[Students] Anyone else have their screen cracked because you had your surface in your backpack whit textbooks?

Kinda ridiculous that this is the reason I was given by a Microsoft representative when asking why my Surface screen suddenly shattered today.

I never take it out of my backpack, except for during class.

Posted Jul 21, 2018, 12:36 AM UTC

08
ratshackGo Go power Surface!•

Protip: glass breaks when squished between heavy things.

4
Jared_ChambersOP•

I'm 5'9 and 130lbs. I also don't wear my "back"pack between my thighs

-6
ratshackGo Go power Surface!•

Good for you!

2
VRising•

I think it would have to depend on how packed your backpack was. Taking a look just now at my SB2 and inspecting the bezel it appears it goes right to the edge. It is totally possible that if enough force was applied it could shatter the glass. People tend to treat backpacks way more careless than laptop bags. It's easy to forget what's in there and quickly drop it down on something hard like a floor or sidewalk. That amount of impact on something like the edge of your laptop can totally damage your computer. Personally I wouldn't keep it in a backpack unless it had one of those sections that was designed to house a laptop with some extra cushioning. No way would I just keep it in my regular schoolbag since I always throw that sucker around.

1
Jared_ChambersOP•

I have more weight from my butt sitting on my phone all day. One textbook shouldn't be able to crack a $1000 tablet/laptop

0
VRising•

Most backpacks aren't made to house a laptop. The bottom of backpacks are made to prevent tearing, maybe to stretch a little but it's purpose is to hold a decent amount of weight without ripping apart. A laptop bag has insulation on the top, sides, and bottom. It has a compartment for the laptop itself. Then you have to look at our daily actions. How you set down a backpack, laptop bag, or even a teacup will all be different. Perhaps of of those days it's possible you set your backpack down like well a backpack. Maybe you were tired. Maybe you were only thinking about the books inside and not the computer. It's just not that great a place to keep the Surface at least without some good cushioning. Even then you have books pressing hard against it with shoulder straps increasing the force. I mean would you let a small child sit on your computer? The amount of force you are applying to it is probably dozens of pounds per square inch. That's essentially the equivalent.

1
Hothabanero6•

This is a learning moment. It seems you are not absorbing the gravity of the lesson. You aren't the first (maybe there's a support group for that) and won't be the last.

Just like an earthquake can crack a building, the mass of books can easily apply cracking forces to a screen especially when books dimensions are smaller than the screen or they are aligned with edges across the inner portion of the screen. The Cost of the device has nothing to do with it but size is also an important factor, smaller is stronger. last I checked butts don't have hard edges unless maybe you're a supermodel^with.a.butt.implant.

1
Jared_ChambersOP•

I have a bony ass and this lesson was stupid on so many levels idk how to respond

1