Organizational brainstorm: should I separate contents or keep in cases?

OK, so now that I've indulged in an embarrassing B&N sale haul, I'm thinking about storage. I'm tempted to keep discs in accessible folders, make shelf space for insert booklets, & pack away jewel cases (or possibly recycle/discard). However it seems like most on this site keep everything together & file on shelves. I'm trying to declutter, but also don't want to over-complicate.

Is this a lame idea or not? Sound off & thanks in advance

Posted Jul 29, 2018, 8:51 PM UTC

611
CaptainGibb•

Personally, if you opt for doing that i HIGHLY suggest you keep the cases and artwork somewhere. Down the road you may regret getting rid of them. That being said, if youre sure you don't want them, I'd be willing to buy the cases off of you of you'd prefer that.

5
GialloBrowOP•

Thanks for the offer; of course I would prefer to help anyone on this site vs discarding to the ether. If I decide to ditch I'll follow up

3
CaptainGibb•

Sounds good! If you do decide to ditch the cases, at least keep the artwork (in a folder or something to keep them flat) and the digibooks. That way if you change your mind down the road you can always buy replacement cases for them. Ive just seen some people on here ditch their cases and artwork and then regret it

4
GialloBrowOP•

Completely agree. Unsurprisingly, Criterion's TLC to art&packaging is part of what I love about the series so I'm holding those items & filing the art flat (currently from other DVDs, my CCs are in cases so I can sort right now). All those years of nerding with a comic collection have instilled paper preservation etiquette...

1
palaner•

It's a great idea and will cut down on your home looking like a video rental store.

3
demacnei•

Yeah I’ve got that problem right now, but I’d never put my discs into cd binders.

I did it for all the discs I burned from renting from various stores, libraries, and Netflix and it’s a pain looking those up and they aren’t in great condition. It kinda sucks but all those burned DVDs look like crap anyway. I also set aside some cases and artwork for legit releases, and after a couple moves I couldn’t find them.

2
GialloBrowOP•

Did discs get damaged from the binders, or was it just a pain flipping through them all?

2
demacnei•

It was both. ... some light scratching and a pain flipping through. I also found that whenever friends came over and we wanted to watch anything, they were always saying it would be better to have the case to help them pick out a movie.

2
IgnantPhuck13•

Sounds like a good idea if it will actually save you shelf space... just ran out of space myself, don’t wanna do all that now I gotta buy new storage shelves :(

2
CyRo3Established Trader•

It all depends on your set-up. If you don’t find it “lame” then it’s not. :) Gotta do what works for you.

Just a word of advice: if you do separate the discs from the cases, be careful and make sure you get really good, quality sleeves for the for the discs. I made that mistake a long time ago, and I’ll never do that again. I ended up with a bunch of damaged DVDs due to residue getting on the discs from the sleeves. Just do your research and you should be fine.

2
GialloBrowOP•

Egads- thank you for that insight. Needless to say that absolutely sucks about having damaged disks from the shoddy sleeves.

2