r/Destiny•
siamond

How Do You Justify Your Belief? - Debate with Darth Dawkins

Posted Jul 31, 2018, 9:57 PM UTC

4927
DisErect•

Muting your "debate opoment" must be one of the weakest pussymoves ever. Gotta be the fastest way to reach top contender for fuckiest faggot destiny debated.

Literally smh

50
[deleted]•

Don't even mention his name. I do not think that people who do not argue in good faith should even be allowed to have a voice. Destiny should not have put this video up on youtube.

21
project_twenty5oh1SIR•

responsible deplatforming u/NeoDestiny

5
dekkerson•

Destiny should not have put this video up on youtube.

I disagree. I can clearly see that Darth was a fucking asshole and his argument was nonsensical and it discredited his own faith just to make Destiny look bad.

Before I watched this video I didn't know who this guy was and now I'll remember not to listen to anything Darth Dawkins has to say because he is disingenuous piece of shit.

Other then that I think Destiny DID look bad (because of Darths failure to be a decent human being and letting him ask questions) yet he did prove his point this time (unlike in their last conversation). The only lacking point here is that Darths faith also is based on prepositions and following Darth line of thought is also FALSE (like everything, according to his argument).

Overall I think that was worth the chemotherapy I need to endure now to digest this fucking cancerous "debate".

5
getintheVandell•

Hard disagree here. I’ve never encountered this argument before, and now I have a good idea of how to handle it should I find it in the future.

If Destiny floundered and didn’t do a good job at exposing the guy, I would be agreeing with you.

1
Deltaboiz•

You haven't heard the argument because it's an asinine argument to make. I'm not one to call out people demanding falsibility criteria since I think people take the BURDEN OF PROOF MAY MAY way too far at times

But asking for a falsibility criteria for something that is unfalsifiable by it's own definition is pretty fucking stupid.

1
getintheVandell•

Asking that didn't make it expressly bad; people ask dumb questions all the time.

What made it bad was the complete unwillingness to respond to anything until he was allowed to gloat about his victory beforehand.

1
Yatsura2•

for something that is unfalsifiable by it's own definition

Thats just a claim though and also the very claim they wanted to debate about. I think its the opposite: its fucking stupid to debate an argument if you yourself think you lost it already beforehand.

1
alsandersname 1000000 examples•

chill with the f bomb

16
schwafflex•

no

6
Bojarzin•

This was completely unbearable. That guy is so far up his own ass

48
Inangelion•

Did he just debate a dialogue tree?

26
Clarityy•

Yeah I think having a rehearsed argument is fine but this guy literally cannot go "off-script" it's obnoxious as hell

12
ArosHD•

Yup. He is a presuppositionist, or presupp for short. There are many of them on Discord who go around making identical arguments following the same script. They even have the same tactics of muting people etc.

They are quite well known and popular in these circles but literally use the same arguments and form EVERY time and it's frustrating for most people so they seem to win the argument.

If you search for them you can find a Wiki which has more info on them. They even have certain questions they won't answer and will leave the calm if you ask them.

I've personally only has the pleasure to talk to Mr Batman who also has a Facebook page where he posts Right-wing Christian memes and he's a school teacher...

5
Xilis•

A very apt comparison he made recently was that Darth is like a Bethesda NPC.

2

it's always the same thing with darth.

12
spubbbba•

Darth Dawkins has been a huge meme in the atheist/philosophy sphere for ages.

I don't think he has any interest in converting people to Christianity. He just uses the jargon and some really basic tricks to get one over on atheists. Even that isn't very effective as anyone who speaks to him can tell that he railroads them into following his script.

It's rather pathetic if the best proof you have for your deity are some silly word games.

10
JTS_•

Fuck me I can't stand this kind of apologist. DD embarrasses classical christian thought and makes the entire intellectual history of Christianity look bad.

7
surprisinglycat•

Why does the dude get to claim he has the word of god if the bible wasn't written by god but hundred of years later by simple people? why would the bible be the word of god if it's a collection of texts curated by people hundreds of years later from a vast array of similar texts that too weren't written by god, but by people who lived after god?

Doesn't he have the exact same leg to stand on as Destiny? That he has to rely on perception of people/themselves instead of some divine being?

4
ArosHD•

Good luck even getting to that point in an argument with them. They control the flow and won't let you even ask these questions and will ignore you if you do.

If they do endulge you, they deflect to asking you what other Gods could exist but more commonly they'll claim that the Bible is perfectly logical and has accurately predicted the future since it's inception. Trying to argue specifics beyond that doesn't go too well either as they will pull up some crazy "facts" to support them and dismiss most of what you say.

10
Yatsura2•

Well, they are doing pisspoor job at convincing people then. At this point I have to wonder why they are even doing this in the first place? Because they aint turning anyone to religion like that.

1
Blahface50•

I'm only 10 min is so far. Is this guy Matt Slick? He sounds exactly like him and uses the same ridiculous word salads to make his argument.

3
Cecil900•

What the fuck did I just listen to?

2
dekkerson•

Regarding the discussion, I know some of you hate Matt Dillahunty but he mentioned the retarded point that this fanatic was making:

https://youtu.be/QHg_NL4EUAE?t=18m45s

And if you don't like to see his fat face here's a quote for you:

"Is there likely to be a debate that has as it's topic 'Is science reasonable? Is science rational? Is evidence reasonable? Is it reasonable to rely on evidence?'. We could get into a loop where I can present evidence and arguments for why we should consider evidence and argument reliable and we may never get out of that loop but at least we could get to a point where it's self evident (..) that relying on evidence is reasonable."

Well shit, as long as both parties debate in a good faith, sure. Here, the guy was a total asshole trying to get a GOTCHA BITCH moment like the argument that he was making in regards to what Destiny thinks is reliable (evidence, his senses, reasoning etc) doesn't concern him. An why? Because if god exist he is absolute and therefore he is RIGHT while Destinies premises are WRONG. That's the most fucking retarded thing I've heard this month, but it's 1/08 so let's check Trumps twitter feed....and it's the second most retarded thing I've seen this month.

Now to more serious comment:

I DON'T KNOW ANYTHING ABOUT YOU EXCEPT THAT YOUR NAME IS A NAME OF A GAME DESTINY

NOW YOU LISTEN TO ME

BIGGEST POLITICAL CHANNEL EVAAAH

I want to have babies with this admin.

2
Yatsura2•

*"I believe in god because I say he exists. How dare you to say you dont believe in god because you say he doesnt exist! I am the only one allowed to make circular arguments that include the conclusion in the premise!"*

1
Yatsura2•

"You cant proof cause & effect. Its just an assumption"

I dont understand that line. We know cause & effect through observation around us and it works every single time. There is no possible outcome to push the cup and not seeing it fall. On the other hand, we never ever observed anything about god and whenever someone predicts anything about it, it doesnt happen whatsoever. So how can both be falsifiable?

1