Knee-jerk reaction to 2e
I want to like this. I want it to work. Some of the ideas sounded amazing. I know it's a draft.
But the formatting of this book is horrifying. The text is cluttered and split in ways that are completely unnecessary. The summaries are spread between four or five tables, across pages, scattered throughout the descriptions. I lost track of how often a term was introduced with a reference to hundreds of pages later and no explanation. Words are re-defined as other words when you could just use the first word instead. A "Trait" can be anything from a bomb to a humanoid. There are (at least) three new arbitrary point systems, none of which seem necessary.
I know I need to spend more time and give a more accurate review, but honestly... This is painful. I love Pathfinder's complexity and depth. I enjoy 5e's elegance even as I wish it were more customizeable. At the moment, PF2 is all of Pathfinder's complexity, with added crunch and new terms don't seem to help anything.
If other people like these things, maybe it's just not a system for me. But I would be fairly surprised.
Posted Aug 2, 2018, 7:17 PM UTC · edited