Fasti IV)

So, here likewise, there is no mention of ritual prostitution.

Westerholz, J.G., “Tamar, Qēdēšā, Qadištu, and Sacred Prostitution in Mesopotamia,” The Harvard Theological Review, Vol. 82, No. 3 (July, 1989), pp. 260-2.

Assante, J. "The kar.kid/harimitu, "Prostitute or Single Woman? A Reconsideration of the Evidence. Ugarit Forschungen 30 (1998) 5-9.

5
Rimbosity•

Great answer. May I ask a quick follow-up question? Your answer focuses on the Greek response to various cultures, but what about later ancient cultures, in particular the Roman empire?

1
Naugrith•

Well Lucian and Strabo were both writing during the Roman Empire, Strabo having lived in Rome for a time, though not a native citizen. Following Herodotus and misunderstanding foreign local customs meant that they spread the misconception further among their readers.

Other minor Roman sources that have often been used as support for the practice were Valerius Maximus who wrote in the early first century and talks about Punic women in Sicca; and Justinus in the second century, who describes the situation in Cyprus and Locri. However Budin demonstrates how these texts do not actually show sacred prostitution at all.

Finally, there are multiple Christian authors who lived during the Roman Empire, who wrote about the sexually licentious pagans with great distaste. These were Paul of Tarsus, Clement of Alexandria, Arnobius of Sicca, Lactantius, Eusebius of Caesaria, Athanasius of Alexandria, Firmicus Maternus, Augustine of Hippo, Sokrates Scholasticus, and Sozomen. Budin's argument is that these were accusational polemics, and are not credible.

3
[deleted]•

[removed]

1