I've been working on a HL2 Jump for a while, and i'd like some feedback.
drive.google.com/file/d/1FKwA7dzXmf3JVcwMa8uX...Posted Jul 30, 2018, 7:23 PM UTC
Posted Jul 30, 2018, 7:23 PM UTC
Format wise it looks good and ready, gonna have a build soon
Good stuff
Overwatch Squad Leader
Gluon Gun (B&E/Burglary), rips through and disintegrates groups of enemies easily - Citadel, complete with staff, soldiers, Stalkers and synths. -
Adventure Lusted
N.E.R.D.S.
fully staffed, scientists skilled in gengeneering, harnessing ZPE -
Gorgon's Nest
Minerva
Entropy
Diary Entry #1361
Looks pretty good the only suggestions I would make is make the goals a bit more optional like a reward or so turning traitor to whatever faction is an option (However unlikely that is). And maybe instead of advisor a more human like administrator origin with leadership/tech perks. Such as the ability to give well written speeches that while not really overly charismatic allows one to create an alternate view of a situation.
The alternate way to end the jump IS optional, and if you wanna defect, go for it. If you're Resistance, I can't say with certainty the Combine would listen, but if you wanna, go for it.
Someone asked about having an Administrator role, but I don't really think it'd be that interesting. Consider that someone like Wallace Breen is basically just a puppet for the Advisors. They have a little power, sure, but Advisors work for the main big technological role and leadership of the Combine since they're it's actual leaders.
Plus I can't think of too many items for such a role. Monitors, maybe? Dunno.
If you wish to have a humanlike form, you could likely just shapeshift or utilize those psionic powers the role gives you to create something akin to an illusionary one.
Ah ok didn't realize those endings were optional. And your points make sense for not having administrator origin. Other than the odd ideas I had, this Jump seems pretty much complete. Nice job.
Becoming an Advisor, just to turn traitor to the Combine would be hilarious.
Kinda, and it's practically required with one of the drawbacks.
"Behold, I am the ONE TRUE GRUBBY! There is no Grubs better than I - all slaves are freed and all worlds will be restored!"
This is a great start, but you need to do a better job of differentiating combine-aligned origins and resistance-aligned ones. Like, if you’re a resistance fighter, what does it mean to purchase a citadel? If you’re an advisor, how does parkour skill translate? Stuff like that.
Also: unforeseen consequences doesn’t give nearly enough cp for the risk.
You make a good point on some of them, i'll be sure to add more stuff to the notes section. Though consider a lot of Combine technology is often reverse-engineered by the Resistance. I could easily see that for most of the weapons, vehicles and even synths.
For something like a Citadel? Hmm. That's a tough one. Though we could always consider the idea of there being more than one Universal Union, considering we're dealing with alternate timelines and dimensions when it comes to their extent of reach. A bunch of defectors? Help from another Union? There's a few possibilities to be sure.
For the Advisors, it could simply increase the amount of control that you possess via telekinesis, making you move faster and dodge more swiftly.
As for Unforeseen Consequences, I honestly didn't see it as too bad. They do scale up, yes, but with the amount of resources you can get here, it shouldn't really be that big of an issue until probably the end. Regardless, i'll probably boost the CP gain, though that leaves the 400 CP drawback open.
Oh, uh... the term is "Sapient" not "sentient". A rabbit is sentient, but not sapient. A human is both sentient and sapient.
Where in the jump are you referring to?
You called Vortiguants sentient, but most fauna from Xen are sentient - Vortiguants are sapient.
They're not sapient. That word is to refer to homo sapiens, and is used in sci-fi in the manner you speak, but many races in sci-fi are humanlike, Vortigaunts are not. It would be more proper to call them intelligent creatures. You don't hear scientists talk about "sapient life-forms" when you hear talk of aliens.
Other than their bipedal nature, they're nowhere close to homo sapiens. I will change it, however, good catch.
The perks seem a bit weaker than many of the jumps I usually see. The drop in capstone seems to be a bit weakish, three times faster learning in combat seems kind of sluggish when you consider most of the learning a jumper is going to be doing out of combat. Items seem to be stuff one can pick up in jump for the most part thus may I suggest giving the items upgrad like maybe stating they tend to appear out of hammerspace when not to implausible, aka unless you searched for weapons thoroughly enough to find any weapons you hidden the guns will always be there if you reach for them. This solves the issue of carrying them around thus making items more appealing. Alternately you can make the items say stronger thanthere in jump counterparts thus making grabbing them a real boon.
A nice perk would be some kind of combat enhancer maybe something that will let a untrained person who never used a gun take on a hostile marine/overwatch solider and let a trained soldier shoot out with a squad on even terms. Something that lets you fight like a video game protagonist or Gordon freeman. It will make it a much more appealing jump from a jumpchain prespective and help a jumper keep up with the one man army running around.
I guess i'll tackle your points one by one.
The perks being on the weaker side is kind of on purpose. Disregarding Combine technology, the jump is honestly relatively low-power. Combine Tech and the potential that possesses is aimed for the the Jumpers who want powerful things.
You can pick up many of the weapons in the jump, but a large majority of those are the cheaper weapons. Stuff like the Gluon Gun, HEV, Tau Cannon, Immolator, Shockroach, Gravity Gun, and several more are either one of a kind items, or simply items that were lost during the Seven Hour War and beyond. As for the hammerspace option, that doesn't make sense with anything in the jump, so no, not going with that. Also remember that almost all the armor and weapons come with schematics, so you could make more for others and the like.
The Run, Think, Shoot, Live is the One-man-army kind of perk for this jump. Three times faster doesn't sound like too much, except it very much is. I was likely going to add another perk to Drop-In regardless, but you combine that perk with something like Overwatch Training, you'll be more than enough to keep up with Freeman.
Yes, I know there's already a regular Half Life Jump, but HL2 has a lot of extra stuff, especially in the form of the Combine, which are one of my favorite factions in any video game.
I've added stuff from both games, and i'm honestly pretty happy with it right now.
I'd post it to somewhere like the 4chan threads or SB, but I don't associate at all with either group.