I can understand why alcohol is legal, but why are tobacco products still legal?

Basically, alcohol has existed since the beginning of human history, and is practically a staple of human culture, existing for thousands if not tens of thousands of years, so I can see why making it an illegal recreational drug would be stupid at this point. But the second most popular recreational drug, tobacco products (or more accurately, nicotine) is where I get confused. Tobacco is a much more recent drug (saive the Native American populations) that has only been in western culture for around 5-600 years at this point, you could argue its popularity is why it’s still legal, but other smokable drugs like opium and marijuana were also extremely popular, yet they are illegal. Is there some reason this recreational drug is still legal?

Posted Aug 7, 2018, 2:14 PM UTC

226
shezofrene•

its profitable and goverment gets hella lot taxes out of it and most people enjoy smoking and smoking was a thing long before westerners have adapted it

10
PolluxCaesarOP•

Yes but western culture is what dominates now, what was important to say, Native American culture is largely irrelevant, that’s a small portion of Americans and South Americans that have a long standing culture with tobacco. The taxes argument is much more believable.

Also lots of people like smoking crack, marijuana, etc, and they could make tons of taxes off that, yet those (saive marijuana in some states) is still illegal, so there’s gotta be something more there.

-5
shezofrene•

who said anything about native americans? tobacco was brought to americas by immigrants from Ottoman Empire and Middle East.one of the founders of philip& morris was an ottoman jew.

2
PolluxCaesarOP•

Just did a quick bit of research, can I get a source for that? All sources I see point to first European contact with tobacco being with the native Americans in the 15th and 16th century, only thing when I try and find something with tobacco and the ottomans is a modern article about how tobacco is really popular in the UAE

yeah, it was introduced to the ottomans from the americas, namely the Caribbean

1
shezofrene•

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/History_of_smoking second paragraph.im talking about the habit of smoking in general.and cigarettes produced today.

and this guy is one of the founders of philip morris

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Morris_Schinasi

1
TheCulbearSays•

If you think western culture dominates it you have never been to Asia. Not only are the populations huge there but the number of smokers per capita is crazy higher. Smoking is slowly dying in the US most especially. Things like vaping and associates practices have all but ensured that.

1
PolluxCaesarOP•

I should have said in the West and Europe, I didn’t mean anything bad, I just meant that European based cultures are very prevelant

Oh I see what you mean now, I meant that the western, European inspired cultures are what is most prevelant in the Americas and Europe, not that smoking was started by the west. I do realize Asian cultures have a long standing smoking culture

1
seinfeld11•

Imagine if heroin was popular and accepted culturally for hundreds of years. Now make it illegal overnight. Can you imagine the chaos that would ensue?

3
PolluxCaesarOP•

That is kinda what happened though, opioids were super popular in America in the 19th century, then the pure food and drugs act was passed in 1905, and these substances were made illegal. That’s why I’m confused as to why it’s still around if other equally popular drugs are banned. Also I didn’t mean overnight, I just meant after so long why it’s still legal.

1
KatastropheKraut•

$$$

1
PolluxCaesarOP•

Why isn’t crack, heroine, meth, etc legal then if they could tax that and make tons of money?

3
[deleted]•

[deleted]

1
PolluxCaesarOP•

https://www.smithsonianmag.com/history/inside-story-americas-19th-century-opiate-addiction-180967673/

The pure food and drug act was in 1905, opioids has a longstanding presence in western culture, starting with the british who absolutely loved the stuff. Not to mention marijuana has almost as big of a history with humans as alcohol. I do t want any of these things to be legal, but it confuses me where they draw the line.

1
PhilosophyBlue•

Because long term use of these substances are proven to have large numbers of social reprocussions, often make people less willing to work if used consistently, and cause health issues. Not that alcohol and tobacco don't, but they do it to a lesser extent. They could legalize them for regulation purposes (making possession and use legal, while still prosecuting for distribution, as well as providing pure medically supervised doses for addicts to prevent overdoses, gang violence, and street crime), which is a super awesome thing but it doesn't make them any money. Their decisions are made based on how they can cater to the wants of the people - only cases where they can also make money of course - while still maintaining control.

1
PolluxCaesarOP•

Again to approve them for recreational use they could tax it and slap a label on it saying “this is harmful” and they would make tons of money off it.

The other part makes sense though

1
PhilosophyBlue•

My main reason why they wouldn't is because people on those drugs aren't good workers and so legalizing them recreationally (which isn't what I described) would do the government more harm than good.

1
KatastropheKraut•

it can't be properly regulated.

1
RipInPepz•

Because they don’t have billion dollar corporations to lobby for them. That’s really all it boils down to.

1
Teaiayummi•

Had a huge industry to lobby for it when the drug war in the United States was getting heated. In addition, that industry was able to use their wealth and power to try and hide the medical risks. This is something pot doesn't have (yet). Coke, heroin, etc

1
PolluxCaesarOP•

Finally a comment that makes sense

2
onionprincess•

Unlike smoking opium and marijuana.. tobacco doesn't get you high.

1
uss_skipjack•

It does, just not as much.

Otherwise people wouldn’t get addicted to them.

1
uss_skipjack•

Pretty much because it’s been around for so long now, lots more people use it than more intense drugs, and while it will certainly kill you, it’s not like you can overdose and die from the first time taking it.

1