Is anybody else confused by The Wheel?

Discussion

In PoE 1, Spoiler I took this to mean that "The Wheel" is just the abstract concept of the cycle of reincarnation, souls or whatever.

Then, in Deadfire, we discover that Spoiler Besides being seemingly contradictory, that raises so many questions.

Most importantly, Spoiler

I feel like I must have missed or misinterpreted some crucial detail. Or is it really that inconsistent?

Posted Aug 2, 2018, 12:14 AM UTC

4628
PresidentDukakis•

Being confused by The Wheel is basically mandatory for all players and in-game characters

37
obscureposter•

It is mentioned in the game that without the wheel souls will still enter new bodies but it will be chaotic and with no direction as it is now. Basically the wheel directed reincarnation but reincarnation will still happen without it but in its own fashion.

22
holscher•

AFAIK it is not clear that the old way of redistributing souls will be reestablished when the engwithan wheel is destroyed. I think both ways of cycling souls has been ended by the end of deadfire

8
JavaSpread•

As the other user mentioned, I think it broke the cycle, not just the Engwithins' addition. The way Alex Scokel described it is that breaking the wheel also messed up the natural process (or maybe more that the natural process was borked by the new wheel and now the new wheel is gone) . If you change the natural process of a river with a dam and then fuck up the dam, that doesn't mean the river is just going to go back to what it was.

6
obscureposter•

That is entirely possible and probably true. This game does a really bad job at explaining what is going on to be honest. I was just going with what is mentioned in the game but I probably missed some dialogue somewhere that explains it.

6
JavaSpread•

Yeah, I think the content was cut. There's nothing in game (right now) that explains it. Hopefully they add it back in later.

6
6thAnnual•

Josh Sawyer (Deadfire's Director) has explained this a little more on his Tumblr page.

Edit: Also this.

22
SentientRhombusOP•

Oookay, so it's two different versions of "The Wheel" and the difference is never explained in the game because the dialogue was cut. Kinda unsatisfying, but at least I'm not crazy.

14
atresj•

Yeah, also this topic pops up every now and then on this sub because the fan community is decentralized. Josh has confirmed storytelling issues due to cutting dialogues literally during the first 2 weeks of release. They said they will look into improving the explanations somehow in the DLCs.

Around last week they've also said that the >!machine Eothas destroys by end of game could be paralleled with the water flow controler on a dam - but not the dam itself; when you remove the regulator the water will stop flowing but there's no telling whether it will clog the river completely or if it will overflow fast and cause everything to scale out of proportion!<.

14
-Spherikal•

They really should add a in-game book or something (anything) with this information, cause it’s pretty important stuff to know about.

11
Hydrall_Urakan•

Or just... Update the game with more dialogue, maybe? I feel like that's something they can actually do.

17
SentientRhombusOP•

Yeah, it's key information about arguably the most important decision you have to make in the game. Extra frustrating for my guy because he was supposed to be a scientist, yet wasn't given the option to ask those obvious questions.

I agree; an in-game book would be better than nothing.

7
not_old_redditor•

Wow I hadn't seen this before, pretty much explains why it's so vague in the game - they cut a bunch of dialogue out and streamlined it to the point where there IS no in-game explanation...

13
TWK128•

And this happened after their fig campaign exceeded their goals?

How?

7
ZobEater•

Besides the fact that crowdfunding is mostly marketing at this point and i would be surprised if it accounted fot a majority of the development budget, cuts always happen whatever the size of the project. I'm not a writer at all, let alone a professional one, but unless a piece of information is identified as critical (and i would not expect this one to have been) it's not unimaginable to see it cut as part of a larger dialogue/text sequence that wouldn't have fit the final product. You'd have to track lore concepts individually in order to make sure they're explained somewhere else if you cut some appearances. I'm sure they do that to some extent, they probably did not include this specific piece of info in the "must be in the game" category :D

4
Rosbj•

Probably not a funding, but lore issue - maybe telling the story in their DLC in more coherent and presentable way?

1
ventusvibrio•

My understanding of the wheel is that reincarnation as we know is possible because of the wheel. But that is not the true purpose of the wheel. The wheel is made to feed the gods. This is designed by the Egwenians when they decided to become gods of different aspects themselves. In the 1st game, we learn how they were able to do it : by combining souls of devotees of the same faith into one deity. These deities can live for a long period of time but eventually will run out of souls energy and require “feeding” or they would starve and die. They also learn that used souls when put in new body would “recharged” and can be consumed again. So The Wheel was created. When you die, the souls are directed by the wheel to a designed area where they are then lure toward the god they worshiped in life. They are then used up by the gods and put back to earth to charge up again. If the Wheel is destroyed, then the souls will go somewhere not even the gods know and the gods would slowly starve to death.

10
SentientRhombusOP•

I think what threw me most was that the majority of the endings mentioned something about kith repairing or devising some alternative to The Wheel as if it's necessary for life to continue. There was also some dialogue strongly implying that if The Wheel were destroyed, new births would be hollowborn (although I think it was the player character's dialogue, so they may have just been making shit up).

Based on the links u/6thAnnual posted, it seems like there was additional content explaining how the Engwithan version of The Wheel differed from the natural cycle, but it was cut from the final game.

6
ventusvibrio•

I mean that was Xoti’s main companion quest thing where we learn that animancers could potentially create a Wheel like application for the souls she was haversting. And according to Wael, the gods don’t know for sure what would happen to the souls if the Wheel is destroyed. Because before the Wheel was create by the Egwinian, souls must have gone somewhere.

2
ventusvibrio•

Also, Hollow borns are because Thayne was stealing souls from the Wheel to feed his God, Wicca ( I think?). Again, my understanding of the story is that the gods do not know what would happen and what Eortha was doing give them anxiety because they have to deal with the unknown. which is what Eortha wanted. He thinks the gods are stagnant and this destruction would potentially move the gods and Kith toward a new era. The dawn of the new day so to speak.

2
not_old_redditor•

I don't think you read OP's comment, the very first spoiler paragraph.

2
ventusvibrio•

Yeah. I was on the phone app and couldn’t reveal the spoiler thing.

3
Hxfhjkl•

This question also really bugged me. Listening to the gods i got the impression that people would eventually die off because souls would be trapped in the beyond without means to reincarnate. A proper explanation for this seems like a really bad area of the game to decide to cut out.... It diminishes the role playing aspect of the game, when you get false impression of basic themes in the game.

5

Your spoiler links just take me to the reddit mobile homepage. Is this just me?

3
Ninjacide•

If you're on PC and you hover over the links, you can see the text he's hiding behind the spoiler tags. If you're on your phone... well... yeah.

9
holscher•

The reddit is fun app handles spoiler tags well

3
KingofMadCows•

None of the characters are all knowing. They interpret the universe based on their understanding and culture. They may be wrong without being intentionally deceptive.

What the Engwithans discovered did not conform with their religious beliefs but that doesn't mean their conclusions are correct.

1