Can large-scale systemic change only occur when absolutely necessary?
Hello everyone. I recently started reading into anarchism, and the question that came to mind is whether the current, or any, system can truly be replaced as a result of a shift in popular sentiment, or does revolution or large-scale reform only occur as a result of technological progress and necessity.
What brings me to this is that, as I see it, historically major revolutions only occurred as a result of the present ideology (feudalism, capitalism, communism) either becoming anachronistic with technological or demographic realities, and/or major calamities (war, starvation, etc). The French Revolution, a transition from feudalism to republicanism, occurred as a result of a combination of severe economic crisis and the feudal system being hopelessly outdated considering the rise of the middle class. Similarly, the February Revolution in Russia occurred due to mass starvation and suffering as a result of the increasingly hopeless war effort, combined, again, with the largely feudal system being hopelessly outdated.
As I see it, the current capitalist system has two main challenges to overcome. One is the increasing amount of automation, the other is climate change. Increasing automation will continue to drive people out of jobs, and the system will struggle to accommodate these newly unemployed masses, with climate change only making things worse by forcing people closer to the equator to migrate away from these newly inhospitable areas, further straining the economy.
Currently, however, neither of these problems are significant enough to warrant a full-scale overthrow of the present system. No first-world nations are suffering from major starvation or conflict. Thus, is it even possible to replace the current system before it's "too late," or will there only be meaningful change when it is absolutely and immediately necessary, as has been the historical precedent. If so, is there any real point to activism or insurrection that goes beyond small gains in terms of worker's rights?
I hope my question was written clearly enough, if not I will clarify any details in the comments.
Posted Aug 7, 2018, 7:08 PM UTC
I've had your same concern recently. But I think you're missing something from your equation. Automation and cheap products are possible also because of corporations moving their productions abroad, in countries where dignity is not considered and people treated like slaves