What would you do?

[Advice Request]

Quick backstory: Found out yesterday from an aunt that nmom had a (I think) teen pregnancy and gave her daughter (my half-sister) to another aunt who adopted her.

Here's my dilemma. Nmom is a monster. Her own grandchild died from anorexia and she mentioned it in passing like you would the death of an acquaintance. Do I now tell my half-sister that THIS is her mother? Part of me is saying yes, as she has a right to know (she's always known she was adopted). The other part of me is saying no, because my cousin grew up in a wonderful, loving, healthy home. My aunt and uncle (now both passed) were two of the kindest, most loving people you could ever hope to meet. I actually used to fantasize that my aunt was really MY mom, and that for some reason she had to give me up and nmom took me in. Oh the irony.

I haven't spoken to my cousin (now sister) in over 15 years. She's older than me, with grown kids and grandkids of her own now. I assume that being told who her biological mother is will mean she'll want to get in touch with nmom, and I know nmom and I know what she's capable of - it might get very ugly.

What would you do? Reach out to your new sister and hope that nmom plays nice? (I'm NC btw and I'm staying that way, no matter what else happens) Or, say nothing and let my sister have all her good and happy memories and remain in blissful ignorance?

Posted Jul 23, 2018, 9:43 PM UTC

34
BittersweetTea•

Have you considered that maybe your half sister already knows who her mom really is? If she knows she’s adopted then there’s a good chance she already asked your aunt and uncle who her bio mom is or doesn’t want to know.

2
GraphiteInMyBloodOP•

I have thought about that. When I was chatting with my aunt today she didn't know if anything was said to my sister. I know she's not in contact with Nmom and never has been, other than at family get togethers when I was a kid. So she may know, and not want to be in touch with Nmom (maybe she saw what I never did). I just don't want to do anything to cause her pain, she doesn't deserve it.

1
diseased-mog•

I reached out to a half brother that had never met our Ndad and tried to establish a relationship but my dad of course felt it was the brothers job to seek out a relationship, not his to establish anything for the son he just left behind. I told the brother about how Ndad is and told him I wished so very badly that his dad was a better person but I still felt he deserved to know where his “dad” went all that time (21 years old never knowing)

Happy ending though! He now has 3 brothers and a sister he never knew about who all care about him and we all talk now! (3/5 are NC 1/5 is LC and the last still has to live there but is waiting for LC)

2
AutoModeratorMOD•

This is an automated message posted to all posts in this subreddit with some basic information about the group including (very importantly) rules. Why are you getting this message? Most people seem to not read the sidebar for information or the rules, so it is now being posted under all posts.

Confused about acronyms or terminology? Click here!

Need info or resources? Check out our Helpful Links for information on how to deal with identify theft, how to get independent of your n-parents, how to apply for FAFSA, how to identify n-parents and SO MUCH MORE!

This is a reminder to all participants, RBN is a support group that is moderated very strictly. Please report inappropriate content so it can be reviewed by the mods.

Our rules include (but are not limited to):

  • No politics.
  • Advising anyone in this subreddit to commit suicide or referring anyone to groups that advocate this will result in an immediate ban.
  • Be nice. No personal attacks, name calling, or bullying. No slurs or victim-blaming.
  • Do not derail the posts of others.
  • Narcissists are NOT allowed to post or comment here.
  • Please refrain from posting "uplifting" threads.
  • When you comment/post, assume a context of abuse.
  • No asking or offering gifts, money, etc.
  • No content advocating violence, revenge, murder (even in jest).
  • No content about N-kids.
  • No diagnosis by media/drive-by diagnosis.
  • No linking to Facebook pages.
  • No direct linking to anywhere on reddit.
  • No pure image posts.

For a full list of our rules/more information, click here.

I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.

1