What exactly is a key

From what I’ve gathered, a key is a collection of 7 notes that are used throughout a piece of music.

Although other notes can be used, these are the “go to” notes.

A key also seems to determine what note a piece of music feels like it wants to go to.

What I’m not sure about is what the 7 notes must be. Can they be any 7 notes? Do they need to be part of a major or minor scale? Do they need to fit on a key signature?

Could you have a key with A, A#,B,B#,D,E,F for example? This wouldn’t fit on a key signature, isn’t a major or minor scale, and probably wouldn’t sound very good, but it is 7 notes.

Posted Jul 25, 2018, 12:51 AM UTC

114
jarranahaz•

A key is basically a set of rules on which notes (accidentals) to use. You mentioned how C and A share the same Key signature. That is because if you were to start on C and play no accidentals, you’d get C Major Scale. If you played all the same notes starting on A, you’d get an A Minor Scale. These are called Parallel Minor Keys and every major key has one and vice verse. You find these by counting up 6 notes from the major tonic, and for a Minor you’d count up 3 notes. But more to the point, Keys and key signature basically tell you which notes to use, and you can think of them as a guide. Sort of like a “key” on a map. Hope that this helped feel free to ask anymore questions!

2
vornskaform, schemas, 18ᶜ opera•

Can they be any 7 notes?

No. There's nothing magical about the number 7. In most styles of music, the "key" involves a standard key signature. People talk about 7 notes because the major scale has 7 notes: major comes first, not the number 7.

(Ultimately, you can do anything you want. If you want to experiment with using a weird 7-note collection for your music, go ahead! But most styles stick to the standard major/minor scales.)

2
FsA918OP•

So would you say that a key can be any combination of notes with a tonic? Can I have a key with all 12 notes? Or do we consider music that don’t use major/minor keys not to have a key at all?

1
vornskaform, schemas, 18ᶜ opera•

I think most people would say that a key has to be based on a major/minor scale. It's of course more complicated, because you can use out-of-key notes, but the in-key notes still serve as the basis. If you wrote music that treated all 12 notes equally, most people would say that has no key.

On the other hand, if you wanted to use a piece that only had 7 notes in some weird scale, and you wanted to call that a "key" ... that wouldn't be standard, but it would be reasonable. It's a little bit like debating whether a hot dog is a sandwich. Would most people call it that? Maybe not. Can I see the logic of doing so anyway? Sure.

2
winterryeband•

A key is not a collection of notes, but an explanation for how those notes interact.

For example, take C major. It has the same notes as D Dorian or A minor, but the key is defined by the fact that C feels like "home" in C major. The fifth above C, which is G, is the dominant: it has a dominant place in the key, with the strongest resolution back to C.

The notes outside of the key can be played, as you noted, but their purpose or interaction is less clear and less consistent.

In essence, every note exists and can be used at any time, but the key gives you a sense for which of those notes will have what predictable effects.

2
Sorlz•

Key is short for key signature basically. C-B (7 notes) is C major but if you started it on a, it would be aminor . (a-g, g being the 7th) same notes, different key.

1
FsA918OP•

But the keys of C major and A minor appear the same in key signature. Key signature doesn’t tell you what the tonic is.

1
Sorlz•

It would be implied by the music itself. (I'm no expert by any means, mind you) Most chord progressions follow basic patterns.

2
[deleted]•

[deleted]

1
Musician-Moo•

In music, we often use a set of notes to determine how they sound and interact with one another. Through melodies and harmonies, we perceive how each note makes us feel.

In many cases, the set of notes are in seven. They do not need to be the same seven all of the time. Music consists of many, many patterns. Different patterns create what we have defined as the basic major scales and minor scales. You can also study different modes of scales.

Key signatures are an easier way for us to tell which set of notes we should play when we read music. Much of the musical notation we see today is so that it is easier for us to process all of the notes that are on the page. There are, conventionally, 15 of them. It is much easier for us to recognize that there are two flats in the set of notes we need to use rather than writing out all seven of them. We can determine the key signatures based on the patterns that we mentioned to earlier.

1
qwfparst•

A key is a mapping of tones to scale degrees. All tones "exist" in all keys, but we speak of tones being "outside" a key when what we really mean is they are more distant in a particular way with regard to a framing diatonic collection. In fact it's really helpful to conceive of each tone being capable of establishing it's own hierarchy of distance; hence, even the "inside" notes are not all equally distant from each other.

A diatonic collection are seven tones that are immediately adjacent to each other on the line of fifths:

Ab Eb Bb F C G D

Eb Bb F C G D A

Bb F C G D A E B

F C G D A E B

C G D A E B F#

Etc...

