How canonical are the chalice dungeons?
The dungeons have a lot of original content that's clearly meant to add to the main story, but there are also elements that are clearly there for gameplay purposes (root chalices, additional rites, etc). This raises a lot of questions about which elements of the dungeons are intended to be canon and which ones aren't.
Critical questions are: what does it mean to fight Rom and Ebrietas once outside the dungeons and once within? What does it mean that alternate versions of Workshop weapons can be found in them? Are the dungeons a physical place under Yarnham, or part of the nightmare, or something else?
Posted Jul 26, 2018, 3:40 AM UTC
I’m no expert, but I say it’s all canonical. Yes, all of it. Spoilers ahead, obviously. Massive spoilers.
My understanding is that the chalices were what the Healing Church used to get the Old Blood and where they first found Ebrietas. In fact, I think it was the Isz Chalice that was found first. Then, they found the Pthumerians and their chalices were protecting more Great Ones.
Why is Ebrietas in both the Cathedral "basement" and in the Chalice? I believe that the altars and chalices warp time or something like that. Or... maybe they are alternate realities/dimensions/universes. Rom? Did he really die? Did he go to the Chalice Dungeon to try and stop you from finding Ebrietas? (He’s in Isz, too.) Recall, in the "main game" Rom is trying to stop you from finding the Y’har Ghul. The Unseen Village was the site of the Mensis Ritual (which is going on while you make your way to The One Reborn) and clearly a place where the citizens were sacrificed to the quest for Eldritch power and knowledge. This is similar to the atrocity that happened on the Fishing Villiage. Maria and Gehrman slaughtered the inhabitants after the Church used them for experiments and "research."
Rom, like the Healing Church, wants to hide the secrets. Ebrietas is the source of the Church’s and the School’s knowledge. Both organizations wanted to find a way to transcend humanity and ascend to becoming a Great One. Ebrietas gave the Pthumerians, and then the Church, the Old Blood. It’s also the Pale Blood. "Seek Pale Blood," we are told, "To transcend the hunt." Now, if you gather and consume three Third Umbilical Cords prior to fighting, not submitting to, Gehrman, then you defeat Gehrman, you can fight the true Final Boss, Moon Presence. When you defeat the Moon Presence, you get a cutscene that shows the Doll cradling a squid in her arms and calling it "Good Hunter" that suggests you have transcended the hunt, you are a newly- born Great One, like Kos or Ebrietas.
All of that began when the Healing Church’s Tomb Prospectors found Ebrietas. They had been searching for a cure to the Beast Scourge. I think the Scourge began because the Church was pushing the limits of Blood Ministration. Originally, I think the church just wanted to make people well. But then they found they could make people better and stronger. And they met Pthumerians who had similar ideas. So, it got out of control and people became beasts. And the Church experimented on beasts as we found in Old Yharnum.
The Chalice Dungeons, the "non-root" chalices, are like history lessons, to me. So they are all canon, in my opinion.