Adding a surprise cat to a tenancy agreement

I want to surprise my lady with a cat for her birthday, but her building doesn't allow pets.

I am aware that it's possible to get a landlord to agree to a pet, along with conditions such as an extra cleaning deposit etc.

My question is, can I make these agreements without my girlfriends knowledge (pay the deposit myself, and so on) or does the agreement have to be a modification of the current contract between her and her landlord?

I really want this to be a surprise, and the effect is kind of lost if she has to sign a bunch of paperwork beforehand.

Posted Aug 7, 2018, 6:51 PM UTC

17
fsv•

Not going to attempt to give legal advice, but I’d really not recommend a surprise pet as a present. Even a cat is a big commitment lasting up to 20 years or so.

Unless you’ve already agreed that getting a cat would be a good idea and thought through the practicalities, this is a really bad idea .

17
barnfodderOP•

She's fully committed to the idea of getting a cat, she's had them before and loves them.

The only obstacle is the landlord, and my girl is too afraid of being told no pets full stop to approach them herself. I reckon that if I make the approach and get told no, she doesn't get the disappointment.

5
fsv•

That’s OK then - I’m really glad you have that covered :)

3
psyjg8•

An interesting situation, but since you are not a named party, strictly speaking, you can't make the variation in terms of the contract for her, but you can go ahead, and so long as the landlord agrees, and you get agreement from your partner after the fact, it will then be fine, as you will have been seen to be acting as a messenger/mediator, if you can prove on balance (i.e. you have in messages/writing) in a court both parties agreed to the change.

3
barnfodderOP•

That's what I'm thinking; talk the landlord into it, give gf the cat, then she can sign the agreement once she's stopped "squeeeeeee"ing.

1
psyjg8•

Well, let's take a hypothetical court situation and see how it might play out.

The landlord falls out with your partner for whatever reason and decides this is a perfect way of getting back at her so takes her to court for breach of contract.

Your partner then can provide any emails/messages from the landlord agreeing with you that she can have the cat, and any messages between you and her also agreeing. This would quash the breach claim immediately, in my view.

In short, yeah, what you suggest works fine.

1
AutoModeratorMOD•

To Posters Reddit is not a substitute for a qualified Solicitor. Please only use responses as guidelines to better prepare yourself for when you meet with a Solicitor or qualified legal advisor. Any advice is academic in nature and should not be relied upon.

If you have a legal problem, you should consult a qualified solicitor. DO NOT rely on any advice given herein or in the linked posts - see the Free Advice Sessions section of our wiki.

To Readers/ Commenters

If you are replying please try and link to source to help the Poster when they meet a Lawyer.

If you feel someones advice is wrong cite sources as to why.

Please keep in mind the [Rules] (https://www.reddit.com/r/LegalAdviceUK/about/rules/)

I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.

1