A diatonic collection is one of the coordinates used to tell you where you are in tone space.

Each collection itself can be conceived of having distance to other collections based on the number of fifths it takes to get to one from the other or even the number of overlapping fifths. Even when choosing one collection as a home base, there is no reason we can't conceive of multiple collections in the same piece. You can choose to hear one collection as being "sharper" or "flatter" via the network of fifth relationships; hence, we can sense progression or even regression.

How we choose to order a diatonic into a scale is related our next coordinate in tone space.


Without going into too much detail, periodicity and octave equivalence of pitches classes ("C2" being on some level the same as "C3" or "C4"), we can "fit" a diatonic collection into a single octave bounded by a framing pitch we can call label scale degree 1^. The particular way they fit allows us to perceive them in terms of scale steps where certain tones are adjacent to certain tones, non-adjacent to others.

Within a single diatonic collection, we can choose any member to be scale degree 1^ and thus order the tones into a scale. However, the line of fifths with its clear sense of distance between individual members has a built in sense of directionality that effects how we perceive different orderings.

The following table shows a small portion of these relationships. There's also an implied notion of the primacy of the Major mode as a frame of reference.

Note that I use a non-standard sense of "mode" because the modes here are not merely different orderings of a collection of tones but also give perceptual meaning to tones "outside" of its referential diatonic collection.

In the table, the "coordinates" refer to: (Diatonic collection, Tonic).

Here the reference coordinate is the C Major collection: FCGDAEB.

BbFCGDAEBF#C#G#
(C,F):F Lydian4152637#4#1#5#2
(C,C):C Major-Ionianb74152637#4#1#5
(C,G):G Myxolydianb3b74152637#4#1
(C,D):D Dorianb6b3b74152637#4
(C,A):A Aeolian-Minorb2b6b3b74152637
(C,E):E Phrygianb5b2b6b3b7415263
(C,B):B Locrianb1b5b2b6b3b741526
1
Jongtr•

A key also seems to determine what note a piece of music feels like it wants to go to.

That's the essential factor. The rest is whether the key is in the "major mode" or the "minor mode". We commonly just call those the "major scale" or "minor scale with occasional harmonic or melodic alterations".

IOW, keys depend on two specific kinds of scale: major and minor.
Both kinds of scale have a perfect 4th and perfect 5th;
Both also have a major 2nd degree;
The major scale has major 3rd, 6th and 7th degrees;
The minor key scale has a minor 3rd degree, while the 6th and 7th can vary; they are minor as standard, but are commonly raised to major when ascending to the tonic.
So, the one interval governing whether a scale sounds major or minor is its 3rd.

BTW, a 7-note scale needs one of each note letter. And it's not normal for a 7-note scale to require double sharps or double flats. That's why your scale A, A#,B,B#,D,E,F is not a standard 7-notes scale. We could relabel B# as C, which disposes of the two Bs, but if we rename A# as Bb we're back to two Bs! We'd need to label A "Gx" (G double sharp) to obey the one-of-each-note rule.

And we'd still have the unusual structure with three neighbouring semitones (A A# B C), and one big jump from F to Gx(A). None of the scales in common use (in keys or modes) contain two semitones next to one another. All contain a mix of tones and semitones (major and minor 2nds), aside from harmonic minor which has one augmented 2nd - and sounds quite "exotic" because of that.

1
Xenoceratops•

A key also seems to determine what note a piece of music feels like it wants to go to.

It's 100% this. A key is a pitch center.

From what I’ve gathered, a key is a collection of 7 notes that are used throughout a piece of music.

I would call that a pitch collection. With a pitch center, a collection can be called a mode.

Could you have a key with A, A#,B,B#,D,E,F for example? This wouldn’t fit on a key signature, isn’t a major or minor scale, and probably wouldn’t sound very good, but it is 7 notes.

Doesn't really matter. Depending on the key, the actual pitch center, you would choose a key signature and write accidentals where needed. For what it's worth, this is actually closer to a diatonic collection than you might initially think. For example, this could easily be A minor (A B C D E F G) with A#/B♭ interpolated (the spelling depends on the accidental's usage). Spell that B# as C, yo. Could also be D minor (D E F G A B♭ C) with B thrown in. How about F major (F G A B♭ C D E) with B thrown in? However, you could have any key with as few as one pitch or as many as ∞ pitches.

1
ZiggyXyon•

Your thinking about it too much it should take 30 seconds to learn what a key is.

-1
winterryeband•

"Your thinking about it too much."

It takes 30 seconds to learn the difference between "your" and "you're," and yet here we are.

8