r/btc•
2ndEntropy

About Pre-consensus

It's a bad idea, why?

If you know the results in progress of an election it affects how you vote.

This is partly why the block size debate was so corruptible, no-one wanted to be the person to rock the boat but everyone was thinking the same thing, we just need to do it. The ones that did defect from core got such a huge amount of backlash from the "community" that no-one wanted to follow. Miners should of had 2014 blocks to vote, they would vote with an encrypted message in the blockheader, then publish the private key to establish the results.

Pre-consensus breaks a lot of the game theory of mining, every hash is a vote, it is important to remember this.

Posted Jul 26, 2018, 3:40 PM UTC

05
homopit•

every hash is a vote

If every hash is a vote, then why to waste all the hashes in between the blocks? Put them to work!

3
2ndEntropyOP•

No hash is wasted, each hash could find a block.

Yes you can put them to additional work... for example they can by used as proof for the merchant that a particular miner is working on a particular transaction. This can be done by simply signing a message that contains the SVP Merkel root and the attempted PoW, this should be given directly to the merchant. Only if the miner finds a block and does not include your transaction should you disclose that to other miners. Other miners are then free to retaliate against the hostile miner.

0
0321Reddit•

should of

should have*

2
GrumpyAnarchist•

I gave Amaury a pass on his pushing the idea of Selfish Mining as a legit threat even though no miner has ever tried it.

But now this is the second round of bullshit and now the fake problem is with 0-conf.

ABC client UNINSTALLED. My little bit of hashpower no longer supports that software.

-1
ThomasZanderThomas Zander - Bitcoin Developer•

What are you mining with now? And why are you solo mining?

edit; a word

6